So we assume 317 was not able to submit a kill then?

is a SK considered a faction?

Pen Newton @ 5/9/2020 19:36

I’m just confused why people voted not-Herm yesterday

I believe I joke voted someone yesterday. But then I merged in my Skype survivor game and got distracted and didn’t come back to change it. I did say I would vote Herm, but I didn’t want to get too close to a hammer.

I think there’s 2 or maybe 3 on the herm train. You can look towny lynching him but also seems like a mafia benefit for herm to get lynched.

Might also want to look at who wanted Gmaj day killed. Anyone trying to make it Gmaj over Herm could be sus since Herms black out thing only activated when he was lynched not killed.

Kyle @ 5/9/2020 19:47

Should we just go for IM? I can't find a reason to go for anyone else except Curtis.

IM is at worst a SK. Best the town Vig. Lynching him is not a good idea rn

In fact. Z going back on doing herm and doing Gmaj now looks worse because of Herms lynch ability thing.

But like. Based on vibes I feel very Town on Z

Kyle @ 5/9/2020 20:07

Matt @ 5/9/2020 22:55 playing family feud rn so i am off and on btw ~ wtf does that mean?

I think it means he’s playing Family feud with friends so he will be looking here but not consistently.

Could be wrong tho!

Wasnt Lamps role kind of JOAT-y too though? Granted it wasnt called specifically JOAT but he had 3 separate abilities to use.... not sure im buying this claim

also why wouldnt you use one of them night 1?

Here’s all my sus points with Z.

1. We’ve talked about it a lot but still, daykilling Gmaj over sheen is weird.
2. A JOAT claim when Lamps’ role is Joat-like
3. Having FIVE abilities and not using any
4. A killing ability in one when we seem to have a Town Vig and 2 other roles with a kill

I feel like if 1 or 2 of these happened I’d be like. Ok I think I could believe in him because he DOES give Town vibes. But with all of them together I don’t know if I can really trust that he’s town.

I agree there can be some roles with multiples. But right now we are looking at THREE roles with possible 1-shit killing roles for town (lamps mittens now Z) and then a town Vig? That just seems like too much?

My bad if 317 isn’t Vig. I thought he had said that.

My scum list is probably:

Z
Perry
Zach
Maddie
Farlig

I guess you could throw Jackie/Reaper in there but they're both borderline inactive so like, its hard to place them

Actually wait. one of maddie/perry, I dont think they both can be scum.
Scumreads:
Z
Perry/Maddie
Farlig
Zach

Town reads:
TIB
Rod
Jamie
Penner bc of Rod tho

I suspect perry for the like 'maddie is scum but ill vote jackie over z' I like... GET his 'reasoning' but it feels like something scum would say/do knowing who is town and who is not. Like, he knows maddie is town but hes gonna shade her for the future, but get someone else lynched.

##lynch Zersch