Post #1/45

3 attacks is interesting especially with Lamps flipping a 1-time townsided night killer. could be that one of the attacks was box related

mine was sadly empty

Herm
Matt
Mittens
maybe Penner

^ my suspect pool for today. not necessarily based on actions surrounding the Sock lynch just general weird vibes that I got from them during D1

Post #2/45

Pen Newton @ 3/9/2020 16:10

I was literally the same as I always am, Nav

not REALLY. u beat the inactive drum yet didn't want to vote the inactive Sock. altho Sock flipping town does make me feel slightly better about ur chances of being non-Mafia in the sense that mafia!Penner would have jumped onto not_mafia!Sock easily. so you wouldn't be my top priority today. but there was still some contradiction in the way u behaved during D1

side-note: i had not noticed that i didn't get the box I initially picked. ended up with 26 instead of 6. might be worth looking at who got which v/s which they picked

Post #3/45

Pen Newton @ 3/9/2020 16:19

thenavneet @ 3/9/2020 20:16 Post #2/45 Pen Newton @ 3/9/2020 16:10 I was literally the same as I always am, Nav not REALLY. u beat the inactive drum yet didn't want to vote the inactive Sock. altho Sock flipping town does make me feel slightly better about ur chances of being non-Mafia in the sense that mafia!Penner would have jumped onto not_mafia!Sock easily. so you wouldn't be my top priority today. but there was still some contradiction in the way u behaved during D1 side-note: i had not noticed that i didn't get the box I initially picked. ended up with 26 instead of 6. might be worth looking at who got which v/s which they picked There was zero contradiction. I voted Gmaj, then had to switch when Mal decided to be selfish, and then finally had to land on Sock once Gmaj read his scum forum and decided to vote me out of spite and/or if he thought I was like a day cop or something

i feel like ur only reading half of my post so this will be the last i say of it. i think u acted weird and didn't follow ur own designed meta of voting inactives. but the fact that Sock flipped town actually makes u look slightly better or at least non-mafia. there are other people i'd lynch or even look at before u

Post #4/45

##lynch Herm

not opposed to Mittens or Matt

will be busy for a few hours so you might not hear from me much

Post #5/45

Spin @ 3/9/2020 18:25

Timmah @ 3/9/2020 21:22 Oh goodie I got a day kill. Everyone give me their top scum read asap Penner

timmah u do look glowing tonight. u always do brighten my day just by ur presence

top scum reads in order from scummiest to least
Herm
Matt
Mittens
317/gmaj (feel like theres something there just not sure which way i'd lean right now)

Post #6/45

definitely dont shoot jamie

Post #7/45

Mittens @ 3/9/2020 18:33

thenavneet @ 3/9/2020 21:29 Post #6/45 definitely dont shoot jamie elaborate, you've got plenty of posts to spare

nothing to elaborate i just have a strong town read on jamie based on the tone of his posts (mostly meta reasons)

Post #8/45

Gmaj7 @ 3/9/2020 19:28

thenavneet @ 3/9/2020 21:29 Post #5/45 Spin @ 3/9/2020 18:25 Timmah @ 3/9/2020 21:22 Oh goodie I got a day kill. Everyone give me their top scum read asap Penner timmah u do look glowing tonight. u always do brighten my day just by ur presence top scum reads in order from scummiest to least Herm Matt Mittens 317/gmaj (feel like theres something there just not sure which way i'd lean right now) This hurts after You said I was town at the end of D1 which made me so happy. But I see what you mean.

honestly i still read ur posts themselves as town but 317 seems to be hinting very heavily at info against u. if either of u wanna spell things out that'd be great and then we can shoot Herm and lynch Matt

Post #9/45

also hello again i survived the live night double elimination in the game im playing so im back around if anyone wants to dance with me

Post #10/45

meh i dont feel like a survival is a slam dunk in this case and gmaj really does sound town to me

i guess gmaj said he could prove his role so maybe time for him to do that?

Herm would still be my top daykill choice

Post #11/45

Thisisbad @ 3/9/2020 21:16

What did i miss with Herm? I usually overlook him because in most games if you wanna lynch Herm someone calls you an idiot

i just dont get warm and fuzzy vibes from ol Hermy. admittedly im one of the people who cant read him very correctly and tend to be 50-50 on him. but a lot of others read as much more genuine and relaxed in their posts to me (which is normally a sign of being town on this site since so many ppl hate being scum) whereas Herm's posts have felt a lot like struggling to fill them with any real substance

same with Matt because by now in the last game Matt was writing paragraphs of things going on in the game and also had a few really solid and logical reads about players. i dont see any of it here, not even close

Mittens' posts about sock on D1 seemed dodgy (others pointed this out im just re-stating, not claiming any credit for the Mittens' scumread) one thing that stood out to me was Mittens had a post sorta defending Sock when it was by and large established Sock was being lynched and it stood out to me as a scum member knowing that Sock was gonna flip town

Post #12/45

Well that was both a frustrating and vindicating catch up.

As a general rule of thumb for this game, please nobody listen to smol brain Penner. Both town and scum. Though I would advise scum to keep him alive so that he can be a complete toddler in the day threads.

Sorry Gmaj :( you're a delight when you participate

Will be back with more content after I wake up properly but back to square

##unlynch
##lynch Herm

Post #13/45

Zersch @ 4/9/2020 8:42

Pen Newton @ 4/9/2020 11:40 Also who’s the toddler when all you’re doing is downvoting posts while I’ve been busy scum hunting Let's start taking bets on whether he will grace a post with one of his limited replies or not. I think this might get one.

i missed playing with u Zersch ur hilarious. unfortunate that u had to roll scum in ur return game

Penner ur confusing posting a lot with scum-hunting. ur doing a good job of filling up the thread with nonsense suggestions and theories. i'd actually be legitimately surprised if u have even cast a single lynch vote for scum yet. its early still so u'll have more opportunities im sure

since ur gonna ask what i mean by nonsense suggestions - ur reason for lynching spin is that spin, as scum, baited a town vig onto gmaj and then had his mafia team bus drive gmaj with someone else. who they knew would survive an attack? i mean i felt silly even typing this out

im gonna have to re-evaluate my reads based on the stuff that happened with the daykill but a current off the top of my head thoughts are

1. i saw some post from Maddie which made me feel better about her. im not gonna point it out (and honestly it was a short one so ive forgotten which one specifically) but the tone stuck out to me
2. if Herm is scum, im fairly sure zersch is too. reason: zersch hemmed-and-hawwed about thinking herm is scummy, posted a bunch of reasons why he thought anviling gmaj was a bad idea but did it anyways. i read this as the scum team not wanting to anvil one of their own and instead trying to still seem suspicious of what is a likely lynch candidate in Herm
3. correct me if im wrong but there seemed to be way more people interacting with timmah when he was making it seem like he had a daykill v/s when zersch came out with it. my theory is that bc timmah is town and scum wanted to kiss up a bit there whereas zersch is scum and scum knew they dont need to. i'll try to capture specifics of who this applies to (it could also be a timing thing tho seeing as zersch's bit happened in the morning but still worth a look if nothing else)

Post #14/45

Zersch @ 4/9/2020 9:02

I'm very happy with how wrong you are Nav :)

i hope im wrong too! we already lost 2 hilarious ppl in sock and gmaj. if we lose u the thread will just be Penner being a dumbass and me being a douchelord

Post #15/45

i dont actually think spin saying he got "punched in the face" is a real item he got

if hes being scumread based on that then that seems even sillier because if he was scum he could have just said he got nothing at all