thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:15

Buffy @ 27/8/2017 15:11 Curtis @ 27/8/2017 17:05 If I was scum with 317 and wasn't really silenced then I could've won no problem yesterday. The vote was 2-1. All I'd have to do is vote at the last second to tie it 2-2 for 317, then there's a no lynch Spin dies leaving: 317 TiB Curtis Buffy Zersch If it was me/317 then we'd just have to speed lynch TiB if he really was Hated. Game over rip. TiB's mafia and didn't have that option because him and 317 couldn't have done anything on that five person day If that doesn't convince you then I'm not sure what will This is a good point. What do you have to say about this TIB? Also, I was refreshing for the last 15 minutes or so yesterday and saw you viewing and I was half expecting you and Zersch to swoop in and hammer if we were wrong about 317. I think they must have screwed up with the watch otherwise I have no idea. I can only speak for myself.

What do you mean screwed up?

I also totally don't believe Curtis modified claim that makes it perfect for mafia to not kill him.

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:20

If I was with Jamie, why vote him and have him reveal my eventual role? That's a risky long con.

What's the risk? It's been nothing but beneficial for you

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:22

I also totally don't believe Curtis modified claim that makes it perfect for mafia to not kill him.

That's exactly the same case with a Hated role ploy since scum would never bother killing one and town can't test a lynch on without killing the person

Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:23

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:20 If I was with Jamie, why vote him and have him reveal my eventual role? That's a risky long con. What's the risk? It's been nothing but beneficial for you

How do you figure. It's pretty much why anyone thought anything about me. As a plan it would have been terrible. Staying under the radar would be much better

Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:24

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:22 I also totally don't believe Curtis modified claim that makes it perfect for mafia to not kill him. That's exactly the same case with a Hated role ploy since scum would never bother killing one and town can't test a lynch on without killing the person

Difference is mine is a straight hated townie, not a role I made up to explain why I wasn't night killed.

Plus your hair looks funny

Buffy, we can go back and forth all day, but ultimately you gotta go with what u think. You can vote me and lose, or vote Curtis and wait for z.

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:27

Buffy, we can go back and forth all day, but ultimately you gotta go with what u think. You can vote me and lose, or vote Curtis and wait for z.

TIB I just want you to sell why Curtis is scum and not you. I realize I can vote whenever but I think it's fair to get as much info as possible. If the deadline was in 2 minutes, I'd be lynching you.

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:25

Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:23 thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:20 If I was with Jamie, why vote him and have him reveal my eventual role? That's a risky long con. What's the risk? It's been nothing but beneficial for you How do you figure. It's pretty much why anyone thought anything about me. As a plan it would have been terrible. Staying under the radar would be much better

You were very UTR godfather for the first half of the game, I don't remember you contributing a whole lot at the start (another reason why it makes no sense for Mafia Cop Jamie to decide to scan you out of everyone). And you were still under the radar with the plan in place, all Jamie did was "confirm" the existence of a Hated Townie in the game because that's what you were posing as. It didn't bring you into the limelight or anything

Jamie and the rest of the mafia would've chosen the roles for him to announce very carefully and there's be a reason for each one. The masons were to get JJ/Spin to vouch for Jamie which worked, the Strongman was probably because they scanned another townie role, and Hated was to help give a cover story to their godfather

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:26

Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:24 thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:22 I also totally don't believe Curtis modified claim that makes it perfect for mafia to not kill him. That's exactly the same case with a Hated role ploy since scum would never bother killing one and town can't test a lynch on without killing the person Difference is mine is a straight hated townie, not a role I made up to explain why I wasn't night killed. Plus your hair looks funny

The first part is poo but I'll give you the hair thing. I won best hair in 12th grade but didn't deserve it

I'd like you to explain why I wouldn't have tied the vote for 317 yesterday if I was scum. That would've been victory

Buffy @ 27/8/2017 15:29

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:27 Buffy, we can go back and forth all day, but ultimately you gotta go with what u think. You can vote me and lose, or vote Curtis and wait for z. TIB I just want you to sell why Curtis is scum and not you. I realize I can vote whenever but I think it's fair to get as much info as possible. If the deadline was in 2 minutes, I'd be lynching you.

I understand, I just feel like I'm going over the same stuff over and over. My name has been thrown out for last few days. It just gets tiring is all, it's nothing against you, just from my point of view it's just dragging out.

I know you believe him over me and I dunno what to say about it. I am who I said and if you vote me town loses. It's a lot of pressure and I'm glad I'm not inyour position

Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:32

I'd like you to explain why I wouldn't have tied the vote for 317 yesterday if I was scum. That would've been victory

I don't see why I should have to explain how the mafia team screwed up yesterday. I'm town I have no idea why you do what you do.


I think what you guys don't realize that I'm innocent. All I can explain is my motives. I have no idea why others do what they do.

Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:31

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:26 Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:24 thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:22 I also totally don't believe Curtis modified claim that makes it perfect for mafia to not kill him. That's exactly the same case with a Hated role ploy since scum would never bother killing one and town can't test a lynch on without killing the person Difference is mine is a straight hated townie, not a role I made up to explain why I wasn't night killed. Plus your hair looks funny The first part is poo but I'll give you the hair thing. I won best hair in 12th grade but didn't deserve it

Low blow on my part. Your hair looks great man.

thisisbad @ 27/8/2017 17:35

Curtis @ 27/8/2017 15:32 I'd like you to explain why I wouldn't have tied the vote for 317 yesterday if I was scum. That would've been victory I don't see why I should have to explain how the mafia team screwed up yesterday. I'm town I have no idea why you do what you do. I think what you guys don't realize that I'm innocent. All I can explain is my motives. I have no idea why others do what they do.

We're just asking you to rationalize how I can be scum under certain conditions. The reason most things aren't adding up great for me being scum is because it's not the case