I've seen it both ways numerous times

Angi @ 15/1/2016 22:46

I've never played in a game where the player wasn't aware, that I can remember anyway. Even in Werewolf games, the Lycan was made aware of their role.

Thanks for repeating what everybody else already said. I get it. It's common. My point still holds, in that I don't buy the claim. It's too convenient.

Miller shouldn't be told but sometimes they are. And herm should have said he was miller D1. Now we will have to have this argument about him every day until he's dead.

Also no day kill was given out N1 so I would be cautious JC that it could backfire.

JC @ 16/1/2016 0:47

Angi @ 15/1/2016 22:46 I've never played in a game where the player wasn't aware, that I can remember anyway. Even in Werewolf games, the Lycan was made aware of their role. Thanks for repeating what everybody else already said. I get it. It's common. My point still holds, in that I don't buy the claim. It's too convenient.

How about............fuck off?

Angi @ 16/1/2016 0:54

JC @ 16/1/2016 0:47 Angi @ 15/1/2016 22:46 I've never played in a game where the player wasn't aware, that I can remember anyway. Even in Werewolf games, the Lycan was made aware of their role. Thanks for repeating what everybody else already said. I get it. It's common. My point still holds, in that I don't buy the claim. It's too convenient. How about............fuck off?

How about fuck me instead!

ahoda @ 16/1/2016 0:55

Angi @ 16/1/2016 0:54 JC @ 16/1/2016 0:47 Angi @ 15/1/2016 22:46 I've never played in a game where the player wasn't aware, that I can remember anyway. Even in Werewolf games, the Lycan was made aware of their role. Thanks for repeating what everybody else already said. I get it. It's common. My point still holds, in that I don't buy the claim. It's too convenient. How about............fuck off? How about fuck me instead!

Go fuck your wife

ahoda @ 15/1/2016 22:55

Angi @ 16/1/2016 0:54 How about............fuck off? How about fuck me instead!

I'd be down for a fuck-off between your two avis.

:)

JC @ 16/1/2016 1:00

ahoda @ 15/1/2016 22:55 Angi @ 16/1/2016 0:54 How about............fuck off? How about fuck me instead! I'd be down for a fuck-off between your two avis. :)

go be straight somewhere else

You got anything useful or game related to add? Or do you want to see the blunt end of my big hammer?

JC @ 16/1/2016 1:01

You got anything useful or game related to add? Or do you want to see the blunt end of my big hammer?

Yeah, you're still scum.

Nofo of December 2015 @ 15/1/2016 23:04

JC @ 16/1/2016 1:01 You got anything useful or game related to add? Or do you want to see the blunt end of my big hammer? Yeah, you're still scum.

That's what I figured. You've now moved ahead of Herm on my "Who wants a hammering" list. Congrats.

JC @ 16/1/2016 1:07

Nofo of December 2015 @ 15/1/2016 23:04 JC @ 16/1/2016 1:01 You got anything useful or game related to add? Or do you want to see the blunt end of my big hammer? Yeah, you're still scum. That's what I figured. You've now moved ahead of Herm on my "Who wants a hammering" list. Congrats.

OH YEAH????

##Shoot: JC

Ben @ 15/1/2016 21:30

This back and forth is making JC look bad. Where we played in the past rarely used the Miller role. But I think they are always aware.

I disagree. I think it makes Herm look bad based on words alone

What is a Miller though? I'm not familiar with the role.

Herm what did you actually get as leader? I find it suspect that you haven't come forward about this when our people elected you.

Leaving my vote on Curtis for now, that reply was horrid.

Top suspects for me include Angi, Herm and Badger