Darren Sanders @ 19/4/2017 23:28

Vic had an investigative role. No telling what information he could have given us

DS has been my master this game. If he's scum I'll die just because I've followed his word as gospel

Angi @ 20/4/2017 7:36

CherryBerry @ 19/4/2017 22:11 Angi @ 19/4/2017 23:02 Christian @ 19/4/2017 19:05 Darren Sanders @ 19/4/2017 18:27 CHERRY STOP FUCKING KILLING We would have lynched Vic today most likely if he hadn't killed Vic last night. So saved us some time. :P Sorry Vic. This......is not even good logic If I hadn't killed Vic last night, who would we have lynched today? If the answer is Vic, then Christian is right. No Vig-kill last night N7: Mafia kills TIB D8: We lynch Vic N8: Mafia lynches ??? D9: We lynch Jamie? I Vig-killed Vic last night N7: Mafia kills TIB and I kill Vic D8: We lynch Jamie? It leaves no extra bodies, it just speeds it up a day. Instead maybe we will kill another townie because everyone is so good at that

The logic stands. You can get on my case for killing Town Vic, but you all would have lynched him the next day anyway.

It's Cherry's role to do with as he pleases. He saved us a whole day. Vic would most likely have been lynched. I say he should kill again tonight. Get in at least one last shot before Mafia takes Cherry out. There are 4 or 5 of us that are close to 100% confirmed Town. Cherry only has to pick one of the others tonight.

There will be 8 of us left going into the night. Tomorrow we start with 6 if both kills go through successfully. If Mafia has 1 member left, we're still in good standing. If Mafia has 2 members left, we still have a couple days to sort it out.

I stand by what DS had said. Killing Vic is meaningless in all of this. He's killing too many townies. Vic might have had useful information for us. He may have convinced us not to kill him. Very few people were SOLD on him as absolutely scum lol

Christian.....are you scum? ?? You seem unconcerned about all the town deaths

Vic was going to tell us who Zersch had visited. We can look at Zersch posts if we need that now.

Also, Curtis visited Christian and didn't die, so...

No posts in more than 3 hours. I think you can probably end the day.

Last final attempt since I'll be lynched, a mislynch on me probably isn't the worse thing if there is only one mafia left but if there are more and cherry keeps killing town, town will sadly lose the game

no disrespect to cherry, some of his kills make sense but not all. Merc seemed like a weird one, that one sticks out to me

Im definitely not sold on cherry as town. Continuing to kill at this point of the game makes no sense to me.

CherryBerry @ 20/4/2017 3:27

farlig @ 20/4/2017 7:22 Asking a rhetorical question gets you the answer it did. As to the why question, some people seek to confuse by voting a lot while others seek to vote only when they are pretty sure on their read or when it matters. You are rather new to this mafia thing. My not voting a lot each game is not. But on the contrary your vote could have mattered. Until Mittens' train finally picked up steam near the end of D1, it was a tight race, with potential mislynches in Curtis, me, and Miko. You voted on D2 when there were so many on Sock that a single vote was inconsequential. For a good portion of D3, it looked like we would mislynch Herm. Day 5 is another like Day 2 where the Scum lynch was inevitable. On D6, DS almost succeeded in getting me mislynched.

Mittens was also a mislynch btw

Christian @ 20/4/2017 3:59

It's Cherry's role to do with as he pleases. He saved us a whole day. Vic would most likely have been lynched. I say he should kill again tonight. Get in at least one last shot before Mafia takes Cherry out. There are 4 or 5 of us that are close to 100% confirmed Town. Cherry only has to pick one of the others tonight.

Mafia hasn't felt the need to take him out all game so why would we assume they will tonight?

Darren Sanders @ 20/4/2017 11:51

Christian @ 20/4/2017 3:59 It's Cherry's role to do with as he pleases. He saved us a whole day. Vic would most likely have been lynched. I say he should kill again tonight. Get in at least one last shot before Mafia takes Cherry out. There are 4 or 5 of us that are close to 100% confirmed Town. Cherry only has to pick one of the others tonight. Mafia hasn't felt the need to take him out all game so why would we assume they will tonight?

They definitely wouldn't take him out if they think they know his target and it's someone that is town.