For me suspect number 1 is Canuck - he's just blended in, wouldn't vote Ari u too it was a foregone conclusion, etc... Have a huge raging clue for him being scum

Suspect number 2 is herm. He's not played a town game.

Suspect number 3 is Dylan. Seems like every post is just a question that touches on popular topics but never gives any real insight or commits Andy one way or the other.

As last day ended I looked at the votes and there were some obvious names missing from voting at all. I'm talking active players here: Curtis, herm, and Dylan are chief among those. Rose was as well but we know her allegiance now.

Redster and Jay were also absent but not active at all.

im317 @ 3/11/2015 22:43

i just confirmed that Christian did not forget to tell me i was blocked. im guessing i was redirected in some way.

I don't see how that would end up with you failing in your action. And we were not told that anyone survived a kill attempt.

Mafia killed Buffy Imo. Third party or 317 killed the twins imo.

The big question is what happened to the Mafia kill night2? Night 3 Brian was poisoned so there were actually 2 kills that night, which accounts for perhaps a third party kill. There were 2 kills last night as well and one wasn't 317 if we believe him

## lynch Canuck

Also as I read back over my own posts it's really clear that I need to either start using my laptop or buy a keyboard for my iPad.

I thought it was clear that any redirector was not mafia. Otherwise we'd have seen 317 redirected previously or even Buffy. Trying to float this just makes you look worse...

Oh you mean on night 2? Possibly but then we'd have a town role that knows who didn't kill that night

Jayadamo @ 4/11/2015 1:33

I don't buy IM's Town Vig claim. Wouldn't mafia have killed him by now? If he isn't town Vig I think you can add JC to his team.

Well, they were blocked at least one night it seems, and then it appears they killed the source of the block instead.

I'm going to add to Wikey's list because I don't think it's complete or tells the whole story.

Night 1:

Badger - Killed by Mafia
Angi - Killed by Badger

(1 attack by Mafia)

Night 2:

Ahoda - Killed by im317
Rose - blocked by Buffy

(1 vig attack, no Mafia and not because of the block)

Night 3:

Chris - Killed by im317
brian - poisoned
Ari - blocked by buffy

(1 vig attack, no Mafia?, another form of kill in poison)

Night 4:

Buffy - Killed by ????
Rose/Jeff - Killed by ????

(2 attacks, one by Mafia?)

Dylan @ 3/11/2015 23:36

Quote For me suspect number 1 is Canuck - he's just blended in, wouldn't vote Ari u too it was a foregone conclusion, etc... Have a huge raging clue for him being scum Not sure if this is a typo. A "raging clue". Is that something other than the late Ari vote?

The late Ari vote is a big clue, but it was added to my overall feel for how he'd been playing. I talked about it last day phase before we even got to that point as well. The "raging clue" comment was a joke from South Park, as Wikey already pointed out.

Dylan @ 3/11/2015 20:52

Well looks like everyone so far was telling the truth. Two people died which means (mafia/IM317 (if he is telling the truth). While it is REALLY shady that both people that died had pretty good alabis (especially Buffy), it could possibly also confirm that there is indeed a separate killer other than IM317 (which resulted in Badger's death and one of these deaths).

This is the type of post that makes me suspicious of Dylan. Again, I have never played with him so I do not know if this is his m.o., but im317 claimed town vig, and we know (or we can safely assume) that the mafia has a kill. So, we already knew there were 2 kills out there with the possibility of more given brian's poisoning (which is a kill action, for the record).

Also, Curtis seems to have gone into hiding on us. No posts yesterday that I can recall, liking a post or 2 already today, but no posts.

okay, I see what you are saying and I agree with it. JC may be correct in that it could be some sort of third party JOAT type of role. We've got nothing but speculation at this point though.

a redirection role does not necessarily explain what happened to im317, if I'm thinking through this clearly.

If he was redirected, the only explanation is he was redirected to rose or buffy - probably rose just because the mafia likely wanted buffy out. Otherwise, we should've seen a player survive a kill or im317 should've had notice he was blocked.

Wikey @ 4/11/2015 10:18

Just so we are all on the same page, in most games here, if the mafia have an additional killing role (like a one time unstoppable killer) it can be used the same night as the normal attack. Sometimes there will be a clause, like the unstoppable killer can't go out for both kills, but that's about it. Also, hello Dadd, is this entertaining or wut? :)

The proper greeting is FU Dadd!