Shadow

Denise is the best comeback from minority story of all winners

Denise's was cool for going to all TC's and getting down to two on her tribe, but I don't remember if she was like, way at the bottom of the totem pole all merge. I'm hazy on that entire merge tbh

CHRIS tho. Now there's a come from minority story. My fav

I like how no one's seen Fiji

Fiji is a classic but it sucks compared to other seasons

Vic @ 9/4/2017 11:18

Fiji is a classic but it sucks compared to other seasons

Well that doesn't sound classic at all!

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 9:19

Vic @ 9/4/2017 11:18 Fiji is a classic but it sucks compared to other seasons Well that doesn't sound classic at all!

I honestly think it's a classic.

Spoiler

+

You have an out of place Asian man who ends up being the mastermind of the season and the idol hunter. Lisi faceplanting The Dreamz and Yau Man story is iconic. Rocky is a massive character The season is completely made for me simply because of the 4 horsemen, the cockiness, idol shenanigans, and the reactions at the Edgardo blindside. Boo (the first spy shack maker, I might add) And Earl is someone who had great control throughout the game but played very subtle. He would have also played the first perfect game if he didn't get a random vote thrown his way. I think the bad reputation it gets is because of the have/have not style twist that almost seemed game breaking and also because this is a season that is like 19/20 mactors. The location is kind of gross when you think of Fiji as well.

Denise is someone I would actually be really excited to watch play again. I think she would be just as boring, but I'm interested in her job and how that helps her with people. I'd love to see how she fares a second time.

After Sandra I think Denise is the winner who has the best chance of winning again

I don't think Parvati is a good winner because if they hadn't made it a final 2 blindside Cirie would have won. Not really setting yourself up for the win.

I guess that's true. I like Parv's HVV game best. That game is better than most winners for me

Curtis @ 9/4/2017 9:45

After Sandra I think Denise is the winner who has the best chance of winning again

I always thought that if there would be another two time winner, it would have been Nat A because she wasn't overly flashy or threatening where I think she could slip utr and do it again. I told Jeff before he went out that Nat was a likely contender. Then she got swapped out last minute.

That's a good point about Cochran. I didn't really consider the pre-game relationships. I think Chris and Danni both deserve a lot of credit for coming back from 6-1. I also really love Danni's win because she basically lied in confessionals because she knew the producers wanted Stephenie to win. Really really smart.

Also! There's a theory out there that if Micronesia is a final 3, Amanda actually wins in a plurality. Theory is this:

Amanda: Erik, James, Ozzy,
Parvati: Natalie, Jason
Cirie: Alexis, Eliza

However, I do think Cirie could have gotten Erik's vote.

Discussion of it here: https://www.reddit.com/r/survivor/comments/5u5cuk/who_wins_if_micronesia_is_a_final_3/

Also we all know how Amanda tanks her game at FTC so I doubt she beats Cirie or Parv here. Especially since she lost to Parv the first time. But, if the votes split between Cirie and Parv and Amanda still gets the same votes, yeah I guess she could pull it out.

WEEK #3: Top Five Favorite Seasons

SOFTBALL. Something we discuss all the time

Which five seasons do you think are the best? What about them makes them great? Winner, characters, location, gameplay? Discuss

I was expecting a Top Five Uncomfortable Moments