Is there any actual info that Timmah is bad or are people just jumping on this?

Also, I received a message last night. So that's a role that's in this game.

Honestly, I think Farlig is really erratic and can be a liability sometimes to town even when he's with us. I feel bad that I lynched him and he flipped as a townie, but I don't think he was a bad day 1 lynch target.

That's fair, I don't think we should be ignoring the train. Votes are literally the only thing we have to go on right now. That was just my thinking.

im317 @ 14/2/2021 23:54

no deaths. would Spin make an all recruiting game? scum factional kill blocked?

How would a mafia game actually work if there weren't kills in night phase? That would take forever.

Curtis @ 14/2/2021 23:21

##Lynch Rodney Going with my gut unless this Timmah thing is serious Rod wanting to vote gmaj and then follow Cody on Herm and then focus on the farlig voters today are three shady paths he’s gone down so far. I don’t TRUST it!

I don't agree with this logic. I think Herm can be a valuable town member but I don't get why it's scummy to vote him, he's good playing as maf too.

Also the lynch train makes sense to look at. We have very little to go on right now.

im317 @ 14/2/2021 23:54

no deaths. would Spin make an all recruiting game? scum factional kill blocked?

Is this a potential scum slip indicating that 317 could be part of a recruiting faction?

I feel like it would be more normal to assume someone figures there was 1 recruiting faction and maf was blocked, than assuming there was 2 with no maf. Unless they were already part of a recruiting faction and were wondering if there was another one.

Rodney @ 15/2/2021 0:12

Hopefully the amatures will put it together soon enough to lynch Timmah today

I'm not opposed to lynching him, but its like 3 hours into the second day.

##lynch im317

Open to other options but I'm putting my vote here for now.

Rodney is kinda a bad day kill target IMO. It seems to me like he's actively trying to scum hunt and right now I'm reading him as town. If he dies and he does turn out to be town then we're losing someone who's actually willing to put himself out there in terms of scum hunting.

It's your daykill Timmah, but I think it's better to hit people who are doing the bare minimum to get by.

How long do you guys think it'll be until Reaper complains that everyone on this forum always thinks he's scum?

Honestly the longer Timmah waits to make a kill, the less time we have to productively discuss the lynch.

I feel like we're gonna end up in one of those last minute lynch situations.

I think it's actually a pretty good lead considering there were no kills last night.

But ultimately, my read on timmah is going to do more with how he handles his daykill than the fact that he was roleblocked last night.

AhrNav @ 15/2/2021 19:10

so as it stands rn Cody is claiming a block on Timmah on a night where we have missing kill(s) Timmah has a "provable" role which he is, presumably, about to use tough one honestly i think i still like a Rodney/317 daykill lynch combo but open to someone flying UTR like Reapher or Hodie as well

Do we have any reason to assume Timmah wasn't gifted his day kill by an inventor or gift giver?