Jimmy uhh, Baker @ 24/10/2013 15:33

Okay, I've thought about this. Anyone who believes I am SK, explain how you DON'T believe Curtis is SK. Facts we know: 1. Angi is cop, not paranoid or naive (her scans of Jen and Rob were accurate as town and mafia, respectively) 2. Angi scanned Curtis and he came up scum 3. Curtis led the lynch on Godfather Ari on day 2 From that we can ONLY deduce that Curtis is third party. He's indisputably the serial killer.

I don't believe it because SK scans as/would scan as role-less town... or else third party I guess?

Yeah, Angi scanning Curtis as scum doesn't prove he is the SK. I have never known a SK to scan as scum. Not really helping your case to be honest Roos :\

Also, I still stand by my vic lynch on day 1. I went with my gut (that post Boc pointed out was and still reads as suspicious)

Lamps @ 24/10/2013 14:46

Jimmy uhh, Baker @ 24/10/2013 13:31 Angi, if I live, scan me tonight. SKs scan as a roleless towny, or at least that was the case last game... so that'd kind of be a waste of a scan either way.

Then how has Curtis scanned as scum?

I mean, since he pushed for the Ari lynch on day 2, I'm assuming he isn't mafia, and if SK does scan as town, WUT @ Curtis's scan result

In fairness to Roos, no argument can be made based on the likelihood of him been targeted. Because as he says, he WAS targeted.

And maybe he isn't such an unrealistic option. He has been pretty active and involved for much of the game. But I don't know if he had done enough to earn protection.

He claims that he protected himself. But this claim really really bothers me. When a player can have the choice to kill, protect, scan, roleblock every night, something is up. It is a crazy claim if it isn't true, but sometimes they are the best kind.

Quote

When a player can have the choice to kill, protect, scan, roleblock every night, something is up.

Then something being up has to do with Korr, not me. (:

Curtis @ 24/10/2013 3:38

And it isn't about doubting Angi at all. Putting full faith in role results isn't gonna work every time. It's so easy for it to be bussed. It was easy to follow up on it with Rob because he was already acting very scummy. I don't see how you guys can think I'm scum based on my actions Mafia bus driver could've very easily bussed me with one of their own last night since I (should be!) seen as pro town based on what I've done. If that person was investigated or attacked, it goes to me. If I was scanned, goes to them and I take the fall for it The mafia caught a break with Angi's results and they're gonna jump on my train because no one will blame them once I flip town. The evidence against Russ is so much stronger

Angi

All of this makes complete sense except one thing Why would they suspect you'd be scanned since your actions have indeed been very pro town?

This is a good point, however, maybe scum were expecting one of their own to be targeted last night, and hoped to bus the kill to Curtis. Just a thought.

Curtis is giving me town vibes. As I have said, he usually tries to play it cool if he is lying. Unless he is changing his game on us!

Jimmy uhh, Baker @ 24/10/2013 15:06

Quote When a player can have the choice to kill, protect, scan, roleblock every night, something is up. Then something being up has to do with Korr, not me. (:

What is your role title, if you are allowed to say so? Is it just jack of all trades?

Town Jack

:|

Not Super Jack or anything.

Ok...

##Unlynch

Not wholly convinced either way now.

Still bothers me that there was only 1 kill last night, with no explanation. Two is the norm, and that appears to be true in this game too.

Night 1:

Zersch died probably from a failed recruitment

Paco and Matt were killed by the mafia and SK. Nothing in their roles indicates otherwise to me. Roos has claimed not to have had anything to do with either of these kills. So unless Patrick used his unstoppable kill before he died (unlikely), then there was definitely and SK killing on night 1.

Night 2:

Jen died, and Roos claims to have killed her. Matt was killed, probably by Patrick, who then bore the brunt of Matt's bomb. There was no other kill. SK's usually target someone every night. So what happened? Did they get roleblocked or something? You would think someone would have come forward with such vital info by now if so.

Night 3: Only Roos is attacked. The mafia probably targeted him, but where is the other kill we have come to expect?

You know, as I am writing this, this makes less and less sense. I don't know if this supports Roos's claim or makes him look worse (:

Because, if he was going to claim Jack when infact he was SK, he might as well say he targeted Paco on Night 1 too, wouldn't he?

I am tempted to say that if there is a roleblocker out there who can shed some light on this, it might be best to speak up.

Cause that is the only thing that can explain the missing kill for me right now, and probably point us to the right person.

Quote

Night 3: Only Roos is attacked. The mafia probably targeted him, but where is the other kill we have come to expect?

I've been assuming they BOTH targeted me, but it's probably more likely that one of them was roleblocked.

If so, roleblocker really needs to speak up.

Oh though ... that wouldn't at all be conclusive. SK and mafia could both have targeted me, and roleblocker could have targeted someone else entirely.

Still, it would be useful information.