How was there three kills last night?

Rodney, are you scum?

I killed Timmah, but who killed the other two?

If it's Mafia vs. SK vs. Town, I can't win. Great.

At least I went 3/3 on killing mafia at night (im317, mittens, timmah).

Spin @ 11/8/2021 11:54

If it's Mafia vs. SK vs. Town, I can't win. Great. At least I went 3/3 on killing mafia at night (im317, mittens, timmah).

But if there is mafia left, it has to be rodney, but that would mean the original switch is mafia, as we haven't found the original switch yet. It makes no sense for mafia to have that role, with the other roles that have been revealed.

So, if that is the case, how did Ahoda get two kills last night, and why wasn't one of them me?

Rodney @ 11/8/2021 12:02

Spin killed Timmah Ahoda and Timmah killed the two town YW for the orange night to make this possible, now lynch Ahoda and let's wrap it up

I had an orange pill from Moose, so I would have been able to kill no matter what color it was.

Spin @ 11/8/2021 12:03

Rodney @ 11/8/2021 12:02 Spin killed Timmah Ahoda and Timmah killed the two town YW for the orange night to make this possible, now lynch Ahoda and let's wrap it up I had an orange pill from Moose, so I would have been able to kill no matter what color it was.

Or a teal pill. Whichever one would allow me to take an action on a Teal night.

Grumpy Old Man @ 11/8/2021 11:57

Spin @ 11/8/2021 12:56 Spin @ 11/8/2021 11:54 If it's Mafia vs. SK vs. Town, I can't win. Great. At least I went 3/3 on killing mafia at night (im317, mittens, timmah). But if there is mafia left, it has to be rodney, but that would mean the original switch is mafia, as we haven't found the original switch yet. It makes no sense for mafia to have that role, with the other roles that have been revealed. So, if that is the case, how did Ahoda get two kills last night, and why wasn't one of them me? I think mafia got their kill in even though you killed timmah first?

I guess that makes sense, although that's a reason why kill order is important in your Order of Ops. If town goes first and kills mafia, mafia shouldn't get their kill off.

Grumpy Old Man @ 11/8/2021 12:05

Spin @ 11/8/2021 13:03 Rodney @ 11/8/2021 12:02 Spin killed Timmah Ahoda and Timmah killed the two town YW for the orange night to make this possible, now lynch Ahoda and let's wrap it up I had an orange pill from Moose, so I would have been able to kill no matter what color it was. Didn't you get an orange from Jay?

I just double checked. I got an orange pill from jay and then a teal pill from Moose. So I had both (couldn't use the orange one).

Grumpy Old Man @ 11/8/2021 12:06

I agree. So maybe Rodney is scum too. Which is why I asked who would you pick to win if that was the case.

I'd rather you win, if I can't, but I'm really starting to think it's 2 Town vs. 1 SK, so I will be voting you (most likely), but no rush since TT isn't around.

Rodney @ 11/8/2021 12:09

Actually it's not mathematically possible for me to be mafia. That would make 8, which means there would be 7 living mafia on day 3 with 13 alive. Game would have ended

No, because there was a SK still alive. You'd have had to eliminate Ahoda first.

Right now, I'm 100% certain Ahoda is a SK (no way he's mafia after the way the game has played out). I'm also 95% certain Rodney is Town Switch, with the 5% uncertainty tied into TT's interpretation of the Order of Ops being slightly different than standard.

Grumpy Old Man @ 11/8/2021 12:11

Rodney @ 11/8/2021 13:10 Also if I were mafia I would 100% be lynching spin to give Ahoda the co-win The wouldn't be a co win. I'm BP and youre not. I would win out right.

I almost attacked you last night, assuming you'd take out Timmah, but figured it would be a waste because of this.

Grumpy Old Man @ 11/8/2021 12:12

Rodney @ 11/8/2021 13:11 Grumpy Old Man @ 11/8/2021 13:11 Rodney @ 11/8/2021 13:10 Also if I were mafia I would 100% be lynching spin to give Ahoda the co-win The wouldn't be a co win. I'm BP and youre not. I would win out right. Depends on mod no, that would mean mod would end the game when the game would continue. I kill first by order of ops and I kill you.

But I killed Timmah and he apparently also killed one of Jay or Moose.

I don't understand the kills on Jay or Moose by a SK or Mafia at this point in the game.

Rodney @ 11/8/2021 12:09

Actually it's not mathematically possible for me to be mafia. That would make 8, which means there would be 7 living mafia on day 3 with 13 alive. Game would have ended

Only 6 have died (im317, stargate, timmah, mittens, havo, herm). How are you getting there being 8 possible? At best, it's 7.