So wait, Herm. You think that the game contained an Indian faction who had one person who can impact day votes and one person who can roleblock... and that's their entire faction?

Their win con states that they need to have 50% of the remaining players and also need to eliminate the threats. How would they achieve that with just those two roles?

There's gotta be more to it.

Mads I don't expect you to answer this now but I'm interested to know your scum reads.

As someone who hasn't played for a while, is Reaper the type of player that would go against his own win con?

I can't remember who brought it up but last day phase, but the idea of a Vanilla Recruiter sounds pretty plausible to me right now.

Cody @ 19/2/2021 1:46

Herm. Where’s those great colored voting charts xD

Honestly because you can't quote closed threads, those take a while to make with all the coding. I'll make one in the morning if no one else does because I do have the previous two vote threads done.

Herm @ 19/2/2021 1:48

Unless Badger beats me to it!

I can do it tomorrow if you don't want to, but I've had wine so I'd prolly screw it up if I did it now lol.

Actually I'll try it now but I apologize if it's wrong lol. I'll post a corrected version if I make any mistakes.

OK so I colour coded the lynch trains. Green = Kashmiri, red = Pakistani, blue = Indian.

Day1	+
Farlig (4/9) -- Ahoda, TT, Curtis, Badger Ahoda (2/9) -- Farlig, Lamp Herm (2/9) -- Cody, Rodney Maddie (1/9) -- TIB, Nav TT (1/9) -- Penner Penner (1/9) -- Maddie Rodney (1/9) -- Nav Lamp (1/9) -- Herm Gmaj (0/9) -- Rodney Not voted: Timmah, Gmaj, im317, Reaper

Day 2	+
Penner (6/8) -- Herm, Rodney, Maddie, Gmaj, Cody, im317, TT, Nav im317 (5/8) -- Badger, Reaper, TIB, Nav, Penner, Herm, Penner Lamp (2/8) -- Timmah, Maddie TT (0/8) -- Penner Timmah (0/8) -- Cody, Rodney, Curtis Herm (0/8) -- Penner Rodney (0/8) -- Nav, Curtis Nav (0/8) -- Ahoda Not Voted: Lamp, Curtis

Day 3	+
Reaper (7/7) -- Badger, Rodney, Gmaj, Badger, TIB, TT, Timmah, Reaper, Cody TIB (3/7) -- Herm, Lamp, Reaper, Badger Lamp (0/7) -- Timmah Timmah (0/7) -- Rodney, Rodney, Lamp, Badger TT (0/7) -- Rodney, Lamp Cody (0/7) -- Reaper

I think that's correct?

Oh I missed that 317 and Maddie didnt vote Day 3.

Otherwise its accurate.

Cody @ 19/2/2021 2:24

oh i was mostly kidding LOL. but they can be helpful im struggling with badger bc, his actions genuinely feel v v towny, but for some reason im getting second thoughts, and looking at the voting history im even more so struggling

I know my vote last round wasn't right but at the time I felt like Tib was really having a go on me after I sus'd him and I thought it was an OMGUS situation. I'm still not sure that it wasn't that but I'm undecided on on him for now.

For reference, Tib is one of the only players in this game that I am friends with outside of the game, so when he rejected my apology I got a little heated.

I am still doing my best to scum hunt.

Lamps @ 19/2/2021 2:48

BadgerMcBeaver @ 19/2/2021 6:45 I can't remember who brought it up but last day phase, but the idea of a Vanilla Recruiter sounds pretty plausible to me right now. ... and it happens to be... you? ;)

Umm... no?

I'm not clear what you're referring to?

BadgerMcBeaver @ 19/2/2021 3:00

Lamps @ 19/2/2021 2:48 BadgerMcBeaver @ 19/2/2021 6:45 I can't remember who brought it up but last day phase, but the idea of a Vanilla Recruiter sounds pretty plausible to me right now. ... and it happens to be... you? ;) Umm... no? I'm not clear what you're referring to?

OK I re-read what you said lol. I apologize. Wine is tasty, my bad.

But still no.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 19/2/2021 1:16

So wait, Herm. You think that the game contained an Indian faction who had one person who can impact day votes and one person who can roleblock... and that's their entire faction? Their win con states that they need to have 50% of the remaining players and also need to eliminate the threats. How would they achieve that with just those two roles? There's gotta be more to it.

Could you respond to this post Herm?

Lamps @ 19/2/2021 3:08

If I had to guess, this is where I'm at. 3. Timmah - cult 4. Lamp - town 5. Cody - town 7. Badger - cult 10. im317 - cult? 11. Herm - ? 12. tib - scum 13. Maddie - cult/town, mayyybe scum 14. Rodney - town 16. TT - town

I'm Kashmiri, not cult, but I know that isn't going to persuade you that far.

Honestly, I think cult leader might be Herm because Herm has downplayed the possibility of recruiting. I don't know why you don't have him as a potential option.