I don't know why Perry would use his role right now with Ari. Seems weird but I doubt that Perry's role is mafia just cause it doesn't really seem like it would be. Ari's claim seems like a pretty solid claim. To me it seems like Ari's role would be a townie role because if it were a mafia role and they used it on one town member it doesn't really make any difference since there are like triple the amount of town then there are mafia. But if it were a town role and you hit the right person with it which would be mafia then it increases the chance of lynching mafia which gets pretty hard at some points to lynch mafia. So if they are both town then I'd rather lynch Perry just because he has no more valuable role wise if thats a one time thing but the thing is we can't prove that Ari is town so lynching him is probably a better choice but idk yet.

Ari still could be lying and the person who actually did do that to Vic could just not wanna speak up.

Buffy @ 9/12/2013 19:49

but why would perry do that unless he knows something about ari?

I honestly think it was just a dumb move by Perry because he couldn't really know something about Ari because his role is obviously the lynch thing, its not he could have gotten any info on him from last night so it doesn't make sense to why he did it really.

I feel like Jeff has really just avoided most arguments said against him and just responded to the little joking parts of an argument towards him. This is very tough though because I feel like Panda would be a better lynch but I'm afraid Ari is mafia and I'm just being tricked into believing that he is town

Wouldnt a tie be a no lynch? If so then no because thats the worst thing we can do.

Shawn @ 9/12/2013 21:24

Wouldnt a tie be a no lynch? If so then no because thats the worst thing we can do.

when the choice is to lynch someone you think is town or to no lynch i think a no lynch can be the best outcome. the fact that its very early in the game so were not close to scum getting majority helps, as does the early death of 3rd party cult/SKer.[/QUOTE]


We don't know that these 2 people are both town for sure so a no lynch is not a good idea. One of them could easily be mafia as much as they can be town.

Woops