The Sebneet @ 10/2/2018 13:18

ZacharyB @ 10/2/2018 11:16 Also, do you guys think we had two townies trying to find people? No. I'm almost certain Primate is 3p. Like a failed Cult recruiter.

That's because you're an unimaginative moron.

Josh @ 10/2/2018 14:25

The Sebneet @ 10/2/2018 15:21 Mads @ 10/2/2018 12:09 Another option: Josh is a godfather equivalent so DS made an attack on himself deflect to Josh, but Josh can't be killed at night so DS died. Ok. This does make a lot of sense. I'm pretty sure DS had been using his action on himself and someone else repeatedly. So this has to be it. Whoever DS picked last night with himself has BP protection. That's why DS was the only death. And Joshie, this points most to you than anyone else. DS had been suspecting you for a long time now. I just have to think if it's possible for Joshie to be a BP GF while also having so many "watch" results. This would mean that I would have to be untargetable as well as bulletproof and DS said yesterday that he was able to successfully use his action to move an action off of me onto Primate.

The night he and Buffy both claimed to have done something to me, my pm specifically said nothing happened to me, so if he moved an action, it was a harmless one. DS also said if he died, he would take someone with him. Not someone instead of him.

Josh @ 10/2/2018 15:09

Maddie, are you even reading anyone else's posts? He was saying he was doubting I had a watcher ability at all. Your posts have been nothing but aggressive and out of context today.

I doubt you have a watcher ability, too. As long as one scum had it, any scum could claim it.

I'm in no hurry here. We need to get it right.

If we are sure there are mafia left:
Josh seems like the way to go for all the reasons mentioned earlier.

Maddie's confidence is a little out of character, but I don't think she and Buffy were mafia together. Like someone else said, if they were, they deserve an award.

Zach is the odd man out here. Nobody has looked at him since early in the game, and he has skated along.

Nav isn't mafia.

If we are looking for 3p:
Zach
Mads
Josh

If we are looking for dumb townies:
Nav
Primate

The first player post of the day yesterday. Is this not confidence?

I jumped the fuck into Day 9 with confidence.

Primate @ 10/2/2018 17:03

Josh @ 10/2/2018 15:09 Maddie, are you even reading anyone else's posts? He was saying he was doubting I had a watcher ability at all. Your posts have been nothing but aggressive and out of context today. I doubt you have a watcher ability, too. As long as one scum had it, any scum could claim it.

Thinking logistically, Buffy would be the only person to have the watcher ability because I had proven results the night that Canuck died and his flavor matched the death of the night he died.

If that were the case, wouldn't Buffy have watched the night she died and sent me out for the kill to keep up the facade? It would make no sense to go this late in the game with a watcher claim and not do everything I could to keep up that claim.

Buffy didn't die in the night though...she was lynched. Last night was your only night without Buffy in the game and you claim to have watched me.

Mads @ 10/2/2018 17:46

Buffy didn't die in the night though...she was lynched. Last night was your only night without Buffy in the game and you claim to have watched me.

I’m saying the night before she would have watched and it would have shown up as her last song successfully played.

We also there was some kind of role blocker/jailer about and the night Buffy performed the kill and today, we haven’t seen any claims of anyone being blocked. She was claiming jailer so what would be the logic in us just switching claims and if we were together?

I can buy the train of thought that I’m scum watcher because I’m still alive but it just doesn’t add up that I was scum taking information from someone else.

Zach, where are you at my friend?

Day 10 Love My Way Votes


With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch. Plurality is in effect.
Deadline is Monday 2:00pm


Josh (1): – Mads


Not Voted:

Zach
Primate
Josh
Seb

Good morning. I don't know if anyone else is around. I'm going to post some thoughts in a minute about claims and things since no one else is around.

Nav:
Claimed commuter. Claim backed by Josh D2. (Any other instances D2?)
Claimed love song. Played and no counter claim.
Claimed break-up song. Played and no counter claim.

He led the lynch on Buffy, his claim has lined up with his actions through the game so far. The only sketchy thing was making Maddie & Buffy lovers late in the game and not commenting on it much but he undid that action after a while. Could have been him trying to get a two for one knowing that Buffy was going to be lynched/killed by Zersch. Scum doesn't feel right for Nav, though.

Maddie:
Claimed unstoppable. Visiting role was backed but there was no instance of the visit doing anything. Zach said his flavor said he was feeling good a day later, but Maddie claimed it made their actions unstoppable during that night if I remember correctly.
Claimed love song. Tried to use but was roleblocked.
Claimed one-time bulletproof? Or untargetable?

She claimed that all of her actions were one-use but then claimed to have read her role wrong. Also read her role wrong about the unstoppable action she had. Now that I think about it, this would be a good way to cover herself for having no results from her role until late in the game. We also know we are/were looking for a scum RB so she might have switched her claim to avoid getting caught in that. The only thing working against this claim is the Zach visit but we don't know because he didn't use any role the night she visited. The unstoppable claim is an easy one because there is no proof that she visited people and after I claimed, people would be looking at my visit results and she could easily slip in a different name than myself of who she visited because no one would doubt it. On the other hand, having an unstoppable would balance out having a roleblocker which was my original thought of her being town. After today, I'm insanely iffy on Maddie but she could just be misguided town.

Zach:
Claimed love song. Played and no counter claim.
Claimed untargettable action on lover. Played and backed by Josh.
Claimed silencing action on lover. Never used?
What else am I missing? I feel like there was more.

He's slid by through the game without any pressure on him really. His voting history is pretty nondescript for this game so I don't know what to go off of there. He has been on scum trains late in the game but there isn't anything of note earlier on in the game. I'll go back and look at lynch counts and the notes on them later. He's been pretty quiet today which worries me because I've seen him in the thread, which could just mean he was checking in on his phone but today is a weird day to sit back and not at least say you'll be back. But we have until Monday afternoon so I won't start hounding on activity until later.

Primate:
Claimed break-up song. Played and no counter claim.
Claimed search role. Nothing backing this. Was told he didn't get told about this portion of his role until late IIRC? Claims to no longer have it.
Claimed untargettable when he doesn't use his role. Just for love songs or anything in general? Do we have any actions that were used on him?

Primate has had a weird game IMO. He has not voted for the past few days (the last vote he cast was the lead vote in the TiB lynch). He seemed to be leaning to protect Buffy throughout the past few days over Maddie from his posts but he was also selling that the mimic could have been 3p. I think the 3p route is an odd choice but I could be the crazy one in this situation. I've never had a great read on Primate this game because of his search role that matched up with Ahoda(?) and his inability to be visited by love songs (and possibly more). He also was told he was no longer able to visit to look for whomever he was looking for in the middle of the day at one point IIRC too. (Too much has happened in this game & I'm hungover SOS).