Lol there's no way that he would have hid behind me after yesterday and the fact that I have a claim that can't be proven.

Buffy @ 10/5/2016 21:14

So TIB hiding behind someone not town would kill him but why no other kill?

Could be that the mafia attacked TIB in addition to him hiding behind the wrong person.

Eben Etzebeth @ 10/5/2016 21:37

interesting that tib died and nobody else.. I don't know how all the inter workings of that role work. Could the person he hid behind have been protected?

I think we would have received a report that they survived an attack if that was to happen.

Things I'd like to see happen this round:

- Pressure on Mal
- Some sort of meaningful contribution from Rose
- Some sort of explanation from Redster about why he is defending Rose adamantly
- Wikey's analysis on things since I think his role is usually town and he's usually pretty smart in these games

Butttttt chances are that these things will not occur and I'll just end up as a default lynch.

I think at this point it's time that you give some sort of rationale for why we should be blindly trusting your claim that Rose is town. Thisisbad was most likely targeted by mafia with a night attack last night (if it was just that he hid behind the wrong person, we'd have another night attack to account for). But since we have no evidence of a night attack at all, and we know the town roleblocker is dead, the next most likely scenario would be that they attacked the Hider and whiffed. And the two people who he was singling out last round were you and Rose as targets for today.

Also, I find it interesting that your argument is related to the Dadd lynch train when Jamie and I were both part of that fuck up. You'd probably be saying the exact same thing if I was lynched and Jamie survived last round.

Not sure what you expect though with regards to the Jamie vote. I'm not scum and there was only one alternative with what sounded like a questionable claim.

Also of the people on my lynch train that you highlighted as confirmed town, Angi and Eben were actually lynch votes for Jamie, you counted yourself twice, and Rose has basically been inactive. Yes there were town who voted me but you're kinda misrepresentating things.

I do think you actually make a pretty good case for Buffy though.

##lynch Buffy

Ari @ 11/5/2016 9:32

Very interesting Redster. I dont want to roleclaim right now, but I will do it tomorrow. I want to do it tomorrow as I have a plan tonight that might fuck up some stuff for the mafia and I can find out what role Buffy has. Not scanning related though. I would prefer to try the plan out on Buffy, as it seems like she is the roleblocker, and not Badger as I suspect he might have a non-visiting mafia role or a limited-visit mafia role. I think it will work better that way. So that means I would prefer lynching Badger today, who is scum anyways, and I should be able to fuck shit up for the mafia and confirm Redster's suspicion about Buffy. This will also prove my role. Needless to say, if we go with my plan and I am killed tonight, you lynch Buffy.

This idea might work if I was actually scum, but you're just tunneling. Or scum trying to protect scum. One of the two.

Details like what night you investigated Mal and what action you used in Angi could have easily been included in the post to me without taking any extra time. Waiting til you get home to post them sounds like a stall tactic...

Ari @ 11/5/2016 11:44

Timmah @ 11/5/2016 17:20 And, I'm with Canuck, I think Ari is scum and is stalling for both his claim and to get Buffy an extra night, while perhaps taking out another town role. I can see him getting that extra night for the mafia blocker, and then throwing her under the bus tomorrow to get town cred and "confirm" his role claim. What none of that makes any sense. If im scum what longtime benefit do I get? Buffy flips mafia roleblocker and im fucked. Id gain much more from pushing her today for some longtime cred. How can I throw Buffy under the bus when Redster has pretty much ousted her. Cant think of any towny reason for her to visit Angi. I only want to prove my role.

I agree that you don't gain town cred by protecting Buffy if she flips Mafia Roleblocker. But the point about you holding off your claim and getting an extra block is very relevent (especially considering we have a Doc out in the open right now that mafia would want to block).

I find it interesting that you completely ignored that part (and Cannuck's entire post).