Is it still Day 9, or did you guys rush the hammer?

Note: I've got about 5 minutes now, and then I'll be gone until late tonight (PT), as I'm flying across the country for a conference starting tomorrow morning.

I'll make sure to check in when I get there tonight and try to catch up (if it isn't already locked, like last night).

My "drive-by, could probably be wrong" scum list would go like this right now:
Note: I haven't had a chance to look at voting records, etc. yet, these are just gut feels.

Most Scum

Herm - I just can't get the Anti-town scan out of my head. It's like a scab...you just want to pick it and cant stop messing with it until you pull it off.
Curtis - Playing a very smart game, and I could easily see all this work leading to driving the town bus, when actually scum.
Vic - I buy the hider claim somewhat, but it'd be easy as scum, with no active trackers/watchers, to claim a role like that, when you already know who townies are, especially when he "cleared it up with the mod" that he could also hide behind cult and not die. Actually, now that I type that out, Curtis and Vic are tied for me at scum slot #2
Angi - I just don't see that role being part of the mafia, especially if the mafia only has 1 person left. Just not enough abilities to offset having a 1-time only vote (per day).
JC - I'm Town Bulletproof, so obviously I'm the most town one of us all. ldo

Most Town

Herm @ 27/1/2016 11:12

It is Day 10 right now.

Vic @ 27/1/2016 14:35

I'm waiting to hear from JC and Angi

What exactly are you waiting to hear? I threw my thoughts out earlier, and there is no way I'm going back to try to find quotes and vote counts while on shitty airport free wifi and my phone.

We should have lynched Herm yesterday to remove that variable, but you guys speed hammered Ari. Now, we are at MYLO potentially (if 2 Mafia left), and the Miller claim is still overshadowing everything.

Curtis @ 27/1/2016 15:14

JC @ 27/1/2016 16:06 We should have lynched Herm yesterday to remove that variable, but you guys speed hammered Ari. Now, we are at MYLO potentially (if 2 Mafia left), and the Miller claim is still overshadowing everything. That was HERM! His hammer was sketchy. He says he didn't see that I voted Ari, but Christian posted two updates showing my vote on Ari on a page that Herm was posting on and around during. I think he wanted to end discussion before it swayed back to him

Herm was only 1 of 4 votes on Ari. Anyone on that lynch train is scummy to me for going so fast.

Planes a boarding. See you guys later on. Try not to fuck it up in the meantime.

I'd like to dedicate our current clusterfuck to Badger and his amazing skill at killing townies.

So, we have a bulletproof, hider, Miller, weak voter, and vanilla. What a collection of super useful roles, and the perfect claims for scum to hide amongst. This is exactly why we needed to get rid of the Miller yesterday and not let Curtis lead us into a quick lynching. The way he drove that train gives me a bad scum vibe, and then how Vic, Angi, and Herm followed so quickly also looks shady as fuck.

We put ourselves into this situation, and now we have to live with it.

If there is only 1 scum left, the play needs to be lynch Herm. At worst its 2v1 tomorrow and we get to do this all over again.

If there are 2 scum left, we're pretty much screwed.

Just remembering the claims and when they happened, I lean towards only 1 scum left.

If forced to vote right now, I'd vote Herm, but Curtis is a real close 2nd.

And now it's time for plane #2. Be back late tonight.

Ok, caught up, and see we aren't any closer to a decision now than we were earlier.

In any future games, if someone claims Miller, I'm voting them everyday until they are lynched or killed, because its screwing with us hardcore right now.

Vic @ 27/1/2016 23:41

JC, how much more confident are you about lynching Herm than you are Curtis?

Curtis is at least fighting for his life by working hard and providing a lot of information. Herm just seems resigned to being lynched, and not really trying to figure stuff out.

While I put the chances of Curtis just playing all of us with this effort pretty high, I just couldn't stand if we lost because we let scum slide by with a miller claim all game.

I'm not going to be around at all tomorrow, so I'm ok lynching Herm right now and rolling the dice.

Curtis @ 27/1/2016 23:46

Are people gonna be around tomorrow morning leading up to deadline? Should we hold off on voting then?

I might have the ability to check in briefly in the morning, but I'll be in meetings all day, so I won't be around much at all. I'd rather put my vote in tonight, as unless someone volunteers that they are scum, I'm not sure I'd change my vote between now and then.

Herm @ 27/1/2016 23:50

As long as no one lynches anyone until then we should be able to figure something out not long before the deadline.

You got some new magical information you are holding back and not sharing? Because it really looks like you are about 5 minutes from being lynched, and you seem pretty casual about it, and knowing people won't be around, have no problem suggesting we wait to lynch until later.

See what happens when you rush?

I said I'd check back in before deadline, but no, lets lynch Angi.

Bad game town, good game Mafia, meh game cult.

Christian, I'm still waiting to find out what signing up for the Walker Nest team meant.

Curtis @ 28/1/2016 10:33

Ryan Grant @ 28/1/2016 11:28 Who gets LVP? Wait what Curtis Badger Titan (rob) lol how can you make the argument that I'm LVP. I WAS A HERO MAN! I had Herm and Vic pegged for some of their bullshit all day today and got the others to agree on at least Herm for now by fighting to prove my innocence. I lynched Angi because I absolutely had to to get her vote. Before this ending I nailed all scum every day. What a very selective memory you have!

On the other hand, the lynch on Ari sealed the fate of the town. We HAD to lynch Herm that day, and you guys sped through it way too quickly. Up to that day, Town was still in control. After that, we were at the mercy of the roles we had left, and they didn't work out to take us to victory.