I'm getting scum vibes from Eben. His somewhat insistence that Lamps is guilty because of this comes off as scummy to me. One of his D1 posts gave me a vibe too

##Lynch Eben

Could be Lamps for sure but my first thought was what Ahoda said, that JC was a likely Vig kill. The idea that Mafia killed JC to "frame" me is pretty stupid. When has framing like that ever even worked (:

Getting the feeling that we're being pushed down the wrong track on the Lamps lynch but it's hard to say, he could just as easily be Godfather. Need more from Lamps today I think, but right now I'm going with my biggest gut read

ahoda @ 28/4/2016 7:24

Angi @ 28/4/2016 8:23 I have to agree that I think it's more likely that vig attacked JC but who knows. We all know I'm not very bright lol But you're super beautiful so that masks the intelligence issue. ;)

Omg <3

vladykins @ 28/4/2016 9:26

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 8:40 I don't understand why a Vig couldn't have killed JC. Usually someone with that role can't resist killing someone. On the first few nights, in the absence of a solid scum read, they'll kill an inactive. But how about a player actively complaining about their role? Being distracting? And even self-voting at one point? I can see a Vig killing him. FOS on those that are discounting that. So you are saying that this game has a mafia who targeted Lamps and a vig that targeted JC and that we either have no SK or an SK who didn't bother to turn in a night action? I'm sorry, but that set up just sounds off to me. The fact that everyone is assuming vig, with *NO FLAVOR* at all to back that up seems silly and a way to give Lamps an out. I'm not sure where Curtis is suddenly saying people are framing him either, because outside of one post that I thought was a joke, nobody has even mentioned him. That strikes me as weirdly defensive.

I was catching up and remember seeing like three people talk about Mafia killing JC to frame me (they weren't joking). Just seemed like a silly line of thinking, I feel like that sorta framing is never successful

Lamps relying on the idea that Mafia probably attacked him doesn't sit too well with me really. Seems like you're focusing too hard on that. I think it's worth claiming

Eben Etzebeth @ 28/4/2016 10:27

Curtis/Lamps connection noted.

I thought I was being so subtle :(

Possible that Lamps is SK and Mafia really did attack him and that's why he's frustrated and trying to rely on that

I didn't overreact at all, I just thought it was a poor theory (:

You're over exaggerating my over reaction sir!

Angi @ 28/4/2016 7:02

Buffy @ 27/4/2016 22:21 Herm, are you saying Curtis is scum? I took it more that scum is maybe trying to frame Curtis, but then when I was mafia I remember saying we could just use that as our reason why we wouldn't do it lol So he still could be

Also Vlady ^

Not just Herm

Also why would I even need to defend myself over the idea that Mafia is trying to frame me (making me town)? (:

WHACHU EVEN GETTING AT PUNK

If Lamps has a good role there is zero reason not to claim it if he's gonna get lynched today. If he survives the lynch then there's still the threat of roles to watch or protect him at night, enough that I can't see mafia risking killing him. It'd also give him at least one night to use his role if it would help

Let's ALL claim so we can put the pieces together and guess what Lamps is

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 15:00

Eben Etzebeth @ 28/4/2016 20:12 Because in all scenarios we can see how people react, and even if you do get lynched still we can start to put together the pieces on who is scum or not. If you have a shit role then this is unlikely to help, but it's in the town's best interest to provide all info available so that we can make the most informed decisions. Angi @ 28/4/2016 20:22 I think Lamps is saying he has a good roll and he'll just get killed tonight if you all unlynch him so what's the sense? Ok you both have a point. I'm a dead fish in all scenarios so it doesn't necessarily help but also doesn't hurt any extra since votes seem to stay on me anyway. I am JOAT and protected myself last night because my other 3 abilities would go to waste in case I got killed. Do you guys want me to list my other abilities?

Yes

Herm @ 28/4/2016 15:40

Buffy and Curtis, who are you lynching?

My votes still on Eben

Lamps' claim could easily be bullshit but I don't see him lasting long if he's lying (ya I know Jay). He has opportunities with his other three abilities to prove himself. If he constantly fails to do so then it should raise eyebrows

Personally I would've acted way differently if I was in Lamps' shoes. If scum tried to kill me on N1 and I successfully thwarted it and saved myself, I'd be elated instead of defeated like Lamps is acting. Maybe it's just a difference in playstyle but idk, it stands out to me

Willing to see how things pan out with him though. I still get a vibe from Eben above most but I'm fine with lynching a no show again today

Lamps did you consider using anything else on anyone else or was it always gonna be the protection?

Mercator @ 28/4/2016 16:38

🎺 Malion @ 28/4/2016 14:37 Docs can't protect themselves? Since when? Since always

Incorrect