Christian @ 17/8/2020 22:17

I mean, he could be an attempted murderer. :P

He also could have just not been sent out for the kill on N1 and was there doing something else.

Anyone else get the feeling that those anonymous votes on Nav were designed to help Nav look better today? The lynch on rose wasn't really in doubt.

I'm looking at that end of day vote count and I see Christian and Matt, who are very unlikely to be mafia given their ALL CAPS GANG claims. Herm was town. I tend to think Ahoda was town. Then you have all of those unknown votes. The FOS one could be town, based on the Nofo vote the day before. Makes me think that mafia may have piled on rose and then threw some anonymous votes on Nav to make him look better.

I tend to believe Jackie's claim with Christian and im317 backing it up, so I'm guessing her train could have been an attempt to save Nofo on D1. Problem is the votes after Nofo's are more or less people I do not suspect, other than the anonymous one.

Matt @ 17/8/2020 22:35

Timmah @ 17/8/2020 23:33 I'm looking at that end of day vote count and I see Christian and Matt, who are very unlikely to be mafia given their ALL CAPS GANG claims. Herm was town. I tend to think Ahoda was town. Then you have all of those unknown votes. The FOS one could be town, based on the Nofo vote the day before. Makes me think that mafia may have piled on rose and then threw some anonymous votes on Nav to make him look better. I tend to believe Jackie's claim with Christian and im317 backing it up, so I'm guessing her train could have been an attempt to save Nofo on D1. Problem is the votes after Nofo's are more or less people I do not suspect, other than the anonymous one. This was my initial thought too, but I think it could have just as easily been a ploy to make Nav look WORSE to goad us into lynching him this round so I'm not keen on actively pursuing it at the moment. I think the Perry lead is the most concrete thing we have atm.

I mean, yeah. There's only one way to find out though!

I agree with you on Perry.

Navvy Doo @ 17/8/2020 22:45

oh good of u to join us again scummah

Thanks! Glad to be back!

So do we have town Curtis who will show up on D5 and suddenly have tons of reads, or do we have scum Curtis who will pop in and out randomly?

Navvy Doo @ 17/8/2020 22:50

just so its clear, the people who think that the ??? votes were used to "make Nav look good" instead of potentially saving Nofo on D1. that's what we're going with right?

It's one of a few working theories, yes.

Lamps @ 18/8/2020 0:43

Timmah @ 18/8/2020 5:33 I'm looking at that end of day vote count and I see Christian and Matt, who are very unlikely to be mafia given their ALL CAPS GANG claims. Herm was town. I tend to think Ahoda was town. Then you have all of those unknown votes. The FOS one could be town, based on the Nofo vote the day before. Makes me think that mafia may have piled on rose and then threw some anonymous votes on Nav to make him look better. I tend to believe Jackie's claim with Christian and im317 backing it up, so I'm guessing her train could have been an attempt to save Nofo on D1. Problem is the votes after Nofo's are more or less people I do not suspect, other than the anonymous one. Timmah @ 18/8/2020 5:50 So do we have town Curtis who will show up on D5 and suddenly have tons of reads, or do we have scum Curtis who will pop in and out randomly? This is rather funny since you basically showed up D3 with 'tons of reads'.

Yeah, I called that one the town Curtis. I missed large chunks of the first 2 days, but I did catch up.

Thisisbourbon @ 18/8/2020 6:37

Timmah @ 17/8/2020 22:24 Anyone else get the feeling that those anonymous votes on Nav were designed to help Nav look better today? The lynch on rose wasn't really in doubt. For all those calling out timmah as possible scum because of his choice of posts, make sure to include this one. The ??? has been well commented on.

Revisionist history much? The ??? had been commented on yes, but not really discussed. It was thoroughly discussed, mostly by Matt and Nav, after I made that post. And I think the interaction between Matt and Nav told us things about both, so you are welcome.

Ahoda Exotic @ 18/8/2020 9:30

Is there any reason to believe Vernon is town?

Vernon has come across pretty town to me. He could be SK, but I can't see him as mafia.

##lynch Mal

I would not lynch: Rodney, Ahoda, boobs, Moose, Jackie, Perry, Vern, Christian, Matt, im317

I've read Lamps more town than scum. JJ has seemed more likely town than scum.

I'm pretty torn on Nav. He came across pretty genuine last night during his discussion with Matt about the ??? votes.

Mal is at the top of my lynch list. Wikey and Kyle too, for just not providing much of anything. Farlig trying to shade me for what I see as something that's not even correct, kind of seems like he's trying to piggy back Lamps and JJ's thoughts on me.

Everyone else is meh. Well, Curtis could be scum I guess but he really never says anything useful until halfway through games.

Ahoda Exotic @ 18/8/2020 9:29

Jamie did you try to kill Herm N1 and got blocked? Then did you have your scummate do an unstoppable kill on him N2?

Boobs has seemed pretty town to me. The only thing I could point to him about would be the late vote on Jackie D1.

JJ @ 18/8/2020 9:45

Is Mal getting lynched because people assume "the munchies " means he's roleblocker?

There's a whole lot of nothing in his posts too

Kyle @ 18/8/2020 12:32

So I'm only up to Page 17, this is kind of hopeless unfortunately. My role can't actually do much of anything so I don't have any useful secret info to contribute, I was however able to scramble the user list between Day 1 and 2 lol. So there's that.

What does that mean?