Zach, buddy, if you would have killed brian N8, like you wanted to, the good guys would have won. Trust your instinct, and always, always kill if you got it.

:)

Sorry mafia buddies, I tried to finish it off. I almost had it had I not screwed up the opening of today. I should have come out guns blazing at Zersch, and said I sent him to Zach. That was my mistake. I lost track of how many people were left when I posted at the start of the day.

Good game Maddie (and Vic, I guess). Tip for next time, cut down on the hidden text, especially the ones that mod-confirm, mod-clear, or mod-condemn (sorry buffy) people. It's hard enough to win as Mafia or SK, but when you clear townies and out SK with hidden text, it makes it even harder.

Darren Sanders @ 11/5/2017 0:23

"DS never does anything smart, so no big surprise there." Blocked Mafia turncoat n1, lynched mafia curtis d1 and called him out as scum on d2, and was in the process of blocking Timmah n3 until I realized that sock would thoroughly enjoy seeing my dick but of course, I didnt do anything smart.

I think that was a quote of mine. If so, you were town and I was mafia. How else do I justify killing you so coldly? :)

Your insistence on outting roles and pushing the obvious vig gave me an easy out to claim my role and kill an extra townie all in one. You almost allowed us to win the game, so I guess, thank you for being you.

Zersch @ 11/5/2017 0:30

spindoctor02 @ 11/5/2017 1:25 I almost had it had I not screwed up the opening of today. I should have come out guns blazing at Zersch, and said I sent him to Zach. I was sure that's what you were going to do, and I feel like Brian would have sided with you if you had.

That was my plan, had Zach picked to kill last night (he'd have killed Josh, btw), as it would have been 2v1, and brian was clear, and I could claim you did the killing. I just frantically missed that the plan still would have worked with 4, as I'd have gotten you lynched, then killed one tonight and won. That's what I get for playing on my phone while walking to my car after work.

Darren Sanders @ 11/5/2017 0:33

also props to Big Dyl for that Primate snipe

Un-fucking-believeable. Josh, the Town Nurse, is the easy lynch, and then Dylan steps up and takes out our roleblocker or would have taken out the GF.

If we didn't have bad luck, we wouldn't have had any luck at all...

Oh, and Zersch, I didn't redirect Vlady to you N2. I sent him to Primate. Merc scanned him N1, found out he was looking for 'Donny', and we sent him N2 to Primate, so he could join us.

I had to keep claiming I sent him to you (which didn't make any sense), because that's what Vlady claimed happened before he died.

Maddie @ 10/5/2017 23:46

It was so frustrating to watch Zach and Zersch both bring up the idea of a universal back up for so long but never act on it.

I about hit the floor when Zersch mentioned this the first time, since it was a role that was used in the previous game, so people were still thinking it was a possibility.

I should have just made up a redirect claim from N1, but when I had to claim, there were still enough PRs out there to possibly shoot a hole in any set of claims I would have made.

Josh @ 11/5/2017 0:40

spindoctor02 @ 11/5/2017 0:33 Zersch @ 11/5/2017 0:30 spindoctor02 @ 11/5/2017 1:25 I almost had it had I not screwed up the opening of today. I should have come out guns blazing at Zersch, and said I sent him to Zach. I was sure that's what you were going to do, and I feel like Brian would have sided with you if you had. That was my plan, had Zach picked to kill last night (he'd have killed Josh, btw), as it would have been 2v1, and brian was clear, and I could claim you did the killing. I just frantically missed that the plan still would have worked with 4, as I'd have gotten you lynched, then killed one tonight and won. That's what I get for playing on my phone while walking to my car after work. I saved myself that night so I would have seen I got hit and realized you redirected HIM

I didn't think nurse's could self-protect.

MADDIE...you got some 'splainin to do...

Just finished reading through the graveyard. Man, the town hate was strong with me. The fact that I got away with it for so long was awesome. Mafia never should have had a chance to win, and if I hadn't fucked it up the last day, we would have.

Lesson for some: don't take things said in-game personally. Sometimes you have to play a character in order to advance your win condition. I had to play up a dislike for DS, to make it look possible that a town redirector would choose to get the town roleblocker killed. And you guys bought it.

ZacharyB @ 12/5/2017 9:49

wouldve found the GF if you didn't block me!

Yeah, but you wouldn't have killed him.

:P