I am here now, and should be around until work calls. I am taking a look at the threads from yesterday/today right now and gonna give my thoughts but is there something specific Jamie/Curt?

OK I just gave yesterday's thread a re-read. Here are my thoughts on everyone in the game right now:

Leaning Town

Maddy - She seemed like frustrated town at the end of the day and was actively scum hunting. I don't buy the idea that she just should have known Kat's timezone, I could see how someone would forget that. The only thing that kinda makes me second guess her is that the Nav/SK thing I mentioned yesterday could still have been a slip but I think I buy her explanation.

Curtis - He seemed like he was scum hunting and his reaction to Rodney's targeting of him felt sincere to me. He drew attention to Nav, Tib and 317 at various points through the day. He settled on Tib, which seemed like a reasonable lynch.

Unsure

im317 - Knew what Nav's item was and defended him, but that sounds kind of like a role cop. I have seen more evil role cops than I have seen good role cops so IDK what to make of that. If Nav is scum, I think that 317 is town because I don't think he'd be that brazen defending another scum person. But if Nav is town, then I could see 317 being scum that was trying to get town cred. I feel like I might have a better read on him if we know why he is sus of JJ?

Ahoda - Very little to go off of in either direction.

Timmah - Also not tons to go off of. Said he thought we should be voting for Nav because he survived and then he followed through by voting for Nav. Felt like a reasonable enough vote but also a vote that someone would make if they were trying to stay utr.

Farlig - Had a decent amount of posts but they didn't really feel like they said all that much? The only scum hunting he did was saying that I revealed that I was visited 'too quickly' which was kind of lazy IMO. Especially considering that all I did was say I received something.

JJ - She posted a fair amount and didn't really target people, which is what I'm used to seeing from JJ. I don't know whether that makes me feel like she's town or scum tho. Kind of defended Herm and Nav at different points through the day. Interested to see if more comes to light today with 317.

Leaning Scum

Nav - Even though I didn't get a particularly scummy vibe from him, he did survive a kill and seemed to have some people defending him. That could have been members of a scum team trying to save him.

Jamie - Suspected Herm of being maf yesterday based off vibes. Was against Nav being lynched because he felt it was lazy. If Nav is maf, I could see Jamie maybe being maf lowkey defending him.

Herm - Didn't really seem like he was scum hunting that hard but said he wanted better scum hunt posts from others. Seemed like he kind of wanted to make it a tie when he lynched tib. Makes me feel he could have been aware that the votes were going to get fucked with.

Reaper - Brought up the possibility of a cult, which while possible feels unlikely in a game this small. To me, speculating about a cult usually comes across like mafia trying to appear helpful. Also, the dice rolling thing seems kinda fake to me. He forgot to use it day 1 and day 2 said the roll he got didn't do anything. Day 3 he said it was good but nothing has happened. If it's a rolls are supposed to be done publicly, I would think we'd have something public from Boc that would confirm something about it? Feels off.

Tib - Started out with his vote on Herm, but switched to Reaper shortly after Reaper voted for him. I do agree with Reaper that it seemed kind of like an OMGUS vote. Didn't post much of substance.

jamie @ 5/5/2023 12:39

BadgerMcBeaver @ 5/5/2023 12:04 I am here now, and should be around until work calls. I am taking a look at the threads from yesterday/today right now and gonna give my thoughts but is there something specific Jamie/Curt? did you have anything to do with the vote shenanigans yesterday

No, I did not.

gabagool @ 5/5/2023 14:07

Just a heads up I’m going camping this weekend and will probably lose cell reception tonight

Ohhhhh that's fun, I'm jealous!

You know what, I could get behind a Maddie lynch.

##lynch maddie