LSFissue @ 18/2/2013 16:52

because ari is cool

##Lynch LSFissue

My guess is Henry was targeted the first night and he used his role. Very likely that he would use it on night one, and I can buy that someone would try to kill him right away, mafia or otherwise

I'd say either that was the reason why Night 1 had only one attack, or a roleblocker out there got lucky and has some info

Let's all lynch Rito

Rito Kanakiri @ 18/2/2013 17:43

Now I am just as lost as ever. I'm thinking Mal could be a good vote. I am also thinking to vote for Gimpapple.

How come?

tbh Jeff is a good candidate for lynch

He is..
A: Useless in terms of discussion because he has added none
B: Expendable (as bad as it is to say) because he claims he has no role now
C: Quite possibly the don or SK, or a mafia member that Greenday protected

I think the pros outweigh the cons on a Jeff lynch

Jeff is Leaffan for the new players who aren't aware

##Lynch Jeff

After looking through his posts I've made up my mind

He did nothing but say hi on day one. Why would mafia attack him after that? I understand if the mafia is KIND and wants to take out someone not adding too much, or strategic and wants someone that wouldn't be a likely person for the doctor to protect, but Jeff just seems too random of a target to me. I just don't see them wasting a kill on him

Then he decides to prematurely roleclaim in his third post in the game. The odds are greater that he's mafia/SK/cult over a townie. The chances that the mafia got so unlucky by hitting the quiet one time BP are so low

I think he's the safest lynch today

I can't decide if this is just a case of RITO being horrible as usual or Drrr being pissed that a horrible player is onto her

I wish you could both just die honestly!

If I was mafia and in Drrr's position and Rito came after me after endless amounts of retardation and vote switching then I would be pretty pissed and would've made that exact post that Drrr did in order to place tons and tons of doubt into all of Rito's already awful theories. That way everyone would feel stupid for even considering following his lead

HOWEVER, if I was in Drrr's position and was town then I would be equally annoyed that he came after me and might've done the same thing she just did in order to make fun of him

HOWEVER AGAIN, it's interesting to note that of all the many people that Rito has lynched so far, Drrr is the only one to act extremely defensive to his silly accusations

Rito Kanakiri @ 18/2/2013 18:41

keep in mind. I have the best record in mafia on this site, and have voted for more scum than ANY of you. probably by 2-3 times the amount, too.

lol'd. You have voted for more players than any of us, probably by 2-3 times the amount! There's an enormous difference. And when you happen to be right about someone due to luck, your previous actions are always so poor that you're incapable of forming any sort of argument to support it and aren't able to get anyone to follow you. Your record for actually successfully getting someone lynched is probably quite poor

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 18/2/2013 19:35

I'm not willing to lynch someone just because they survived a single night attack. His lack of being remotely useful in any way is another matter, but lynch-all-survivors is not a brilliant strategy. There are a lot of reasons he could have survived the night that don't involve him being anti-town. I think it's a bad idea to lynch solely based on survival. Maybe he is scum, I don't know! But I'd rather we go for a lynch based on more than just that.

For me at this point it's based more off of his few actions which were questionable than purely his survival

Tom Brady @ 18/2/2013 19:55

Which means that all actions were submitted on night 1 most likely, and nobody was blocked. Someone definitely failed a kill.

What do you mean nobody was blocked?

Yeah I get that he's eliminating the possibility of an SK or Vig not sending a kill on time, but I don't get the second part

Him being blocked is the most likely scenario