Dylan @ 4/11/2015 19:41

Ugh my phone posted early. Let me continue. Because I am on my phone it he has assumed stuff that scum could know but then later backtracked (I.e it being a redirection role today). Redster has been pretty worthless this game, but always seems to show up when he has to. Curtis jumped off ari's lynch but has been getting credit for starting it. I'd like to hear his thoughts today because he's been quiet. Hopefully none of you a-holes interrupted my thought

Oh right. Would be strange for Curtis to be scum if he started the lynch train on Ari.

Hermlappen @ 4/11/2015 17:52

Jay Isn't the goody two shoes of the game usually scum? I think his claim holds up, sounds believable to me. If it is indeed a fake claim, he can be a future lynch candidate. But there's still you and there's still Curtis.

I am town but feel free.

I'm all for a Jay lynch.

I'm still not sold on Wikey or Curtis from my suspicions from yesterday. But Jay sticks out to me right now as being scummy, I'd rather see JC shoot him.

Jayadamo @ 4/11/2015 17:56

Hermlappen @ 4/11/2015 17:52 Jay Isn't the goody two shoes of the game usually scum? I think his claim holds up, sounds believable to me. If it is indeed a fake claim, he can be a future lynch candidate. But there's still you and there's still Curtis. I am town but feel free.

Are you sure you're town?

Would you admit it if you weren't "town"

There should be 2-3 mafia among us.

Herm: Town
Canuck: Town Santa Claus
im317: Town Vigilante
JC: Town (holds Canuck's Gun)
Dylan: Softclaims Town role
Jayadamo: Says he's Town

Curtis: Seems to have started lynch train on Ari
Timmah: Was consistently suspicious of Ari.
Henry: He's hard to read, but I don't get a scum vibe.
Schrauben: He's also hard to read, suspicious of Ari yesterday but did not lynch him right away.
Wikey: Not sure
Redster: Not sure

Hermlappen @ 4/11/2015 18:02

There should be 2-3 mafia among us. Herm: Town Canuck: Town Santa Claus im317: Town Vigilante JC: Town (holds Canuck's Gun) Dylan: Softclaims Town role Jayadamo: Says he's Town Curtis: Seems to have started lynch train on Ari Timmah: Was consistently suspicious of Ari. Henry: He's hard to read, but I don't get a scum vibe. Schrauben: He's also hard to read, suspicious of Ari yesterday but did not lynch him right away. Wikey: Not sure Redster: Not sure

Well hell if that's all I got to do, to enforce the idea that I'm town with you, is admit I'm town, then be rest assured Herm.

I'm 100% pro-town!

## Lynch Jay

I'm still lynching Jay, I was just arguing from his pov to see who else could be scum if he is indeed town like he says.

##unlynch
##lynch Jayadamo

JC @ 4/11/2015 13:45

I asked anybody for evidence that Henry is town. I have seen nothing other than Wikey jumping to his defense stating things like "this is how he always is" and other garbage. If Henry turns up scum, I think we've found a partner.

As someone who has known Henry for years and seen him play countless mafia games, for someone new here to dismiss my claims as garbage is a little premature don't you think?

Let's get one thing straight, I am not defending Henry. I am trying to point out that you are essentially taking a shot in the dark by shooting him. Because he is ALWAYS antagonistic, he ALWAYS says dumb shit, and he NEVER contributes. Yes he might flip scum. But you could say the same if you line up any inactive in the game with no evidence against them and threaten to shoot them.

Meanwhile there are other targets who you can make a stronger case for. Dylan, Redster and Jay are three examples I can think of. I find it rather annoying that you asked for outside help on who to shoot, but as soon as someone suggests someone other than your original target, they are scummy and clearly protecting their scum buddy!

FUDadd

JC... If you shoot Herm or Wikey it would make my day.

Wikey @ 4/11/2015 20:13

Meanwhile there are other targets who you can make a stronger case for. Dylan, Redster and Jay are three examples I can think of. I find it rather annoying that you asked for outside help on who to shoot, but as soon as someone suggests someone other than your original target, they are scummy and clearly protecting their scum buddy!

I think he's just scumhunting.

Jayadamo @ 4/11/2015 20:15

JC... If you shoot Herm or Wikey it would make my day.

Don't shoot me, I am town.

Hermlappen @ 4/11/2015 18:17

Jayadamo @ 4/11/2015 20:15 JC... If you shoot Herm or Wikey it would make my day. Don't shoot me, I am town.

You have no problem lynching town so he should have no problem shooting you.