[img][/img]

V is for virtue, a trait you hold dear.

L is for loyalty, that you show.

A is for accord, the harmony you spread.

D is for diamond, the brilliance you shine.

Y is for young, the years never show!

ahoda @ 28/4/2016 9:52

Can't reason with you Vlady. You are too dead set on your path of town destruction. You are the early favorite for the honorary Chris HOL Award.

OK, I'll humor you. Vig killed JC. Mafia then clearly attacked Lamps, so he's not mafia. Nobody has reported a RB at all, so no SK floating around then.

We have exactly what to vote on? I'm happy to go back to Curtis and his overreacting on what I considered a joke post. We can just let Lamps be free to live on without question.

Tell me, who should I vote for, since Lamps is clean in your mind?

vladykins @ 28/4/2016 10:54

ahoda @ 28/4/2016 9:44 You are pushing like his is 100% scum Vlady. Don't act like you're not. I do question his claim but I tend to fall on the town side right now like I have said from the get go. Pressure him all you want. Lamps will be back and I'm sure he will respond to all the doubters. I'm waiting to hear it. For now I think you are pushing a scum agenda right now so you get my vote. Of course I think he is scum, like Vinicio, Harry, and Ida were. In my mind, unless he has a pretty damn good defense, I'll be happy to watch him go down. I could be wrong like I was with Dolly, but I don't think I am. What I find interesting is the people like yourself who are giving him a free pass without any question at all, who just go "Yeah, clearly the JC thing was vig." One person saying that I might buy (especially if that person was the vig softclaiming). But multiple people just buying into that doesn't seem suspicious to you at all, especially given how, as Ti9mmah already pointed out, the attack survivors in these games have almost always been BGs? That's why, in my mind, suddenly flipping seems more suspicious, except for the fact that it is so obvious that I don't want to believe it.

Timmah meta gamming doesn't make this instance mean Lamps is scum. I play each game as a separate entity. I think pushing Lamps is good. Please do. But you keeping saying he's definitely scum and I don't see it. I could be wrong. Then so be it. I suck at mafia and that's a known fact.

vladykins @ 28/4/2016 10:57

ahoda @ 28/4/2016 9:52 Can't reason with you Vlady. You are too dead set on your path of town destruction. You are the early favorite for the honorary Chris HOL Award. OK, I'll humor you. Vig killed JC. Mafia then clearly attacked Lamps, so he's not mafia. Nobody has reported a RB at all, so no SK floating around then. We have exactly what to vote on? I'm happy to go back to Curtis and his overreacting on what I considered a joke post. We can just let Lamps be free to live on without question. Tell me, who should I vote for, since Lamps is clean in your mind?

6 people haven't even posted yet. Why you rushing this day? Let it happen.

Wait!! Don't push Lamps to claim just yet. GEEZUS unless he's silly bullet proof, or scum, we don't need to out his role. What if he's something important.

It's been open for 14 hours in a 24 hour day phase.; it's not exactly rushing. :P

Angi @ 28/4/2016 11:01

Wait!! Don't push Lamps to claim just yet. GEEZUS unless he's silly bullet proof, or scum, we don't need to out his role. What if he's something important.

Angi verified scum with Lamps, Ahoda, and Curtis.

Timmah @ 28/4/2016 10:03

This is really pretty interesting. In 99.9% of the games over here, when someone survives a kill and there is not an accounted for reason, they get lynched. And about 90% of the time, they flip scum of some fashion. And rarely is there much push back from more than the person who survived and maybe 1-2 others. Contrast to this game, where Lamps survives a kill attempt and has 5-6 people defending him pretty damn hard.

Strange, because the last like five games I've played in here, everyone bitches if we target someone who survives a kill. Sometimes they're scum, sometimes they're bullet proof, sometimes they're the fucking doctor

Day 2 Vote Count:

Lamps (8/13) - Nofo, Merc, Eben, Bryce, Buffy, vladykins, Free Candy, Herm, Dadd
Eben (2/13) - Curtis, Dadd, Redster
Redster (1/13) - Canuck
Bryce (1/13) - Lamps
vladykins (1/13) - Ahoda


Deadline is 9:00pm est Thursday.

Hi checking in between classes so can't say much. I've mostly caught up though

Lamps's survival isnt that suspicious really. Night 1 there are a lot of reasons for someone to survive. The REACTION is really interesting though. It seems like a lot of pushing in both directions. The meta about survivals at FE always being scum is seeing off some red flags for me. Survivals usually get heat, but the reason so many we lynch flip scum is because we usually lynch when there's a good chance they are scum.

Also how often Lamps is the N1 target? I'm remembering Sherlock mafia and maybe one other before or after that, but otherwise I dunno. Can't check now tho

vladykins @ 28/4/2016 11:01

It's been open for 14 hours in a 24 hour day phase.; it's not exactly rushing. :P

I didn't say rushing, but fishing is scummy. And I was more directing my comment to Herm's posts a couple pages back. What if Lamps is the doctor.

That doesnt mean he can't be mafia doctor, I'm just saying, there are a lot of different reasons why he could have survived, town or scum reasons alike.

It seems cold hearted ... but if a Doc heals himself on N1 and gets hit ... his role is kind of ruined, no?