Helios Garabandia @ 25/8/2016 22:26

Curtis @ 25/8/2016 22:11 There are 100% town tanks with a lot of HP. He could also be getting hit for smallish amounts of damage I don't doubt this. I've seen the character list. However, I still have my doubts. The smallest potential attack damage we've seen thus far has come from ahoda, who could deal 80 damage. At that rate, if he really was attacked four times, then he would have taken 240 damage + whatever happened N4 (remember, he claimed that Night 1, 2, and 3, he was attacked for the same amount of damage; he has not said that for N4, so I cannot assume). Also, why someone would choose to heal him N4 and not N1-3 (since he has never claimed healing before, but suddenly claimed to be healed this time) is beyond me. Especially because, and I can't stress this enough, why would someone attack 317 four nights in a row? I'm quite concerned about this whole thing right here! I think he's made up at least some of the attacks, if not all four attacks. Back in D2 he waited to mention that he was attacked until after Spin said he was attacked. And most of you have decided that the people who claimed being attacked all "lean town". So, it would stand to reason that a Mafioso would claim being attacked because it would make them look good. That's what I think has happened here!

you are really starting to look like frustrated scum who cant manage to kill me at night and is not trying to get me lynched instead. and yet im not convinced you are scum.

-dr @ 25/8/2016 22:28

I dunno why im317 would claim an attack every single night to try to lay low. Also 240 isn't that much. And if he was healed, he would probably just be notified of being hassled and attacked, and his total HP. He wouldn't know if it was for the same amount because of the healing.

i think but am not sure that it was the same person this last time, since i was also healed. i suppose it could be multiple people that do the same amount of damage. i have also begun to wonder if maybe someone had an ability that deals x damage per night to whoever they pick night 1, just because its starting to get ridiculous.

without saying how much HP i have or how much the damage has been, i will say that its not so much that there are not characters that could have taken 4 nights of the same damage without dying.

im317 @ 25/8/2016 22:48

you are really starting to look like frustrated scum who cant manage to kill me at night and is not trying to get me lynched instead. and yet im not convinced you are scum.

Given that 1)I can't attack at night and 2)I straight don't believe your claim, I'm not "frustrated scum".

Christian @ 25/8/2016 19:38

but also I don't think this is Drake's first Mafia game anymore. :P

To my knowledge it is

Helios Garabandia @ 25/8/2016 23:05

im317 @ 25/8/2016 22:48 you are really starting to look like frustrated scum who cant manage to kill me at night and is not trying to get me lynched instead. and yet im not convinced you are scum. Given that 1)I can't attack at night and 2)I straight don't believe your claim, I'm not "frustrated scum".

but you can see how its starting to look like you are.

Helios Garabandia @ 25/8/2016 20:05

im317 @ 25/8/2016 22:48 you are really starting to look like frustrated scum who cant manage to kill me at night and is not trying to get me lynched instead. and yet im not convinced you are scum. Given that 1)I can't attack at night and 2)I straight don't believe your claim, I'm not "frustrated scum".

Are you saying you can attack during the day?

I'm surprised we've seen all these role reveals showing day powers and yet no one ever uses them

Anyway I want to hear thoughts from Dadd, Vladdy, Merc, Wikey, and Odd. Suspect lists and the like. Those are the people I have the least solid read on.

Helios do you WANT us to lynch you??? ...

-dr @ 25/8/2016 20:13

Anyway I want to hear thoughts from Dadd, Vladdy, Merc, Wikey, and Odd. Suspect lists and the like. Those are the people I have the least solid read on.

While you're at it you and everyone else should post their lists...

Ole' Vern @ 25/8/2016 23:13

Helios Garabandia @ 25/8/2016 20:05 im317 @ 25/8/2016 22:48 you are really starting to look like frustrated scum who cant manage to kill me at night and is not trying to get me lynched instead. and yet im not convinced you are scum. Given that 1)I can't attack at night and 2)I straight don't believe your claim, I'm not "frustrated scum". Are you saying you can attack during the day? I'm surprised we've seen all these role reveals showing day powers and yet no one ever uses them

No. That's not what I'm saying at all. Stop rolefishing.

Ole' Vern @ 25/8/2016 23:14

-dr @ 25/8/2016 20:13 Anyway I want to hear thoughts from Dadd, Vladdy, Merc, Wikey, and Odd. Suspect lists and the like. Those are the people I have the least solid read on. While you're at it you and everyone else should post their lists...

Strong town vibe
Drrr alone

Lean Town
22. im317
Curtis
17. Ole Vern
5. Christian
7. Oddilus

No read
18. Vladykins
14. Dadd
12. thisisbad
8. Helios

Lean scum
16. Timmah (mostly no read)
10. itsbrianyay (up from heavy suspect)

More than lean scum but not heavily suspect
13. Drake
20. Mercator

Heavily suspect
4. Wikey

Christian @ 25/8/2016 20:38

but also I don't think this is Drake's first Mafia game anymore. :P

Drake totally slipped out of "i'm a newbie" mode

And i agree with a wikey lynch. just seems right

Extra thoughts:
Starting to have my doubts about Vern as "confirmed" town. I feel like we all went for the town vibe really early on when Vern was in helpful mode but I feel like people were too quick to accept him as confirmed town.

Helios keeps going back and forth for me. I feel like for the most part the aggressive Helios trademark posts are going towards silly mistakes and obvious duck ups and less towards actual scum hunting. Helios is always aggressive but I feel like most cases he's been building have been against people for being goofy or for flimsy stuff like the im317 thing.

Wikey seems to just be trolling but I want to see how he reacts to the votes against in the morning.

I really feel like Drake has over-played the newbie act and is playing mostly defensively with the random occasional big accusation. If we were more ahead I'd be going for him but it's hard to tell what's scummy and what's newbie

I lean town on Odd but I don't like how little he said overall.

I go back and forth on Curtis but since I helped him out I'm keeping him high on the town list for the sake of my ego. His reaction to his attacks and questioning of Chris yesterday all seemed pretty town to Me though.

I don't find im317's claims weird at all

strange. i thought Wikey had 3 or 4 votes but i checked and only Oddilus has actually voted for him. just lots of people listing him as there scum read.

##lynch Wikey

that should be enough pressure to get him to participate when he shows up. time for me to get some sleep, g'night.

Town
Dr
Timmah
Oddilus
Helios
Christian

No read / Undecided
Vern
Curtis
Vladykins
thisisbad
itsbrianyay

Leaning Scum
im317
Dadd
Mercator

Scum
Wikey
Drake

Current Tally

Wikey (3/8) - Oddilus, im317
Helios (1/8) - Vern
im317 (1/8) - Helios

21 hours remaining