Who killed TIB? That person needs to come forward right now!

We've now lost the backup switch and the backup-backup switch. Wonder what happens when we lose the switch tonight (as the streak will probably continue).

Deadline is 9 PM ET tomorrow, for those of you who don't want to subtract 1 from what TT posted.

Rodney @ 7/8/2021 18:07

If there was a 6 person mafia team 6 mafia and 1 sk = 35% scum which isn't unreasonable Then we are at lylo and lynching a SK wins the game for mafia. I am concerned that this is a gambit by scum star. What role besides role cop which is a mafia role would be told someone's role exactly? Whether it's true or not this looks bad for star

Explain how we are at lylo in that scenario? We killed im317, meaning at best (in your scenario) there are 5 mafia left. Even if we lynch SK today, it'd likely be 5v7 going into the night. Unless you think they can kill multiple people, I don't see it.

Moose @ 7/8/2021 18:50

Spin @ 7/8/2021 19:39 Rodney @ 7/8/2021 18:07 If there was a 6 person mafia team 6 mafia and 1 sk = 35% scum which isn't unreasonable Then we are at lylo and lynching a SK wins the game for mafia. I am concerned that this is a gambit by scum star. What role besides role cop which is a mafia role would be told someone's role exactly? Whether it's true or not this looks bad for star Explain how we are at lylo in that scenario? We killed im317, meaning at best (in your scenario) there are 5 mafia left. Even if we lynch SK today, it'd likely be 5v7 going into the night. Unless you think they can kill multiple people, I don't see it. What do you mean ‘we’?

I assume mafia didn't kill their own, so the "we" in that statement would be the Town.

TheNavneet @ 7/8/2021 18:50

Spin @ 7/8/2021 15:39 Rodney @ 7/8/2021 18:07 If there was a 6 person mafia team 6 mafia and 1 sk = 35% scum which isn't unreasonable Then we are at lylo and lynching a SK wins the game for mafia. I am concerned that this is a gambit by scum star. What role besides role cop which is a mafia role would be told someone's role exactly? Whether it's true or not this looks bad for star Explain how we are at lylo in that scenario? We killed im317, meaning at best (in your scenario) there are 5 mafia left. Even if we lynch SK today, it'd likely be 5v7 going into the night. Unless you think they can kill multiple people, I don't see it. hypothetically Lamp's daykill coulda ended up in scum hands so its not worth the risk. in general why would u ever want to voluntarily put urself in a situation where the gap between # of mafia and # of town is so tight. this is the first thing u've said this game that i thgt was scummy btw b4 u start whining abt how ur always scum read when its not an alias game ftr i think 6 mafia + 1 SK is a tad high but i suppose not impossible

This isn't a Penner game. Town isn't going to lose on D3.

Moose @ 7/8/2021 18:52

317 could have been Vig OR SK and unless tonight is another orange night, we’ll only get two deaths again. And I know the nights aren’t random and we could get two of the same color nights in a row

Why would a SK kill im317? After yesterday, he'd be an easy lynch target.

I'm shook. Someone thinks I'm likely town.

Rodney @ 7/8/2021 19:09

Spin threw his vote too and moose didn't vote

I was leaning im317 at the end of the day, but was on mobile and didn't want to tie things up by accident. I even commented to Herm that I wish he'd have gone the other direction with his tiebreaking vote.

Grumpy Old Man @ 7/8/2021 19:30

Havo @ 7/8/2021 17:49 Lol. Hodie you ARE a killer. I knew it. Nope, I am not.

So you didn't kill Vern? That's disappointing.

It's almost like people don't even read rules anymore.

Tattooed Tooth @ 7/8/2021 21:55

Penner @ 7/8/2021 23:15 The ghost of Penner floats down… Spoiler + You’re all idiots. Stop lynching me before day 3 when I’m clearly town and dropped great crumbs about my role! I appreciate the PM you sent me about how you wanted to do that. But I would appreciate even more if you had taken my reply in consideration.

Tell me you are trying to get permabanned from playing mafia without telling me you are trying to get permabanned from playing mafia.

Rodney @ 8/8/2021 4:50

SK isn't an alignment

I'd tend to agree with Rod here.

Stargate @ 8/8/2021 12:55

If anyone else had my role this all would've been avoided. I have never not been suspected of being scum this hard as town ever. Every time it's the same. I'm scummy for not shutting my mouth and having opinions and accusing people. But that's just me trying to figure shit out. Mafia it's easy. You have so much to go off of and a team to support you. Town you know nothing. You sus the wrong person, you're dumb. You sus the right person, maybe you get killed for it. Because of how people respond to my suspicions, my strategy as town has always been to be seen as worthwhile to be kept alive by scum at night yet not scummy enough to get lynched. Completely different than how I'd play as mafia. And I think people are well aware of this. Curtis @ 8/8/2021 9:32 Stargate what is your role title, color, night actions, and why you picked those people (I assume just the one night Ahoda same question Role - FBI Agent Color - Orange Night Action - Ahoda Why - Of the two I accused of being scum the other day, his reaction to it made me feel like he wasn't town. I also hoped Nav would be killed at night. I was trying to keep from having to out all this to turn around and be insta killed tonight, but I have nothing to hide. You can color scan me. I'll come up orange. You can role cop me, I'll come up FBI Agent. You can track me next orange night and I'll be where I say I am. The fact that my role exists makes me feel like there is an orange SK and a teal SK or that the SK has a backup. Rodney's insistence that we don't lynch ahoda does make me feel like he could be either a partner, a backup, mafia, or just off in fairy tale land.

I don't understand why you think the SK would be colored, just because you are? That doesn't make sense to me. It makes significantly more sense that TT didn't want a SK found, so he made it so the FBI Agent could only look for the SK on roughly every other night.

Look what happens when you lynch Penner.

Scum im317 is killed at night.
Scum Herm is outted for his bad voting and weak defenses.
Likely scum Ahoda is caught

We should lynch Penner more often!

##Lynch Herm

Having a SK town-side is normally a fun way to liven up the end days in a game. Plus, it keeps the mafia from meeting their win condition without taking him out.