I'm leaning towards either Jay is GF or wikey and Curtis are both mafia. That was the second no lynch tie, though i didn't realize the day was going to end so early. It usually ends 8-9 CST so the 7 cst deadline threw me off

Hermlappen @ 5/11/2015 21:31

Also, mafia seems to have prioritized killing Dylan over im317 for some reason. It's either because he was more of a threat or mafia just does not fear im317.

Dylan had soft claimed a good role. I actually thought he was soft claiming cop

JC @ 5/11/2015 21:33

im317 @ 5/11/2015 19:50 just to keep from going down that path i want to be clear that i did not kill last night. hopefully we can focus on actually lynching someone today. Why didn't you kill last night? You had no problem killing townies before, what stopped you from trying to hit scum last night?

Wish he'd taken out either Jay or Curtis. That would have at least stopped the inevitable return to exactly where we left off debate

JC @ 5/11/2015 22:13

Hermlappen @ 5/11/2015 21:08 I really hope this game ain't got a SKIT as well. I reckon it's two mafia and maybe 1 third party killer? If you really think there is a 3rd party killer out there, then the only person it could be is im317. We've never had more than 2 kills in a night (not counting the twins). If there is a 3rd party killer, then that makes 3 killing roles (assuming im317 is town vig). There is absolutely no evidence so far for 3 killers.

False - why does everyone forget Brian was poisoned on a night where we all assume Buffy blocked the Mafia kill?

He didn't know if the coal poisoned him or not. Trying to mislead us there?

4 people alive didn't vote to lynch Ari: Curtis, Jay, redster, herm

Jay has asked to be lynched several times. Jay, it may take a role claim but help us make sense of this please

Curtis @ 6/11/2015 9:21

Though the part about your vanilla town phrasing doesn't make sense Jay because we've had some flip which means you'd know how it's phrased anyway

I was just about to say that I believed him because of the phrasing, but then I went and checked to be sure, and yep, we've had several Town Vanilla flips.

With 22 to start, I suppose we could have as many as 6 mafia and a third party - I'd lean to 5 mafia and a third party or maybe 2 though. Anyway we slice it, we're just speculating on the setup though. At the moment we've rid ourselves of 3 mafia, no third party, and we have 10 left.

Alive: (10)
3. curtis - D1 lynched brian; D2 no vote stayed out of ahoda trolling; D3 early lynched rose after Buffy's block claim, then lynched Primate late after having started the Primate wagon early, but only after being called out for it by buffy (Curtis not looking good from D3); D4 no vote (still not looking good with Ari's mafia flip); D5 no vote, but tried to save himself by lynching Jay;

4. wikey - D1 lynched brian after changing from the lynch, FC, at literally the last second; D2 lynched im317 and stayed out of the ahoda tie lynch trolling; D3 originally lynched Buffy and then never noted again while town Primate was railroaded for no reason; D4 lynched Ari and was 3rd on, though it was late in the day; D5 saved Curtis by restarting the Jay train at the end;

8. timmah - is definitely town! - D1 lynched Jay; D2 voted Chris over Buffy b/c thought Buffy was town; D3 lynched rose, who Buffy had blocked; D4 beat the Ari lynch drum all damn day; D5 lynched Cannuck and Redster during the day, didn't vote in the end because I got back online after the early deadline;

10. Schrauben - D1 was first on FC lynch; D2 no vote; D3 no vote; D4 lynched Ari, very late in the day and with no comment on it; D5 on Jay early, but no vote;

12. JC - prolly not mafia (shot mafia Henry, though could have just been personal) - D1 hate lynched Henry; D2 no vote; D3 lynched Primate late after arguing he wanted im317 lynched all day, even arguing that lynching Primate gave us no info; D4 lynched Ari very late in the day; D5 on Dylan early but no vote;

13. im317 - claimed town vig (has only shot townies) - D1 no vote; D2 voted Chris over Buffy, then shot ahoda (who had just trolled and tied the lynch); D3 no vote; D4 on the Ari lynch 2nd; D5 no votes;

14. Jayadamo - claimed town vanilla - D1 lynched FC; D2 no vote; D3 voted Buffy early and never unlynched; D4 no vote; D5 lynched wikey;

15. canuck - claimed town santa (maybe did or maybe didn't poison brian) - D1 lynched Redster; D2 lynched henry; D3 early rose vote, then lynched Herm; D4 slid on the Ari lynch at the last possible minute;

16. Redster - D1 lynched Timmah; D2 no vote; D3 no vote; D4 no vote; D5 lynched scharuben (could be scum distancing?)

17. Herm - D1 started the brian wagon; D2 voted Chris; D3 jumped on the Primate express lynch; D4 no vote, but very active...; D5 lynched Curtis

## lynch Redster

I'm going to be out most of the day