Nav, go ahead and claim if that’s what you’re going to do anyway. I need to know why you are so keen on Cody as scum before I consider following you on that.

I cannot imagine town gave mittens a kill.

I’m also not that worried that 2 of the least town seeming players left keep trying to say I’m one of their scum reads.

Im way behind, but Lamps gave the kill to mittens? Really Lamps?

Lamps @ 12/8/2019 11:16

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 17:05 Im way behind, but Lamps gave the kill to mittens? Really Lamps? Who would u give it to?

Other than Penner/Farlig, you or Wikey. Or myself.

Mittens @ 12/8/2019 11:27

I think I know what Timmah is after some thought and he's right up next to Penner on my townie list

If you think you know what my role is and it makes you trust me, you certainly don’t know what my role is. Unfortunately (well, unless you are mafia and then I’m glad to keep you guessing).

I think Josh was the right daykill, but it does give scum mittens an out. It does also let us get more info from the subsequent vote count, too, though.

I thought im317 was town early based on how things went down with Curtis. I “think” I am going to stick with that for now.

I am not writing Nav off as being mafia bus driver at all. The only thing he’s got going for him is the Rodney/Curtis bus, but if he’s mafia he could certainly be bussing a scummate with a town player each night and it just happened to backfire that night.

Herm’s motivator claim is... well, I don’t know. I have to think that is a town role, otherwise mafia had too much power. And we know from Farlig that a motivator role exists. But, Herm hasn’t played like town Herm this game. He typically spends more energy trying to figure out things than he has. But, I think I’m giving him a pass based on the claim now that I think this through more.

If Nav is town, I think Cody could still be mafia. I said it then, but Cody was really quick to come out with his claim right after the Nexus happened. I believe that claim should have come out early, but the timing struck me as odd then and still does. As if he knew his action was messed with and he panic claimed. Buffy did something similar with the panic claim of her action not working.

Did Josh say that he got to use his poison twice in a night?

Or was he “motivated” that night?

So we are just waiting on Christian to process this daykill? What is the lynch count in case this just never happens?

Think I am leaning towards a mittens lynch, after the Josh kill is processed.

How many VTs do you think we have with what we know of the setup?

Penner @ 12/8/2019 13:50

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 14:49 Think I am leaning towards a mittens lynch, after the Josh kill is processed. If Mittens is scum, he probably hasn’t actually put in his bomb request yet. So i’d tread lightly with that kind of statement lmao.

I’ll take one for the team.

Will I though?

I also missed that the day doesn’t end until normal time tonight, so I guess I will be back in a couple hours to see if this Josh thing goes down.

Mittens @ 12/8/2019 13:54

Timmah being so focused on me feels so damn scummy. After I claim he will regret that.

Everyone else has claimed except you and me, so why exactly is it scummy for me to think you are scummy?

Mittens @ 12/8/2019 13:58

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 13:57 Will I though? I also missed that the day doesn’t end until normal time tonight, so I guess I will be back in a couple hours to see if this Josh thing goes down. You want to share who you actually think is scum? If you're not the role I think you might be, then you're near the top of my list.

Yeah, I have pretty consistently posted my reads throughout the game. Currently I still have you at the top of my scum reads, as I just said. After that I am torn between the TIB claim and one of Cody or Nav. I had Herm at the very top of my scum reads list until his claim, which I talked through in a post a little bit ago. I also noted my thoughts on im317 at that time.

Mittens @ 12/8/2019 14:00

Timmah @ 12/8/2019 13:59 Mittens @ 12/8/2019 13:54 Timmah being so focused on me feels so damn scummy. After I claim he will regret that. Everyone else has claimed except you and me, so why exactly is it scummy for me to think you are scummy? Because you're not being helpful except for saying you think I'm scum.

That is not true at all.