Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 2
Day 4
 
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #1: 7th Sep 2020 9:25 PM 
5 kills when 2 town players with kill abilities have already died!?

Also, hilarious that the "most confirmed town player ever to be" was actually unaligned to start.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #2: 7th Sep 2020 9:26 PM 
"Matt, Jackie, Perry, Mal, Cody, Zach

At least 2, probably 3 scum in that list.

1 down. 1-2 of 5 left to go. Anyone want to confess?
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #3: 7th Sep 2020 9:27 PM 
Maddie told me she was smarter than me last night. I wasn't told it was her though.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #4: 7th Sep 2020 9:29 PM 
Timmah @ 7/9/2020 21:26
"Matt, Jackie, Perry, Mal, Cody, Zach

At least 2, probably 3 scum in that list.

1 down. 1-2 of 5 left to go. Anyone want to confess?


I feel better about Matt, Perry and Mal. Worse about Cody and Zach. Based on vote count.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #5: 7th Sep 2020 9:35 PM 
Z claimed town JOAT, with one of those being a kill, right?
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #6: 7th Sep 2020 9:43 PM 
I mean I put out a list of 6 people I thought were likely to be scum, one of them being actual scum in Jackie. Feel like we still have a few scum left on my list too. Stated that I preferred Jackie to be lynched over Zersch. All while missing the majority of the day. Please point out where my bad posts are, Rodney.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #7: 7th Sep 2020 9:46 PM 
IF the town has a dedicated vig, a JOAT with a kill, and the 2 town roles we have seen that could have a kill, THEN the scum have to be WAY overpowered or at least have a lot of firepower or obstructive roles at their disposal.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #8: 7th Sep 2020 9:47 PM 
Oh, well that clears up that mystery.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #9: 7th Sep 2020 9:50 PM 
I seem to recall something yesterday about TIB being cleared, but I never went back and read to find out what that was about.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #10: 8th Sep 2020 10:15 AM 
Oh look, my top 2 scum reads are leading the lynch!

##lynch Cody
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #11: 8th Sep 2020 10:52 AM 
Spin @ 8/9/2020 10:30
Rodney @ 8/9/2020 9:53
I find it interesting that we've got no info on the survival


With everybody checking in today, that makes it most likely the person who survived is scum, otherwise why not claim it?

If that is the case, the person who attacked them, likely targeted scum, and is also not coming forward.

Scum on scum violence?


My best guess is that mafia hit the SK.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #12: 8th Sep 2020 11:11 AM 
Okay so the Jackie/Z vote:

It was tied at 6, and I didn't feel I had the info to weigh in with it that close, so I voted scum Cody instead.

Mal and Perry were already on Jackie, so I feel much better about the 2 of them. They could easily have moved to Z or jumped off of Jackie to save them.

Zach was already on Z. Cody broke the tie to put Z up at 7 votes. Followed quickly by Jackie. Still feel pretty bad about both of them at this point.

Penner reversed and tied it back up by switching to Jackie.

I have been looking for the Matt vote timing here, but he'd stayed out of it so far and actually noted Jackie in his unsure category to this point. BUT Matt did break the tie back to put Jackie in the lead. He didn't have to do that, so maybe feeling much better about him too.

Jackie didn't claim, just said town PR.

im317 unlynched Z, which was a good move after Jackie's non posts. Then Z called Jackie out on going invisible. Seems like that straw broke the camel's back.

After that it was a rush to vote Jackie - Rodney, then Kyle, then Reaper (maybe not because he didn't vote correctly), then Penner back on, then I beat Reaper to the hammer.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #13: 8th Sep 2020 11:16 AM 
So, still think Zach and Cody for scum. Probably adding Reaper back into my scum watchlist, and I could see Kyle as mafia PGO. That's been a role included before.

May need some clarity from IM317 though in light of Zach's claim. For Zach to be legit what he claims we'd then have a full-time town vig, 2 roles that flipped town with a 1-shot kill, Z claiming town Joat with a 1-shot kill, and now an even night town vig.

You'd think with that firepower, 3/4s of the game would need to be like 1-shot BP otherwise the game could've ended 2 days ago with likely mafia and SK kills added in.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #14: 8th Sep 2020 11:56 AM 
We are basing the potential that it wasn't a bus driver on mittens hinting at hiding behind gmaj?
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #15: 8th Sep 2020 11:57 AM 
16. Mittens - Killed Night 2 (Town Hider)
Role -
Role: Town Hider

Three times per game, at night you may hide behind another player. While hiding, you cannot be directly targeted by another player. However if you hide behind a player who is attacked, you will also be attacked.

If you successfully hide twice, you will earn an extra ability.

HIDDEN TEXT: After two successful hides, the cuffs come off and you will be able to use the following ability:
Once per game, at night, though you aren't generally a violent monster, you may attempt to kill another player. You cannot use this action and hide behind someone on the same night.
 
   
11 Users Viewing (11 Guests)
  119. Animafia  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service