Only one death?

ZacharyB @ 8/5/2017 20:13

yeah, I opted to no kill because I don't have a good idea who scum is atm. I was going to shoot brian because he's the last of the sort of non verifiable roles, but he gives me town vibes if I'm being honest.

Primate would disagree, but it makes sense to me.

It sure looks like most people have good town vibes at this point, which makes it even harder to figure out. If I had to lean in one direction, I'd look at the people with passive roles that wouldn't have any issue passing on their action to kill.

Suspense: 9/10

Execution: 2/10

Dylan @ 8/5/2017 21:22

You are a poop

Language this strong will not be tolerated.

Zersch @ 8/5/2017 21:24

I guess you all missed where I said "you did good, kid". It takes years to perfect dialogue like that.

ZacharyB @ 8/5/2017 21:38

spin who'd u redirect

I redirected Josh, but I'd rather not say to where, in case he can't do back-to-back.

spindoctor02 @ 8/5/2017 21:45

ZacharyB @ 8/5/2017 21:38 spin who'd u redirect I redirected Josh, but I'd rather not say to where, in case he can't do back-to-back.

His target didn't die, so either he wasn't the killer or he is a nurse.

Dylan @ 8/5/2017 21:54

who have you redirected this game? Have you redirected myself or Zersch

I don't have the patience to look it up on my phone right now, but I've posted every person over the last 3-4 day phases.

I'm at my computer now.

N1: Nobody -- didn't have a good read on anything as I was super busy, and didn't want to complicate things too early in the game.
N2: Vlady to Zersch -- don't recall my thinking on this, tbh
N3: Brian to Timmah -- didn't have strong pro-town reads on either of you, so figured I'd try to keep potential mafia away from town and send them to possible scum
N4: Ahoda to Dylan -- again, picked people I didn't have strong pro-town reads on
N5: Zach to DS -- DS was actively playing against his win condition by outting the Vig and then trying to lead a lynch train on him. it's also always fun to kill DS
N6: Angi to Ahoda -- the ghoul claim sounded like it could possibly be 3rd party, plus sending Angi to Ahoda just sounded like the nice thing to do
N7: Brian to Zersch -- Zersch wanted to get some memes, plus if brian was a killer, then he'd take out a claimed townie who was essentially vanilla at that point
N8: Josh to ???? -- either josh was scum and would kill the person he visited and I'd know it, or josh was nurse/doctor and would protect that person while not telling mafia who they protected, in case he can't do the same person two nights in a row

Zersch @ 8/5/2017 22:43

Okay, well if you redirected Josh as well as Brian and the person you redirected them to didn't die, I don't want to lynch either of them. I am Inventor, do not lynch me. Zach has to be the Vigilante. That leaves Dylan and you. Big Dyl... Little Dyl all along?????

You got brian's meme N7, so I couldn't have been the killer. Plus, that whole Mafia Redirector being dead a while ago thing.

Zersch @ 8/5/2017 22:53

Well we don't know for a fact that the last Mafia couldn't both use their ability AND kill. Seems like games go back and forth on that rule the most. But yeah, your last point is legit.

Looking back, I bet Merc was the designated killer towards the end, as his claimed investigations didn't seem to make any sense.

Ok guys, lets all settle down and not all post at the same time. I can't keep up.

Dylan @ 9/5/2017 7:13

Then the question becomes if spin redirects them which role gets redirected? I still think that clears Brian/Josh? Spin could still be doing both and Zersch currently has no role to do anything else

It's pretty clear which role gets redirected. When I sent Brian to Zersch, Zersch got a meme. It's not hard to follow.

Oh, and if that isn't proof enough, when I sent Zach to DS, he got dead.