Honestly, I think the Brian lynch is too easy. Someone tell me again why it's not Merc.

Hold up, so now Stephen's lawyers want to tell me "maybe it's him"?!?

Either you or badger, I don't remember which. You convinced me last day he was not scum when all I wanted to do was lynch him...

N1 - 1 kill (DS by mafia ninja)
N2 - 2 kills (Lamps by Josh? And Curtis by mafia since janitored)
N3 - 2 kills (farlig was obvious mafia kill, and Patrick was mafia and killed by ???)
N4 - 3 kills (Josh who was even night vig, im317, and dr who was a pretty obvious vig target)
N5 - 1 kill (Helios - mafia kill?)
N6 - 2 kills (Sock was a good vig target, but even night vig dead, and Herm survived what should be a mafia attack)
N7 - 2 kills (Boc who Miko claims to have killed, and Herm who seems an obvious mafia kill)
N8 - 2 kills (vlady and an attempt on Badger)

Nights 3 and 7 are the only odd nights with 2 kills. For Miko to be scum, they'd have to be banking that an odd night vig isn't going to check in and counter. So, where did the other N3 kill on mafia Patrick come from.

Now we have Nights 6 and 8 with 2 kills, when the even night vig is dead. Also, Brian has now claimed VT, which removes who I thought was odd night vig. So, this gives us an extra kill on Nights 3, 6, 7, and 8.

If it's a SK, why kill vlady though? Vlady was a lot of the vocal players' suggestion for next lynch, though he did hint that he needed one more night before compiling some data. So, maybe he scared some scum?

I think that remaining scum is among: Merc, Stephen, Miko and Brian. If TIB or Badger is scum I will give major kudos. Same for Angi, though I'll kick myself for backing off when I thought she was scum.

Really, how obvious can it be?

Hard time believing he's SK or third party and came up with all of that. He could be mafia and used ahoda' results. The only thing is how he knows that you visited Badger N5, but was that not public knowledge?

Off by a night? I thought that's when he said he saw you visit badger?

He literally said he saw you visit badger on N5, so what am I missing here?

Off by a night about what?

Could you be any more cryptic?

thisisbad @ 1/6/2017 23:08

Timmah @ 1/6/2017 22:06 Could you be any more cryptic? I could be you or merc discussing your role

How in the world could you not possibly know what my role is, other than your own laziness? I pointed you to 2 specific examples of days that would tell you what my role was, and then you even participated in a discussion about my role this day, or at least some people did

I am not trying to clear anyone here, so I am just suspicious of what you are saying. At this point, if you think it clears Miko, then spell it out because that would have us down to 3. At least hopefully it would.

I didn't say he gave info about you that I didn't already know. I questioned whether his info about you visiting badger was already public knowledge. We can continue to dance around the bush if you want, but what good is that doing us right now?