i lived because of my item

its a Smiley Face Stress Ball

i can choose to squeeze it 3 times, on the night that i squeeze it im immune to attacks

obvi chose to squeeze it N1 bc duh

Reaper Of The Dead @ 2/5/2023 16:26

TheNavneet @ 2/5/2023 20:07 i lived because of my item its a Smiley Face Stress Ball i can choose to squeeze it 3 times, on the night that i squeeze it im immune to attacks obvi chose to squeeze it N1 bc duh So you’re immune to attacks 3 nights of your choosing?

that is correct

2 more left

Curtis @ 2/5/2023 17:14

Do you own a smiley face stress ball Nav

jamie @ 2/5/2023 16:54

I gave zero effort in picking my item, nav picking a stress ball doesn’t surprise me, it could have been in his room when he was sending boc an item?

pretty much this

last time it was two face's coin, which ironically is sitting right next to the smiley ball KEKW

jamie @ 2/5/2023 16:55

That said, idk if I fully buy the 3x immune - seems a bit op but maybe he’s lying so scum stays away.

shhh cmon dont give away the game jamie smh

Curtis @ 2/5/2023 17:38

Good enough for me What is that piece of cardboard

my other laptop is sitting on it since i didnt wanna place it directly on the table

Rodney @ 2/5/2023 17:07

I don't see any reason to lie about your item. You can make up anything for it's use

last time i said my item was a picture of Zach with a knife through his head and my role was lyncher

people actually bought it but mostly because there wasnt enough town left to actually question it

Rodney @ 2/5/2023 18:07

Are we suggesting choosing your own alignment is theoretically possible in this game? Because we can open that can of worms. I went in just assuming alignment would be randomized and role would be loosely associated at best

i think Curtis was saying that is is possible to try and game your alignment by picking very pointed items, like a knife or a lighter or something like that

and in case you did try to do that, it is reasonable to think you would also lie about your item

itsbrianyay @ 2/5/2023 18:38

I think voting nav is likely the right call but I’m happy to hear him out

TheNavneet @ 2/5/2023 16:07

i lived because of my item its a Smiley Face Stress Ball i can choose to squeeze it 3 times, on the night that i squeeze it im immune to attacks obvi chose to squeeze it N1 bc duh

Rodney @ 2/5/2023 19:25

itsbrianyay @ 2/5/2023 23:01 No I mean I know what your explanation is I just mean like I need you to beg a little Feels awkward to run up a pressure train on Nav because there probably isn't much more to draw out of him. He made his claim. We pretty much either thumbs up or thumbs down it

im not going to beg lol you either believe me or you don't

whilst im here i'll post some reads and shit i guess since i havent really done that yet

the kills:

Lamp - not sure I would agree that his posts indicate he picked Rodney. the only other person he interacted with was Badger. i would honestly say its more likely he was just outright killed since Lamp tends to be killed early by scum in games. or am i remembering that wrong. if we see only two or only one attack over the next night then this theory can be revisited and we can look at Rodney or Badger at that point.

Rose - also feels like a scum kill, she seemed pretty active yesterday

me - PoE would suggest im a likely vig kill or shot at by a townie. understandable as well since i did my usual D1 thing of voting Curtis which I would do as any alignment

alright i skimmed this day phase

town reads so far (no particular order)
317
jamie
Curtis

scum reads:
reaper (sorry :( )

more town than scum but not ready to commit yet:
ahoda
rodney

undecided:
rest

i'll read day 1 again tomorrow and flesh this out more

JJ @ 2/5/2023 20:45

Nav why 317, Jamie and Curtis town?

317 and jamies mindset about my item resonated with my own thought process which read genuine. add to that jamie's questioning of my ability being 3x.

Curtis' interaction with 317 also read townlike to me

I was really hoping for some sort of absorbing role with the stress ball. That would have been more fun than just an auto ML after being randomly shot at

Apparently I'm missing something that's making Rodney seem suspicious? Admittedly I haven't read D1 properly yet but Rodney's posts today sound like frustrated Town than frustrated scum fwiw