JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:39

If Christian and Nav are both scum they're not the same faction - IMO Christian SK Nav Mafia or vv

if the consensus is that I have to be some kind of scum, which I understand as the numbers dwindle and process of elimination and all, I will gladly take the lynch. But let's end Nav first, so I can be a part of it.

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:42

Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:41 itsbrianyay @ 30/11/2018 20:15 What happens if an SK gets vanilla’d I would assume nothing at all. I think Merc said killing roles would keep their killing role, and I can't imagine they'd just convert to town, since I couldn't see Mafia converting to Town and knowing who the rest of the Mafia were. He also said they wouldn't change factions.

I didn't remember reading that part, and wouldn't know where to start looking for what he said. lol

so we should have had two attacks last night, which we did. Assuming Mafia and SK at first. Then Primate says he tried to kill Nav, but it failed. So then the two attacks from last night most likely were from Mafia and SK, no?

Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:49

so we should have had two attacks last night, which we did. Assuming Mafia and SK at first. Then Primate says he tried to kill Nav, but it failed. So then the two attacks from last night most likely were from Mafia and SK, no?

Unless the Primate's failed attempt was the survival. We never heard from Maddie if she was notified of a failed attempt and whether that was just listed as "unsuccessful." Maybe Mafia blocked the SK.

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:51

Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:49 so we should have had two attacks last night, which we did. Assuming Mafia and SK at first. Then Primate says he tried to kill Nav, but it failed. So then the two attacks from last night most likely were from Mafia and SK, no? Unless the Primate's failed attempt was the survival. We never heard from Maddie if she was notified of a failed attempt and whether that was just listed as "unsuccessful." Maybe Mafia blocked the SK.

why are you assuming that Mafia blocked the SK?

or I should say why are you assuming the roleblocker is bad?

##lynch Nav

Pretty obvious he’s caught right?

Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:53

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:51 Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:49 so we should have had two attacks last night, which we did. Assuming Mafia and SK at first. Then Primate says he tried to kill Nav, but it failed. So then the two attacks from last night most likely were from Mafia and SK, no? Unless the Primate's failed attempt was the survival. We never heard from Maddie if she was notified of a failed attempt and whether that was just listed as "unsuccessful." Maybe Mafia blocked the SK. why are you assuming that Mafia blocked the SK?

I'm saying, if Primate attempted to kill Nav but Nav survived and that was the "someone survived an attack" that was listed, then the other kill was SK or Mafia. So, if one went through, and the other was blocked, it makes more sense that SK was blocked since Mafia probably has a RB. The Town RB is dead.

Unless you think Primate is lying, his failed killed was due to something else, or Mafia/SK both killed the same person?

##Lynch Nav

I never trusted Nav since Day 1. I'm so confident that he's not a good guy. And I'm not missing out on this action, even if it's the last thing I do in this game. :P

Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:54

or I should say why are you assuming the roleblocker is bad?

Mittens had a 3X RB - do you think we had that and a full RB role for town?

Christian, why would you be okay with being the lynch?

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:56

Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:53 JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:51 Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:49 so we should have had two attacks last night, which we did. Assuming Mafia and SK at first. Then Primate says he tried to kill Nav, but it failed. So then the two attacks from last night most likely were from Mafia and SK, no? Unless the Primate's failed attempt was the survival. We never heard from Maddie if she was notified of a failed attempt and whether that was just listed as "unsuccessful." Maybe Mafia blocked the SK. why are you assuming that Mafia blocked the SK? I'm saying, if Primate attempted to kill Nav but Nav survived and that was the "someone survived an attack" that was listed, then the other kill was SK or Mafia. So, if one went through, and the other was blocked, it makes more sense that SK was blocked since Mafia probably has a RB. The Town RB is dead. Unless you think Primate is lying, his failed killed was due to something else, or Mafia/SK both killed the same person?

I'm more suspicious of Nav than Primate at this point. I don't think the someone surviving an attack would be shown if Primate's action didn't go through.
Also, Mittens was a JOAT.

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:58

Christian, why would you be okay with being the lynch?

because I understand that it will become necessary at some point. I don't want it to be today though.

Christian @ 30/11/2018 21:01

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:56 Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:53 JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:51 Christian @ 30/11/2018 20:49 so we should have had two attacks last night, which we did. Assuming Mafia and SK at first. Then Primate says he tried to kill Nav, but it failed. So then the two attacks from last night most likely were from Mafia and SK, no? Unless the Primate's failed attempt was the survival. We never heard from Maddie if she was notified of a failed attempt and whether that was just listed as "unsuccessful." Maybe Mafia blocked the SK. why are you assuming that Mafia blocked the SK? I'm saying, if Primate attempted to kill Nav but Nav survived and that was the "someone survived an attack" that was listed, then the other kill was SK or Mafia. So, if one went through, and the other was blocked, it makes more sense that SK was blocked since Mafia probably has a RB. The Town RB is dead. Unless you think Primate is lying, his failed killed was due to something else, or Mafia/SK both killed the same person? I'm more suspicious of Nav than Primate at this point. I don't think the someone surviving an attack would be shown if Primate's action didn't go through. Also, Mittens was a JOAT.

Yeah, but he had 3X RB still. Also, I'm not saying I don't believe Primate - I do believe him.

Christian @ 30/11/2018 21:02

JJ @ 30/11/2018 20:58 Christian, why would you be okay with being the lynch? because I understand that it will become necessary at some point. I don't want it to be today though.

So, your claim is going to be suspect?