Herm @ 9/1/2018 16:41

Farlig Herm shouldn't be alive because his role could take out scum via a lynch. This could be a miscalculation on scum's end. Kid's faction probably think I'm In-Law, and In-Law faction think I'm Kid. Either way, 2 active town and an inactive town vs 1 scum on Night 9 doesn't sound like good odds to me, unless the inactive townsperson is scum.

Regardless, you still should have had a higher likelihood of being killed last night than Spin.

Why would scum want to kill someone who they think is scum?

I'm pretty sure Jamie thinks I'm scum, that's why his fake claim is the way it is.

If they had believed I was town, they would've probably killed me over Spin based on the nature of my role, yes.

Herm @ 9/1/2018 16:49

Why would scum want to kill someone who they think is scum? I'm pretty sure Jamie thinks I'm scum, that's why his fake claim is the way it is.

You just made my point. If they bought your claim, you'd be dead. But because you aren't...

You forget that there's two factions, and neither them, nor anyone else that is town, knows whether I'm telling the truth or not.

The only one who knows I'm Town Vengeful for sure is me, scum has apparently drawn the wrong conclusion about me.

The other scum, Helios or PORL, knows that one of me/Jamie is town, which could explain hesitation on who to lynch out of the two.

I am not forgetting there are 2 as I am assuming you are one so only one other faction has to not buy your claim, thus you are alive. The fact I'm not sure anyone alive buys your claim means my point looks pretty reasonable.

That and the countless dead people who thought you were stanky.

If scum factions were balanced, we know we probably have one goon left. Based on role claims alone, herm looks like the more probable goon while Jamie would possibly have a scum visiting role where he'd have to be able to explain being seen somewhere.

As long as Jamie is lynched today.

Big lylo moment is at D10.

Herm @ 9/1/2018 16:58

You forget that there's two factions, and neither them, nor anyone else that is town, knows whether I'm telling the truth or not. The only one who knows I'm Town Vengeful for sure is me, scum has apparently drawn the wrong conclusion about me. The other scum, Helios or PORL, knows that one of me/Jamie is town, which could explain hesitation on who to lynch out of the two.

It's not a matter of which one of you is Town. I think you're both Scum, and I'm trying to figure out which one of you is 'Nilla In-Law and which one of you is Power Kids Table.

Our night abilities ranges from Bulletproof to Messenger, not sure it really matters that much.

Jamie's the right move today.

Herm you are putting up a good fight, I'll give you that.

If I was mafia, I woud have broken the game by now. It's very doable.

So what do you think primate? I am leaning Herm with Jamie hammering, although I doubt he will.