I'm not cult. I'll put that out there right now.

I'm not sure we are looking at a poisoner, per se. What if Badger has some sore of protection, that delayed the kill from the night he was attacked until the end of the next day? I know nothing popped up in his writeup, but I've seen (and used) the Bleeder role/ability in previous games.

Hasn't Brian also mentioned that he missed night actions earlier in the game? If he is the cult recruiter, this could be good news for the town, as it's less possible cult members roaming around.

Just putting this out there...

Badger, you are a terrible Town Vig. Thanks for killing all those townies.

/soapbox

Curtis @ 23/1/2016 18:39

JC @ 23/1/2016 19:37 I'm not cult. I'll put that out there right now. I'm not sure we are looking at a poisoner, per se. What if Badger has some sore of protection, that delayed the kill from the night he was attacked until the end of the next day? I know nothing popped up in his writeup, but I've seen (and used) the Bleeder role/ability in previous games. What night would he have been attacked? We would've had a missing kill that night but everything's been consistent

My bad. I thought Badger was the person listed as the one who was attacked to open Day 6. It was Bryce. Forget that whole part from my previous post.

:merc:

Curtis @ 23/1/2016 19:46

LET'S TAKE A LOOK! Ryan/Titan/Miko/Dadd/Jay/Wikey were lynched. The first two Town, the next four Mafia. Here's who (alive) voted on those trains in the order that they voted: Ryan: No one alive on the train Titan: Vernon* (vote stolen) Miko: Herm, Curtis, Vic, Bryce, JC Dadd: Ari, Bryce, Herm, Curtis, Angi, Vic, Vernon Jay: Vic, Curtis, Herm, 317, Bryce Wikey: JC, Vic, Ari, Brian, Curtis, Bryce CURT: 4/4 BRYCE: 4/4 VIC: 4/4 HERM: 3/4 ARI: 2/4 JC: 2/4 BRIAN: 1/4 317: 1/4 ANGI: 1/4 VERN: 1/4

Useful, but it's discounting the people who were on the Wikey train the day that Jay was lynched. Shouldn't we (or at least me) get half credit there? Come to think of it, I was on the Wikey train the day Dadd was lynched too. Hot damn, I've been on scum all game!

Curtis @ 23/1/2016 20:28

I wanna hit the leader so bad tho. I'd love to focus on Mafia or maybe JC because of the Timmah scan, but Leader seems like priority to me today for sure. There's ten of us left, Cult has had six days to recruit. They could be really big and very possibly on the verge of winning. THAT SUCKS!!!!!

So, because Timmah visited me, when he was maybe cult, maybe not cult, I'm now automatically cult? I don't follow the logic. There are plenty of people who have claimed town roles, still alive in the game, that would make much better recruits than myself.

If you lynch me, town will be down a useful role that will prove its purpose eventually (I hope). I'd also like to live long enough to find out if joining the Walker Nest team actually does anything.

Herm @ 23/1/2016 20:47

JC, who are your prime suspects for Cult Leader? I think this culprit is our prime target today.

Mafia Herm would love to get rid of the Cult, wouldn't you?

Vic @ 23/1/2016 22:25

Wait why can't JC be Cult?

Because I say so, duh.

Vern For Mod 2016 @ 23/1/2016 21:36

I am very forgetful of a lot of information and basically forgot JC was in the game as an example of that- but I'm going to give this a go. I think Herm is cult leader. I think im317 is Mafia. I think Ari is town. I think Vic is cult. I think Curtis is an asshole. I think JC is..... Town? Based on the Timmah scan thing if that's real? I didn't look into it myself yet. I think Brian is telling the truth about protecting Bryce and is town. I think Bryce is cult. I think he is playing a great game and the information he gave us helped us kill Mafia so that is something he would want as cult. I think Angi is dumb as fuck and town I know I am town.

I was the most vocal one in support of your nomination for leader, and you can't even remember I'm playing?

:(

Well, that's ok, I can barely remember that I'm playing too.

Bryce @ 23/1/2016 22:27

I think JC is cult but I don't think he's cult leader who should be our primary concern for this lynch.

I almost wish I was cult, because then I'd have more of a clue what's going on right now.

If I was to lynch right now, I'm lynching Herm. That Miller claim still doesn't sit right with me, and now that we know cult exists, he could easily be the cult leader.

And before Herm comes in and tells us all that Cult Leaders never scan Anti-town, they do, and have before, so it's not a absolute certainty. Especially if Patrick's investigations were more along the lines of Town/Not Town.

itsbrianyay @ 23/1/2016 22:34

if we were both cult, why would he expose me as visiting timmah?

To set up your Town JOAT claim, duh.

There is no way I am cult leader. You really think, if I was cult leader, I'd have Timmah (whom I've already recruited, based on your claim), visit me at night to clear me as town, when everybody already says Cult Leader would scan town anyways? What, I just knew Timmah would be tracked?

Are you serious? I know I'm not following along all that closely, but there is 0% chance of me being Cult Leader.

Vic @ 24/1/2016 12:46

I don't see why Cult Timmah would scan Cult Leader JC if he knew his alignment. I doubt JC is the leader but I think there is a high probability of him being Cult

Your blinders are strong. It's almost like you took over driving the tunneling machine after Timmah was knocked off.

Vic @ 24/1/2016 12:49

Ok I literally haven't been tunneling you at all lol BUT really anyone could be Cult in my opinion, I just think because of the scan from a Cultist he ABSOLUTELY had to have reported that he got an innocent scan on you to whoever the leader is, making you an easy person to recruit

I really think the only reason anyone suspects me of cult is because Timmah visited me right before he died. If he visits anyone else, nobody even bats an eye that I'm cult. It's the problem of recency. Once you get beyond that, you'll see your arguments make no sense.

Plus, there are other people (bryce, herm, angi) who would make much more valuable recruits right now, because nobody is questioning their "town-ness". Everybody is questioning mine after Timmah's flip, so why again would I make the "best recruit"?

Curtis @ 24/1/2016 13:08

"NIGHT 1: i watched curtis because I figured he'd be prime watcher material (it's actually what i had planned to do N1 of that game i actually WAS watcher but you dumb shits lynched me d1). shockingly no one visited him." ALTHOUGH, how could Cult Leader Brian make this claim if he was lying? Anyone could've said hey one problem JACKASS I visited Curtis N1 and then Brian's claim goes to shit

Unless there is a Town Watcher out there who hasn't done anything useful yet, it's actually an easy claim to make. The Tracker (Bryce) already laid out his claims, and the Town Roleblocker and Town Motion Detector are already dead, so who would be left to counter his claim?