dr @ 29/10/2015 22:41

Someone tell me who to lynch

Pick one of the many "what if" scenarios and vote. Or make up your own scenario.

Wikey @ 29/10/2015 22:46

Jayadamo @ 29/10/2015 18:41 Wikey @ 29/10/2015 22:35 Hermlappen @ 29/10/2015 18:26 Canuck Stud jumped on Angi's joke lynch train on Vernon Day 1, seems like a stupid thing to do if they were both scum. I would give him the benefit of the doubt for now. Same thing regarding im317, he also jumped on the Vern train. I don't think he's scum either, would be surprised if lynching Vern Day 1 was a mafia tactic lol. It's nearly always impossible to get a read on anyone based on Day 1 shenanigans...people mess around every single time. Someone joke lynching a player who isn't even in the game is not evidence in their favour. I think the JC train is the best evidence we have at the moment. We should be looking at these people more. im, why did you choose JC specifically? Why not any other person who was quiet, like Chris, who you have just changed to? I still feel like you are protecting Buffy. Scum vote their buddies a lot on day 1 for a laugh. Buffy may not be scum but I really want to find out. Plus if she is scum that would give me the warm and fuzzy that you are too. If we lynch im I personally feel like I am getting less information. I am not protecting Buffy and I am not sure why you are suspicious of her...

Same reason I am suspicious of everyone. I don't know her role or alignment. All i can do is pick one of the guess and go with it. I like the idea of voting someone that voted scum day 1 and avoided being on a townie lynch. Can't prove I am right but also can't prove I am wrong. Everyone else can vote whoever they want. I am not trying to sway people to join me.

Hermlappen @ 29/10/2015 18:43

As much as people fuck around on Day 1, I think we can learn at least something from the fake Vernon lynch. Angi joked lynch Vernon, why would im317 jump on that train if both of them were scum and knew he wasn't playing? Same could be said about Canuck, who was also on that train/ and JC's train today. I don't think Henry woulda jumped that either if he was scum. Seems like a strange thing to do for im317 if he is scum.

In fairness, im317 seemed to really believe Vernon was in the game. He said so when he unlynched (unless that was a joke too!) You'd think he would be in on Angi's joke if he was on the same team.

But...again, I don't want to work with evidence which is based around a joke lynch. It's not very reliable.

I jumped on the Vernon lynch d1 as it seemed from the first game I played here that voting him d1 due to inactivity was a common occurrence, and with people using different names I didn't realize that he wasn't playing.

As for voting JC, I felt that timmah's reasoning was sound, and I don't know Wikey or Norbert, so I with the one I knew. As it looks like he was silenced, I do agree that he's not the right play today. Based on that I'm going to cast a vote based on my gut.

##henry

Jayadamo @ 29/10/2015 18:41

I still feel like you are protecting Buffy. Scum vote their buddies a lot on day 1 for a laugh. Buffy may not be scum but I really want to find out. Plus if she is scum that would give me the warm and fuzzy that you are too. If we lynch im I personally feel like I am getting less information.

Your reason for lynching me makes as much sense as Denmark's Zoo's reason for publicly dissecting animals in front of children. So everyone can see what's inside. The Lions did nothing wrong but let's cut them open anyway!

If I had done something scummy it would make sense to go a step further and say - oh maybe she was distancing. But, just the fact that I voted for scum on Day 1 is a bad reason to lynch someone that is an active contributor as town, which I am. It's a valid thing to consider possibly distancing but just to lynch me because of it is pretty lame.

Sorry.

##unlynch JC
##lynch henry

Wikey @ 29/10/2015 18:55

Hermlappen @ 29/10/2015 18:43 As much as people fuck around on Day 1, I think we can learn at least something from the fake Vernon lynch. Angi joked lynch Vernon, why would im317 jump on that train if both of them were scum and knew he wasn't playing? Same could be said about Canuck, who was also on that train/ and JC's train today. I don't think Henry woulda jumped that either if he was scum. Seems like a strange thing to do for im317 if he is scum. In fairness, im317 seemed to really believe Vernon was in the game. He said so when he unlynched (unless that was a joke too!) You'd think he would be in on Angi's joke if he was on the same team. But...again, I don't want to work with evidence which is based around a joke lynch. It's not very reliable.

i honestly thought Vernon was playing when i voted for him. it was a stupid assumption on my part.

I gotta go for a bit, don't know when the day is supposed to end.

But I'd be happy with a lynch on either im317 or Canuck. Primate as a close second.

It's reasonable to assume that JC is telling the truth and was silenced, and that he was silenced by scum. If we believe that, then scum would probably have been looking to take advantage of that. I'd be amazed if at least one of those three aren't scum.

Buffy @ 29/10/2015 22:56

Jayadamo @ 29/10/2015 18:41 I still feel like you are protecting Buffy. Scum vote their buddies a lot on day 1 for a laugh. Buffy may not be scum but I really want to find out. Plus if she is scum that would give me the warm and fuzzy that you are too. If we lynch im I personally feel like I am getting less information. Your reason for lynching me makes as much sense as Denmark's Zoo's reason for publicly dissecting animals in front of children. So everyone can see what's inside. The Lions did nothing wrong but let's cut them open anyway! If I had done something scummy it would make sense to go a step further and say - oh maybe she was distancing. But, just the fact that I voted for scum on Day 1 is a bad reason to lynch someone that is an active contributor as town, which I am. It's a valid thing to consider possibly distancing but just to lynch me because of it is pretty lame.

You talk as if anybody that votes will have a solid reason.

You missed my point about the poor lions!

Buffy @ 29/10/2015 23:02

You missed my point about the poor lions!

No I didn't. I enjoyed your post and agree they are similar.

It was a joke...

I like my herm vote

I think this is correct. Thanks Herm for paying attention!

Day 2 Vote Count

Buffy (2/11) - Ari, Jayadamo
Wikey (2/11) - Primate, Dylan
Chris (2/11) - Dylan, JC, im317, Herm
im317 (2/11) - JC, JC, Wikey, Buffy
Herm (1/11) - Ahoda
Henry (1/11) - JC, CanuckStud
Redster (0/11) - Buffy, JC, JC, JC
JC (0/11) - Timmah, CanuckStud, im317, Primate
CanuckStud (0/11) - JC, JC
Primate (0/11) - JC
Jaydamo (0/11) - JC
Schrauben (0/11) - Herm, JC
Dylan (0/11) - Ari
Nobert (0/11) - Herm, JC, JC, JC

2 hours 11 minutes left

Just over an hour left.

There's not much time and four players are tied in the vote. This is not good. Start voting people!