I have no evidence that Rose is the jailer, just wanted to say it.

But yeah...

##Lynch Redster

If he is town, his role has more than served its purpose by absorbing two attacks now. Nobody would be stupid enough to take another shot at him, so there is no danger in claiming as far as I'm concerned.

His reluctance to do so makes me think he is fibbing.

@badger yeah yeah k, just dont fraud-quote anymore plz cuz i honestly thought you quoted my other post, my fault.

Daniel @ 12/10/2015 14:53

BadgerMcBeaver @ 12/10/2015 18:42 FREE CANDY @ 12/10/2015 8:54 Redster @ 12/10/2015 8:39 FREE CANDY @ 12/10/2015 6:26 Redster should of been lynched yesterday. However let's get rid of this monster, ##lynch beaver. What do you have on beaver? You have infos? i thought beaver's posts on day 2, post 11, 19 and 248, were interesting. if you go back and read post 214, i wanted to see if i could draw out beaver with a response, but nothing. I decided to RB beaver, but it failed. remember, a kidnap happens prior to most everything else in night action resolution. i think beaver is part of the kidnapping and deciding to kill one or the other. Oh, noticed this after I posted that. I haven't gone back and looked at those specific posts yet, but I'll get around to it in a bit once Im at my desktop. For the record I do believe that you tried to roleblock me because my role specifies that I can't be roleblocked. But you are wrong about me being jailer, I have a town role and I can reveal more if you guys insist on me claiming but I don't think it's a good idea unless absolutely necessary. TBH though, i think u have revealed enough in this post and im INCLINED to believe you. U should rly try to start considering the option that i am not scum, too, though. Scum will post however ppl are expected to post, i post whatever the fuck i want. Think about it. ##unlynch badger

Didn't see this post when I made my last one.

I am unsure as to whether or not you are scum, I could see it being either way but I'm thinking it's less likely now than I did before. I will not be voting you as of now.

What is fraud quoting?

Redster has survived two attacks in a row, seemingly from the same faction. He was definitely targeted by the faction that did not jail anyone Night 1, and the only other kill was Curtis on Night 2 (most likely by a Vig).

I'm never really sure about Henry, still think he's scum.

Shadow and Timmah have played enough games and it just feels weird to me that they are having a hard time buying Redster's claim. I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that all three of them are mafia. Boc has also been pretty suspicious this game.

Shadow, Boc, Henry and Timmah are probably all mafia. Let's throw im317 into the mix as well and we got a fully functional scum team. You only have to look at their posts and their lynches (not one of them lynched Vernon Day 1 at a time when he was never in any danger).

Henry lynched him at the end, the others who did vote lynched someone random.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 12/10/2015 22:21

What is fraud quoting?

quoting half a post, it made it look like the other post to me somehow, and can take it out of context (not applicable here tho). Could be cuz im mobile and had little time to read that day.

Herm @ 12/10/2015 16:21

Shadow and Timmah have played enough games and it just feels weird to me that they are having a hard time buying Redster's claim.

What claim?

He hasn't claimed anything!

It definitely is hard to buy someone surviving two attacks whilst claiming to be town, but at the same time not claiming to be BP town. Yesterday, I gave Redster the benefit of the doubt, because I thought it was possible he was the doctor. But that clearly isn't the case anymore...

Herm @ 12/10/2015 16:21

and the only other kill was Curtis on Night 2 (most likely by a Vig).

Why on earth would a vig go after Curtis? That would be scummy as fuck. Not a single thing he said yesterday would have justified a vig taking a shot at him. He was clearly town, and if a vig did in fact shoot him, then they are a god damn idiot!

You are looking pretty scummy too right now Herm!

Daniel @ 12/10/2015 13:25

quoting half a post, it made it look like the other

I do that all the time, what's the problem? If I want to respond to a specific sentence in a big post I delete the rest to get rid of the clutter. You guys and your pyramid quotes on this board make my fucking eyes hurt.

Someone with an axe went after Curtis Night 2, someone with dogs went after Redster nights 1 and 2.

I only quote what I want to reply to as well.

And I didn't mean claim, Wikey. Sorry.

No worries Herm!

But flavor isn't evidence. Unless the rules state otherwise, it's just flavor, right?

Unless the hosts specifically state otherwise, It's just random bullshit they make up. That's how it works every other game.

Wikey @ 12/10/2015 22:30

Herm @ 12/10/2015 16:21 Shadow and Timmah have played enough games and it just feels weird to me that they are having a hard time buying Redster's claim. What claim? He hasn't claimed anything! It definitely is hard to buy someone surviving two attacks whilst claiming to be town, but at the same time not claiming to be BP town. Yesterday, I gave Redster the benefit of the doubt, because I thought it was possible he was the doctor. But that clearly isn't the case anymore... Herm @ 12/10/2015 16:21 and the only other kill was Curtis on Night 2 (most likely by a Vig). Why on earth would a vig go after Curtis? That would be scummy as fuck. Not a single thing he said yesterday would have justified a vig taking a shot at him. He was clearly town, and if a vig did in fact shoot him, then they are a god damn idiot! You are looking pretty scummy too right now Herm!

Lol whether you agreed with it or not, Curtis got quite some heat yesterday. Don't see the need to attack Herm like this based on your read of Curtis.

I do agree with Herm that it is quite likely, based on N1 kills.

@ Herm, Buffy didn't vote to lynch Vern on D1 either. Hell, I called her out on it and it started our fight. And then she flipped town!!!

And why are we supposed to believe Redster right now? He's claimed nothing but that he's town, while surviving 2 attacks. I tried to get Curtis to shoot him yesterday, and he had enough support to avoid that and the lynch. And then he survived again!!! Why is he auto-town in your book, such that anyone not believing him must be mafia? That logic does not compute.

Boc, Angi, rose, JC and nofo all laying low today. I'm giving Cannuck a day because its holiday where he is, but no more freebies after today.

Buffy and I discussed Boc during our captivity. I told her that I didn't like his hammer of gmaj, and she told me that she couldn't see him doing that and getting the attention if he's scum. However, she also said that she'd had a scum vibe from him other than the hammer.