I played the first game way too long ago to remember specifics but I DID enjoy it overall. Especially Oswald and Harvey's characters but I'm a bit biased in that I'm a big Two Face fan and the leaner, conniving take on Oswald was something I found to be a fun juxtaposition to the short, fat and corny Penguin that I'm used to from Batman TAS.

I've bought the first episode of the second game but haven't played yet. Will probably play this weekend and post my thoughts about it.

I've only played Batman and the Game of Thrones one by Tell Tale and between the 2 I'd probably give the edge to GOT in terms of how engrossed i became in the game /story but both were definitely solid games for me.