FREE DARKUS @ 14/2/2017 14:36

One of tib and rose have to be scum. Roles are too similar

I disagree!

Unless he claimed otherwise, TIB is probably a rapper whistle or variant. He probably doesn't just stop attackers, but any role that visits and announces it. That role doesn't really make sense if it only catches killers. They're two completely different roles with completely different utilities and i know I'm town, and I think TIB's role would be town, so the TIB vs Rose thing feels really forced and manufactured just to spread doubts and distract

Grunkle Drrr @ 14/2/2017 15:57

FREE DARKUS @ 14/2/2017 14:36 One of tib and rose have to be scum. Roles are too similar I disagree! Unless he claimed otherwise, TIB is probably a rapper whistle or variant. He probably doesn't just stop attackers, but any role that visits and announces it. That role doesn't really make sense if it only catches killers. They're two completely different roles with completely different utilities and i know I'm town, and I think TIB's role would be town, so the TIB vs Rose thing feels really forced and manufactured just to spread doubts and distract

1 time BP and rape whistle are very similar. From our view point and the way you've played you can't seriously say you don't see how we can be suspicious of you

Christian would have to have created 2 town roles that basically can't be night killed. That would be a little OP'ed unless there are more than 1-2 AT left, and in my limited experience with his games, Christian seems like a pretty careful and organized mod.

Unless maybe he didn't think it was OP'ed with a poisoner and 1 time unstoppable kill on the mafia team.

## Vote Rose

oops!

## Lynch Rose

Primate (4/6) - Brian, Ahoda, farlig, Helios
Rose (2/6) - Ahoda, Darren Sanders, Primate
Helios (1/6) - Spin

Primate @ 14/2/2017 16:07

Christian would have to have created 2 town roles that basically can't be night killed. That would be a little OP'ed unless there are more than 1-2 AT left, and in my limited experience with his games, Christian seems like a pretty careful and organized mod. Unless maybe he didn't think it was OP'ed with a poisoner and 1 time unstoppable kill on the mafia team.

If there's no doc it makes sense though

One of the times I had a whistle blower role, I picked a target. Anyone who visited the target would be scared off by my whistle.

I would like tib to confirm that this isn't how his role works. If it is, We can probably look at someone other than rose.

FREE DARKUS @ 14/2/2017 15:14

Primate @ 14/2/2017 16:07 Christian would have to have created 2 town roles that basically can't be night killed. That would be a little OP'ed unless there are more than 1-2 AT left, and in my limited experience with his games, Christian seems like a pretty careful and organized mod. Unless maybe he didn't think it was OP'ed with a poisoner and 1 time unstoppable kill on the mafia team. If there's no doc it makes sense though

Yeah.
There is a bodyguard, but I haven't seen a poison doc/antivenin role yet, so it may not be OP'ed.

Primate @ 14/2/2017 16:17

FREE DARKUS @ 14/2/2017 15:14 Primate @ 14/2/2017 16:07 Christian would have to have created 2 town roles that basically can't be night killed. That would be a little OP'ed unless there are more than 1-2 AT left, and in my limited experience with his games, Christian seems like a pretty careful and organized mod. Unless maybe he didn't think it was OP'ed with a poisoner and 1 time unstoppable kill on the mafia team. If there's no doc it makes sense though Yeah. There is a bodyguard, but I haven't seen a poison doc/antivenin role yet, so it may not be OP'ed.

Don't think I've ever seen a poison doc when the poisoner is limited like mittens was

FREE DARKUS @ 14/2/2017 15:14

Primate @ 14/2/2017 16:07 Christian would have to have created 2 town roles that basically can't be night killed. That would be a little OP'ed unless there are more than 1-2 AT left, and in my limited experience with his games, Christian seems like a pretty careful and organized mod. Unless maybe he didn't think it was OP'ed with a poisoner and 1 time unstoppable kill on the mafia team. If there's no doc it makes sense though

I would think there has got to be a doc of some type out there. Well, more than just Farlig.

FREE DARKUS @ 14/2/2017 16:02

Grunkle Drrr @ 14/2/2017 15:57 FREE DARKUS @ 14/2/2017 14:36 One of tib and rose have to be scum. Roles are too similar I disagree! Unless he claimed otherwise, TIB is probably a rapper whistle or variant. He probably doesn't just stop attackers, but any role that visits and announces it. That role doesn't really make sense if it only catches killers. They're two completely different roles with completely different utilities and i know I'm town, and I think TIB's role would be town, so the TIB vs Rose thing feels really forced and manufactured just to spread doubts and distract 1 time BP and rape whistle are very similar. From our view point and the way you've played you can't seriously say you don't see how we can be suspicious of you

I absolutely see why. I expected to still be lynched yesterday actually. But I know I'm not scum and I'm convinced TIB isn't, which makes the WILL ONE OF EMS GOTTA BE really stand out as suspicious.

Primate @ 14/2/2017 16:07

Christian would have to have created 2 town roles that basically can't be night killed. That would be a little OP'ed unless there are more than 1-2 AT left, and in my limited experience with his games, Christian seems like a pretty careful and organized mod. Unless maybe he didn't think it was OP'ed with a poisoner and 1 time unstoppable kill on the mafia team.

I didn't want to point this out, but usually rape whistle is a one time deal, just stopping the first person to visit then AND OUTING THEIR VISIT, which is why it's different than just being BP. They work differently and have different utilities, even if they can both technically stop a kill. It's more like a PGO that doesn't kill than anything.

Lol that I got negged four times today

It's fine, I was too close to zero anyway

spindoctor02 @ 14/2/2017 11:36

Helios Garabandia @ 14/2/2017 13:34 Primate @ 14/2/2017 14:32 Helios Garabandia @ 14/2/2017 13:30 Primate @ 14/2/2017 14:25 Helios=Mafia bomb, imo We got eem boys. My offer for Rose yesterday is available to you. Lynch me, but you need to be the hammer. Meh, we still have time for the vig to get you, tbh. TBH, why are you scared? If you really think I'm Mafia (and you're the 'Nilla you claim you are), then you should be more than willing to give up your life to take mine. This is not good helios logic. The Law of Helios states that any town deaths are bad deaths, so using your statement, you say if he's town, he should be fine being taken out with other town. That's not abiding by the Law of Helios. ## Lynch Helios

Good point

Make that five times today