Wow!

Rose's protection of Grim... too obvious or scummy?

Curtis @ 21/2/2013 13:32

I just looked back through Mal's posts. The only thing he said to Rob after Rob claimed alignment cop was asking him who his first scan was. Maybe that means he was suspicious of him. Mal you should've pushed on that!

So Rob's whole getting blocked thing created a few problems. We probably should of figured then something was up.

Well with Rose's obvious protection of Grim (could be reverse psychology though) + the Friendly neighbour thing (if true!), good chance she is town which would back up Mal.

Rob also said Alex was town because of his false scan results.... Again, too obvious if he knew his scum buddies? Perhaps he thought he was safe as we thought he was town before Mal died.

^ Or it could be a brilliant move where we think it is too obvious :P

Also Rob didn't throw Alex under the bus like he did Greenday... Said Greenday was 100% scum while saying Alex was town.

It was almost you/Natalie who dropped the Grim thing after misreading something Rose said? It just disappeared that issue...

http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=782&pagenum=19&pp=15

Why did you reveal it because Rob is scum? He couldn't of told his scum buddies as he was separated...

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 16:36

I still think Rito is the devil I really want to lynch Kiwi for this annoying DO YOU THINK X IS SCUMMY?? YOU DIDN'T ANSWER MY QUESTION SO SCUMMY but the fact that I want to lynch him almost certainly means he is town. I could see scum!Curtis pushing for a less useful memeber of the scumteam to gain favor, especially if some other scum with more valuable skills was in danger, but there were so many targets yesterday that he could have picked literally any other player with less than 10 posts or gone with them... or just hung back and switched the heat off of whoever. But even then, I don't see Curtis sacrificing a roleblocker.

I didn't say "YOU DIDN'T ANSWER MY QUESTION SO SCUMMY" since Grim and Shawn did answer my Q. Grim was scum thoe. What about Ari?

Shawn @ 21/2/2013 18:53

Dylan @ 20/2/2013 18:33 Looool sucks to suck mafia! That just makes you look suspicious, like I think Curtis said yesterday someone coming on and being like ahh man someone from the town died :(. This is basically the same thing.

That person (grim) turned out to be Mafia too.

If I was to metagame I would say Frosti is scummy based on the argument of him jumping around. Normally when town he is much more stubborn. But then your activity is kinda scummy based on the past (not to be a dick or anything u invisible mute :P )

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 19:16

At least you didn't call me a mule

Lol all the times subsequent to the first time I did were a joke. Almost did then but others wouldn't understand your mule ways.

Shawn @ 21/2/2013 19:17

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 0:10 Kiwi @ 20/2/2013 23:57 Shawn @ 21/2/2013 18:53 Dylan @ 20/2/2013 18:33 Looool sucks to suck mafia! That just makes you look suspicious, like I think Curtis said yesterday someone coming on and being like ahh man someone from the town died :(. This is basically the same thing. That person (grim) turned out to be Mafia too. That's not an absolute indicator really. I have a hard time basing a lynch on someone reacting to the night's events. I know I wasn't saying lets lynch him because he said that. I was just pointing it out and hes someone who I think could fly under the radar as mafia but I don't really see too big of things to really believe he is.

Agreed! But Rose is right about basing it off of night reactions.

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 21/2/2013 19:16

JUSTIN DO YOU THINK KIWI IS SCUM?

Maybe I should lynch him to get him talking?

+ you know I am not scum anyway.

Unsure about yourself though Curtis?