Patrick and Jeff have been scummy as shit the past two days. I'm pretty okay with either of them right now

Nofo were one of those two kills from you last night?

Bryce @ 14/8/2013 13:42

I doubt Dylan is an SK Ari. Especially when you read DD's role. Revived players come back roleless unless that's only the people he would revive.

DD didn't revive Dylan

Mal @ 14/8/2013 13:45

Bryce @ 14/8/2013 13:43 And Mal, we've taken out 2 scum. So if your 5 scum left thing is true, that means there were 7 to begin with. I'd say max 6, but likely 5 to start meaning 3 left. Who was the other scum? I know we took out 2 third party players.

Rob!

Bryce @ 14/8/2013 13:44

Curtis @ 14/8/2013 11:43 Bryce @ 14/8/2013 13:42 I doubt Dylan is an SK Ari. Especially when you read DD's role. Revived players come back roleless unless that's only the people he would revive. DD didn't revive Dylan I know that. I put at the end "unless that's only people he would revive" because I wasn't sure. But have the kills changed at all? Like since Dylan revived have there been more than normal?

I doubt a clause in DD's hidden text is universal for all revivals in the game. You never know really. I wouldn't say that it's any sort of evidence as far as Dylan's revival goes

Nobert @ 14/8/2013 13:47

Plus if I voted Merc as mafia, I wouldn't kill him at night. Would just make me look a whole lot scummier so the mafia probably attacked him to frame me and have an easy lynch.

lol I doubt it. Once Samm finally flipped it became crystal clear that Merc was town. Mafia would've had no reason to keep him at that point. I doubt it was done to frame you. I think you framed yourself! Ps)

Mal and ari out of my head

Might as well give a list of night actions with that

That could be a scum role pretty easily. And we already saw Willis as a scum character so Wikey the mime would make a lot of sense

Is this a daily thing or just once Jeff?

I don't get why you would chose to mimic DD after Day 4. I had my suspicions against her too because of the lynching all silenced players thing, but after she explained herself there was little reason to reflect her own role back at her. And you said on Day 5 right away that you read the whole last day and found her suspicious, which I didn't get at that point

And...if you mimic'd her N4, that means you found out her role as reviver, but still said you were suspicious of her Day 5? Not really adding up for me at all tbh

##Lynch Jeff

If you're able to explain or be more convincing then I'll happily switch to Patrick

Nobert @ 14/8/2013 14:08

Curtis @ 14/8/2013 14:07 I don't get why you would chose to mimic DD after Day 4. I had my suspicions against her too because of the lynching all silenced players thing, but after she explained herself there was little reason to reflect her own role back at her. And you said on Day 5 right away that you read the whole last day and found her suspicious, which I didn't get at that point And...if you mimic'd her N4, that means you found out her role as reviver, but still said you were suspicious of her Day 5? Not really adding up for me at all tbh ##Lynch Jeff If you're able to explain or be more convincing then I'll happily switch to Patrick I mimicked her night 3! When she did nothing

But didn't you learn her role after you mimic'd her? And yet you still pushed for her?

You reflecting it back to DD might have cost us her second revival (:

Oh but you're saying she did nothing so she chose not to revive that night which means your mimic didn't reflect. I got that part now

Jeff you've already spelled it out (:

Jeff reflected Ari and learned that Ari is a cop, and Ari scanned Patrick

##Unlynch
##Lynch Patrick

Ari might as well talk about it at this point because Jeff gave him away really. If Ari is confident then I'll follow his lead

Still not quite sure that I buy Jeff's role entirely. I don't wanna base too much off of characters, but Jeff being Wikey a villain is hard to ignore. Like if we knew Samm was Willis I'm sure we would've all been even more suspicious. That and Jeff's ability can easily be a scum one

Like Dylan said though, I'm more switching because of Ari and because Patrick himself has been shady all game