Are we lynching Stephen now?

BadgerMcBeaver @ 29/5/2017 0:17

As much as I appreciate the scan results Herm, I'm only gonna take them at 50% value right now because of the fact that so 5 mafia have been offed and we still have a GF lurking. I coudl easily get on board with a Primate lynch though. His voting record an posting habits both look bad. I'm not going to place my vote til I hear more though. Timmah, what's your read on Stephen based on? I'm not seeing what you're seeing.

Just the same stuff from the announcement day on Zachary. I've been pretty much unable to follow along since then, though I've tried when I could.

I need a refresher on herm's scans and other things that clear people probably.

Oh I'd been assuming primate was a role stop of some sort. I don't really see it as a scum role, unless it's third party.

Are we thinking it's only mafia GF at this point? Is that why we've limited the options like this?

I'm not mafia or third party. My role is pretty confirmable based on a couple of things I've said about night actions. I'll take a lynch before I claim though, as a matter of principle after the last few games.

TIB is "cleared" for swapping actions that got a mafia killed, right?
Miko is "cleared" for giving us info once?
Badger and a couple of others look "good" for lynching Zachary with only a few votes?

I was hinting at my role, and confirming my promise from the mafia forum in the last game that I will not claim under any circumstances. If you think there are more than 1 mafia and definitely a third party left, would it not make more sense to focus outside Herm's scans?

There are 13 left:

1. Herm has claimed cop
2. TIB swapped a kill to a mafia member - could still be third party

There are 4 clears from Herm's scans: (1 could be GF)
3. Brian
4. Kiwi
5. Merc
6. Timmah

7. Miko claimed a watcher or tracker or something way back and handed us a mafia member (right?) - could still be third party.
8. Primate claimed commuter, and the inability to act on him has been proven twice by suspected town
9. Badger lynched Zach when he didn't have to - could still be third party
10. Vlady lynched Zach when he didn't have to - could still be third party

11. Angi claimed inventor days ago - honestly she could still be mafia or third party

12. Stephen is a complete and total question mark in this list
13. Boc has been inactive, made a random post that he had info for us and then disappeared.

Also, the hinting at my role and saying I was not going to claim was a response to Kiwi asking who hadn't claimed out of a list of about 4 that I am on.

thisisbad @ 29/5/2017 12:03

I feel like I am pulling a DS here and over posting so i'm going to pretend to log out for a bit while really i'll be sitting here refreshing the thread and hoping other people post. I'll leave my list again Town: 12. Badger - 15. Angi 11. TIB 16. Vlady 18. Hern 18. Herm Feel good about: 26. Timmah 25. Miko - 5. Merc - Both feel good about and bad about same time. Lean 3rd party maybe not Mafia 14. Primate Mafia GF: 22. Kiwi - based on being cleared and voting pattern and going back and reading his comments, this is where my guess would be Need research: 20. Stephen - I'll spend my exile reading all his comments. Try to see what others are seeing. Umm: 13. 'N'Brian - 17. Boc - Claimed info then was banished apparantly. I do think there is another Chaos person of course, and i realize it could be someone on my town list. I was going to include more notes, but decided against it

We have a cop clear of both Kiwi and Brian, so one of them is town...

##lynch Boc

It makes sense based on the list I compiled. I could easily go for Stephen instead, though.

@badger:

Wait a sec. I'm not asking for a free pass and there is a BIG GIANT FUCKING DIFFERENCE between process of elimination due to game mechanics (or suspected game mechanics) like cop scans and EVERY FUCKING PERSON IN THE GAME JUST CLAIMING so there's no need to bother playing.

It just seems odd to me that when everyone thinks there is more than just GF, that we should focus only on a list of people that SCANNED FUCKING TOWN. What if herm hasn't hit Gf yet? We gonna spend the next 4 lynches hunting down a Gf that's not on the list? That's literally all I was saying.

Now, having said that it doesn't look like that is the direction we are going, but F'ing A man.

Also, I'm not looking at spins lynch when I say someone could be third party. I'm literally just stating there's a chance that person could be third party. How do you know that anyone aligned with spin knew he was third party anyway? Do you know something I don't?

Seems like I touched a chord here.

thisisbad @ 29/5/2017 17:46

BTW isn't it interesting we had 2 kill attempts last night?

I tried to discuss the 3 kill thing days ago and most people ignored me. It's been fine since we have been whittling down scum but it's still a valid point (unless I missed the explanation)

Mercator @ 29/5/2017 14:37

I'm still half asleep, but imo anyone but Primate today would be a mistake.

So you are convinced he's mafia/third party commuter? Role stopper? Why?

We have an hour and maybe a tie right now...

I don't really understand the primate lynch but I've been wrong before so maybe I just wasn't able to keep up enough to see it for myself.