Oh, because you unlynched. I forgot who the four were, just remembered four so nvm.

Yeah, I also want to hear from Tricks but he did say his schedule was much busier now so if he's telling the truth and is not pulling a Vic he probably won't show up.

JJ @ 8/6/2014 15:07

Deetster @ 8/6/2014 15:05 So, we now have 4 opportunities left including this one to get the SK. Let's get this right. 10 left 8 left 6 left 4 left We still have to get cult out (if there is one left) in order for town to win.

Yeah, but the numbers will very different then, in terms of how many attempts we have. They wouldn't be killing us into one less attempt every round.

Let's hope the SK might also accidentally kill the cult on one of these rounds perhaps too.

Yeah, there must be 1 cult member left. I ran the numbers back when cult was more of a threat several times and I think we either have the #1st recruit or the #5th recruit left.

Oh what fun I missed

I don't think we have to kill cult to win actually. Given that there is just one left with no killing or recruiting power, I think they would just lose if all other scum were killed and they didnt outnumber the town. I'm not completely sure though.

I'm going back and forth on Shawns role. On one hand its sort of a weird hider variant and he had trouble with spitting out what it does, waiting an entire night to go from sort-of-doctor to hider variant, but I don't think it conflicts with what he was saying last night.

Part of me has been thinking that SK had to be paying attention but then again I'm not sure they would go killing Patrick over Hupu or Tony (though the possibility of hupu bussing one of those might have scared him off)

But I don't have any strong leads so Shawn's as good a choice as any. I'll vote him later if we don't have any other leads. It just doesn't quite feel right

Herm @ 8/6/2014 15:23

Yeah, there must be 1 cult member left. I ran the numbers back when cult was more of a threat several times and I think we either have the #1st recruit or the #5th recruit left.

That's why I think it's Tricks. I think whoever it is has kind of cop/investigative role and Tricks made that comment about confirming im317 to be town. idk if he would've been recruited before spilling that info, though and I can't remember which day he said it. Day 2 or 3 I think?

If it's not Tricks, then maybe Cash but I also don't think he would've been recruited before revealing his role.

And that's even "if" Raptor recruited anyone Night 1. I probably wouldn't have but maybe he took the risk. If so, I would probably bet on KC or Curtis being recruited first unless there's a reason I'm not remember that they couldn't have been.

Drrr @ 8/6/2014 15:42

Oh what fun I missed I don't think we have to kill cult to win actually. Given that there is just one left with no killing or recruiting power, I think they would just lose if all other scum were killed and they didnt outnumber the town. I'm not completely sure though. I'm going back and forth on Shawns role. On one hand its sort of a weird hider variant and he had trouble with spitting out what it does, waiting an entire night to go from sort-of-doctor to hider variant, but I don't think it conflicts with what he was saying last night. Part of me has been thinking that SK had to be paying attention but then again I'm not sure they would go killing Patrick over Hupu or Tony (though the possibility of hupu bussing one of those might have scared him off) But I don't have any strong leads so Shawn's as good a choice as any. I'll vote him later if we don't have any other leads. It just doesn't quite feel right

Oh, I thought since cult could win if they're last one left, we would have to get them out to win. But I guess it's impossible to be the only one left if it comes down to 1 town, 1 cult member, they can't vote each other out or kill each other (unless the specific cult member has some type of role where they can kill but that's kind of a long shot). So, that makes sense.

Can you ask Hupu who he bused last night? He seems to respond to you lol.

Quote

That's why I think it's Tricks. I think whoever it is has kind of cop/investigative role and Tricks made that comment about confirming im317 to be town. idk if he would've been recruited before spilling that info, though and I can't remember which day he said it. Day 2 or 3 I think?

This is pretty my feelings on the matter as well. I think Tricks said what he said on Day 3.

I always assumed Curtis was recruited either Night 3 or Night 4. KC either Night 1 or Night 5, but from what it feels like with Raptor definitely sure Brian and Nofo were scum it's probably Night 5. IM317 on Night 2. Ahoda on Night 3 or Night 4. Both Ahoda and Curtis were killed on Night 5.

Is it possible for cult leader to recruit the SK or would he have died if he had tried?

lel tim

That's a really good question Herm. Could someone have dual alignments? Idk. Technically that just makes it way easier to "win" since SK would just need to try to have the cult members remain safe.

But when Adoha and Curtis were both killed, wouldn't that mean that SK killed a cult member? Why would they do that.

If they were cult as well, I'm saying.

JJ @ 8/6/2014 15:49

Herm @ 8/6/2014 15:23 Yeah, there must be 1 cult member left. I ran the numbers back when cult was more of a threat several times and I think we either have the #1st recruit or the #5th recruit left. That's why I think it's Tricks. I think whoever it is has kind of cop/investigative role and Tricks made that comment about confirming im317 to be town. idk if he would've been recruited before spilling that info, though and I can't remember which day he said it. Day 2 or 3 I think? If it's not Tricks, then maybe Cash but I also don't think he would've been recruited before revealing his role. And that's even "if" Raptor recruited anyone Night 1. I probably wouldn't have but maybe he took the risk. If so, I would probably bet on KC or Curtis being recruited first unless there's a reason I'm not remember that they couldn't have been.

Actually, I take it back. There has to be another recruit and it has to be some type of cop role. There's no other explanation for knowing both Brian and Nofo were mafia. KC's role doesn't account for that if he wasn't told alignment. Maybe he could guess about Brian's item but I doubt it.

Also, if it's true cult can't win now, if there is a cult cop they should just help us if they know alignments so we can get SK out. For "old times sake" when they were town. :P

HUPU

Who you bussed

I mean, technically can't they tie? They can get us town folk into a tie.

Really, of course if there is a cult alignment, they NEED to kill the SK. IF the SK doesn't die during the round of 4, no matter what, SK wins.