Zersch @ 20/8/2017 22:59

Oh and for the record I didn't just waste the mirror for shits and giggles, I didn't have a choice and it could only be used on myself.

What was it supposed to do?

Timmah @ 20/8/2017 23:01

THE GREAT DR @ 20/8/2017 21:59 Timmah @ 20/8/2017 22:59 If lamps is scum, so is 317. In my non expert opinion Why's that? It was something I was thinking yesterday while,reading back on lamps posts

don't tie me to him.

Angi tied herself to timmah yesterday. Not sure if they are scum together, or if she knows he's Town and is trying to get credit.

JJ @ 20/8/2017 21:05

Zersch @ 20/8/2017 22:59 Oh and for the record I didn't just waste the mirror for shits and giggles, I didn't have a choice and it could only be used on myself. What was it supposed to do?

He watches himself

Curtis - I would never leave you out. :)

Spoiler

+

D1: Joke posts. Talks about Ahoda as scum. Jokes. Treestumps. Lynches Nofo, unlynches, tells him to stop signing up. (Nothing stands out) D2: Asks about how Farlig is claiming to be blocked. Thinks Patrick dying because he didn't realize plurality was on was hilarious/most Patrick thing to do. Talks about Merc's survival and whether day killer is vig or sk. Some jokes about the Rose/Shadow interactions. 6:14am Lynches Maddie in the morning after seeing Zersch's posts that she's mafia. 6:22am Curtis Farlig being blocked on a 1 kill night has been suspiciously brushed to the side in favor of focusing on Merc's survival it seems. Fishy fishy. Feels coordinated to me Talks about Farlig coming out about block to get ahead of it since there was only 1 kill. Continues to talk about Farlig. Says Ahoda is member of mafia. 11:04am Curtis I'm not sure how anyone is reading Maddie's posts as anything but scummy. Vig should kill her or Ahoda today imo 12:00pm - Merc killed, flips SK/Hex Girl (Curtis's vote is on Maddie at this point) 12:08pm Curtis Shadow for odd night SK and hit Merc and joined a forum with him, hence missing kill? Talks about Hex Girl info after Merc killed. Ahoda points out Vlady breadcrumbing. 12:52pm Curtis Kill Shadow or Vlady and lynch Maddie imo Badabing bocabooda! lol'd (again): Quote Curtis @ 11/8/2017 13:25 Maddie list all of your scum buddies in alphabetical order Quote Actually no, favorite to least favorite. Let's see some drama 2:29pm Curtis I'd maybe shoot Vlady over shadow at this point, vlady's goth talk is pretty damming and I can buy shadow as a frustrated young man 5:11pm (after Maddie killed/flips) Curtis lol I expected mafia bus driver at least Anyone push hard for Vic earlier? Mafia probably thought they blocked SK Vic at the start of today Lynches Vlady, FOS's Brian as goth girl (I'm guessing as joke tho) Quote Merc was definitely the mafia attack yes. Wasn't SK and wasn't Vig VOTE COUNT DAY 2 Vlady (14/14): Shadow, Rose, Ahoda, Curtis, Primate, Christian, Dadd, im, Lamps, Angi, Vic, DS, Mittens, JJ Farlig (0/14): Vic, DS Shadow (1/14): Ben, Ahoda, Primate, Spin, Maddie Sock (1/14): Herm Curtis (1/14): Sock Farlig (0/14): Primate DS (0/14): Ahoda Maddie (0/14): Zersch, Curtis, Jamie, Ben, Im, Shadow, Lamps, DS Merc (0/14): DS, Mittens Vlady has been lynched. (5 pages of posts but many were just jokes/filler. Doesn't really look too bad this day. Lynched Maddie right away but it was a foregone conclusion that Maddie would be killed or lynched, given Zersch's info. He did suggest either Maddie or Ahoda be killed but could've been joking about Ahoda. Most of this day was focused on Hex Girls after Maddie died so can't really draw many conclusions about Mafia as Vlady's train would have mafia, town and also had Shadow.) D3: Zersch asks im317 whats up, buddy. Curtis lynches him right away: Quote Lawl ##Lynch 317 Then says maybe it was just Zersch saying hi because he saw im317 viewing player list. Jokes. Says Ahoda is mafia. Asks Primate why he's scum with Timmah. (so does Curtis). Primate says Curtis/Timmah both tried to push on Merc without voting him, like mafia who missed a kill might do. Curtis says he wasn't pushing on Merc, then Primate says he had Curtis confused with someone else. More joke posts. Curtis Ahoda Mittens Shadow im317 assuming I was reading Zersch's post right Daykill/shoot/lynch three of them. It's the new kill/fuck/marry Quotes one of Mittens posts as looking scummy. Quotes one of TIB's posts as looking scummy. Talks about whether someone got a note from Shadow. Says Ahoda calling for Shadow to be killed quickly looks bad, as if he wanted him killed before Shadow could speak. (Ahoda also called for Jamie to be killed quickly in that post) Analysis of Herm's posts after he is killed, saying he didn't pick up on any watcher hints. Talks about Shadow more, and Herm's role. Shadow says he sent Vic a note but was blocked. Curtis asks for the flavor of the roleblock. Asks for name of Shadow's role. Unlynches im317 (after Zersch said he didn't have anything on him.) Lynches Shadow. Quotes JJ's "wtf Brian" post (after Brian killed Herm) and says these posts are confusing him. Spin says he thinks "they" think Brian is daykiller and Curtis says he assumed it too but didn't know why so many people jumped on that opinion so suddenly. Thought he missed something. Jokes with Shadow about not lynching him if he'll kill himself. More jokes. Says he's town in response to JJ asking him to make statement. Speculates that whoever blocked Farlig didn't block Shadow, if Shadow is telling the truth, because flavor is different. Agrees with theory that DS could've been jailed. VOTE COUNT DAY 3 Quote Shadow (9/13): Lamps, Mittens, Primate, Curtis, Jamie, DR, im, Ahoda, Spin, Christian Ahoda (5/13): Timmah, Brian, Mittens, Dadd, Shadow, DR Jamie (0/13): Mittens, Shadow Mittens (1/13): Vic DS (0/13): Spin Angi (0/13): Jamie Im317 (0/13): Curtis Herm (0/13): Brian Shadow has been lynched. (5 pages of posts again, ugh. Suspects that day were Ahoda, Mittens, Shadow, im317. All but 1 has flipped either town or 3p. The one who hasn't, im317, he lynched immediately after Zersch asked im317 what's up, as if he had info. So, he could either be town thinking Zersch knows im317 is scum or scum, feeling he needs to lynch to look good if Zersch has info. Either way, not really conclusive except that none of his other 3 reads were mafia and Shadow was obvious lynch that day, anyway.) D4: (only 3 pages this time, thank God) Starts out with statement in response to Spin saying he has a lie detector and wants everyone to say if they're town or scum.: Quote I'M TOWN MOFUGGAS Quote Mittens Ahoda Scum Goodnight Quote ##Lynch Ahoda now gn Responds to Timmah that about adding words to his "I am town" statement, points out he already said it without add-ins day before. Lynches Dadd after Spin says he got lying result on his "I am town" statement. Questions Spin a bit about whether he isolated the statement. Defends Spin when someone says he could be making up the result as a ploy to get Dadd killed. Thinks false lie detector could be from Mafia Jack who also silenced DS. Unlynches after Brian kills Dadd. Jamie claims Psychic. Curtis asks: Quote Did Jamie say it was random or did he say he has to ask a specific one? I can't imagine you would have to ask for a specific role name. I guess that's kinda fun and different but with some role names adapted to fit flavor or meaning new things in the game that'd be kinda meh In response to people discussing the "random" aspect of Jamie's role claim. Discusses role more. Wants a grenade. Quote ##Lynch Jamie Little bit torn because the role if truthful is kinda fun and different (also potentially vry useful), I've seen it before but he could just easily be a role cop or at the very least have one on his team feeding him the names. IDK IDK Christian is reminding me of ScumChristian too tho. This is where a grenade would come in handy Feels im317 is a legend. Farlig FOSes Vic, Curtis defends, saying Mafia roleblocked Vic N1. Curtis I finally got outta work and this party DIED!!!!!! Christian did you suspect Jamie before today? Who are your top suspects besides Vic/Jamie? Christian Mr. Curtis, sadly I do not have anything to help me gather information to deduce who I think is scum and who I think is not. As a member of the workforce like yourself, I have to read real fast when I get home to catch up and don't have much time for formulating good enough reads. I did have some thoughts about Dadd being blocked while I was catching up, but then he died. I didn't suspect Jamie before today, but I didn't not suspect him either. But what was the Mittens/Jamie thing someone brought up today? Curtis Mr. Christian, parts of this post amused me on a personal level but didn't do much for me on a scum hunting level. No gut reads at all? Mittens/Jamie have been beefing and accusing each other for the past couple of days if that's what you're thinking of Vote count was Jamie 7, Christian 5 at time of Curtis's last post of the day. No posts last two hours of the day. VOTE COUNT DAY 4 Jamie (8/11): TiB, Ahoda, Primate, Ben, im317, Curtis, Christian, DR, Farlig, Mittens Christian (6/11): Vic, JJ, DR, Ben, Lamps, Angi, Sock, Spin Mittens (2/11): Jamie, Sock Spin (0/11): Mittens Vic (0/11): Christian JJ (0/11): Lamps Ahoda (0/11): Timmah Dadd (0/11): JJ, Spin, Curtis, Ahoda Jamie has been lynched. (Continues to say Ahoda is scum. Lynches Dadd after lie detector result, which seemed obvious. Lynched Jamie after his claim. Said Christian seemed scummy.) D5: Defends suspicion on Ahoda in that "Shadow should be killed "quickly" " never left his head Posts D4 vote count, then: Quote for reference. I might go through how the lynch votes came in soon First thing that stood out to me was Jamie still going after Mittens instead of voting for Christian. I can see both being scum together, Christian also didn't even seem all that suspicious of Jamie to me when he was voting him After Christian points out Jamie didn't make it back before deadline to put his vote on Christian, says: Quote You were definitely pretty even with him when he was around tho, he could've just thrown his vote onto you. The only thing that actually made me waver between you and him was him not voting you and you voting him tbh Pretends he has a Daykill, no one believes him. Quote The Jamie/Mittens bickering didn't read fake to me and I can't believe Mittens might actually be town following that unbelievable post from a few days ago IN response to JJ asking why Curtis is not scum: Quote I got real fortunate when Zashua randomized the roles I'm town as town can be. Borderline mod confirmed Talks about why Christian sounds scummy. Quote Zersch and Vic are the most town imo. I can't buy those ploys right at the start of the game, makes no sense to me. Unless it was to get dummies like me to post this exact thing!!!!!! I guess maybe Maddie's block could've been redirected by someone to fellow mafia Vic and they capitalized but that's a stretch Curtis's Reads TOWN AS FUCK Curt Zersch Vic Brian PROB TOWN Drrr JJ TOWN VIBES Spin Primate Angi I DON'T REMEMBER A SINGLE ONE OF THEIR POSTS David Lamps Farlig I CONFUSE THEM FOR EACH OTHER SOMETIMES Ben Timmah SCUMMY Christian TIB Mittens im317 Sock (I color-coded them, also note that he doesn't list Ben or Timmah as anything, just says he confuses them for each other sometimes.) Notes Davis has fallen off 24 hour active user list. Talks about people thinking he's scum. Asks what Christian's claim is. Quote Would the other people also be millers looking for you and the other person? Or maybe they'd be insane in some other way other than miller and could cure their version of it. That'd be cool Quote Spin are you and your pal(s) confirmed town to each other? Or is it just communication Masons Your partner in crime revealed him/herself today [yay emoji] Talks about Masons some more. Lies to Mittens and says JJ smited him. Quote Christian claiming Miller came at a very convenient time (for anyone paying attention) ##Lynch Christian More questions to Christian about claim. Christian is killed by Brian, flips Miller. Defends Zersch to Maddie, then: Quote Primate's theory that Maddie and Zersch set it up if Maddie was gonna be busy is...not super likely but possible. She's moving across the country right now. Worth keeping in mind at least Asks Spin again if Masons are confirmed town to each other. Seems satisfied with answer that they can post their roles in Mason forum. Quote We should be looking closely at the Maddie/Jamie trains but also the Christian vs. Shadow switch, I can see mafia wanting to mislynch Christian while keeping sketchy SK Shadow in play to kill and distract And by we I mean anyone but me at the moment After some questioning by Primate, says he meant Shadow vs Ahoda lynch. Quote OH my bad it was Ahoda. A last minute effort by people to swing things onto Ahoda instead of Shadow Quote Not as many people were on that as I remembered. It was Timmah - Brian - Mittens - Dadd - Shadow - Rose in that order, but Timmah I think was on well before the switch and Rose hoped right off and back to Shadow. It was really just Brian/Mittens/Dadd with Shadow joining to save himself, nothing that interesting rly Quote I feel good about most scum being within those 5 or so suspects I listed earlier but hardly feel more strongly about one over the other, it's a total grenade day (In reference to Christian, TIB, Mittens, im317, Sock) Ben claims Hider, Curtis asks why he would hide behind him N1. Doesn't like Sock or Ben claim. Doesn't think PGO would work during the day (Rose said she thought Sock was claiming PGO) Discussions on whether SK had to apply their BP. they didn't. Quote Ben or Sock or Timmah or a Farlig blindside maybe HMMMMMM Quote Or David I guess but that's boring Asks who Timmah would suggest. After Timmah hints at vengeful but then says he was just making a request, says smells vengeful. Lynches Farlig. Says he has no idea what votals are, then posts them: Quote Ben (3/10): JJ, Lamps, Vic, im317, Mittens, Angi Sock (2/10): Ben, Mittens TiB (2/10): Sock, Primate Farlig (2/10): Timmah, Curtis David (1/10): Spin Angi (1/10): TiB Timmah (1/10): Drr Mittens (0/10): Sock, Spin Curtis (0/10): JJ Spin (0/10): Mittens, Christian (0/10): DR, Curtis now I do Says these four voters, minus Vic, (so Lamps, im317, Mittens) are giving him major pause about those two targets, especially with votes so low: Quote Ben (3/10): JJ, Lamps, Vic, im317, Mittens, Angi Sock (2/10): Ben, Mittens Rose votes Farlig, tying it 3/3 between Ben and Farlig. Curtis posts votals. Quote A David lynch is zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz Posts a pic of David Lynch. VOTE COUNT DAY 5 Farlig (6/10): Timmah, Curtis, DR, JJ, Mittens, Spin Ben (3/10): JJ, Lamps, Vic, im317, Angi David (2/10): Spin, TiB TiB (2/10): Sock, Primate Sock (1/10): Ben, Mittens Timmah (0/10): DR Angi (0/10): TiB Mittens (0/10): Sock, Spin Curtis (0/10): JJ Spin (0/10): Mittens Christian (0/10): DR, Curtis Farlig has been lynched. D6: In regard to Farlig lynch: Quote I can't decide if I think some scum used the opportunity to take advantage of the switch (to save Ben or Sock) or if it was entirely town. I trust mostly everyone who joined it tho JJ said we should've stayed with Ben lynch. Response: Quote Prob. The people who lynched him and Sock are among all my top suspects so it sketched me out. Lamps and 317 on Ben and Ben and Mittens on Sock. Mittens' vote for Sock especially felt opportunistic to me Quote I'd shoot Ben or Sock for the most answers. Then 317/Timmah/Lamps/TIB based on vibes. Then David for the hell of it. Then me for the hell of it Ben/Sock>>317/Timmah/Lamps/TIB>>David Quote But I'd let Sock clarify his weird claim first in case he's PGO Asks Ben who he hid behind night before. Brian shoots Ben. In response to Timmah saying one of the people on Farlig lynch (Farlig (6/10): Timmah, Curtis, DR, JJ, Mittens, Spin) are Mafia, Curtis says it's either Timmah or no one. Says he's 95% sure the rest are town, one thing gives him pause about Mittens. Guesses Vic is silenced by Ben. Gets vibe that scum votes were scattered on other 1-2 trains. Says "Sock or Lamps imo. Maybe TIB" in response to 2nd scum target if Timmah is lynched and is town vengeful. Or Primate I guess. I have no read on Primate whatsoever" "or 317 ofc WHY CAN'T YOU ALL JUST HAVE A STROKE" Defends Vic to Timmah's conspiracy theory. Notes it looks scummy and that Ben was going after same angle. In response to Timmah saying Lamps looks good for not jumping off Ben lynch, points out Lamps wasn't around for last 5 hours or so and, while he doesn't look good or bad, wouldn't give him a +1 for it. Quote ##Lynch Sock Gonna be with ppl for most of today and will be contained to my phone for the most part. I get the vibe that Ben knew he was dying soon (via brian or lynch) so he voted Sock before he was shot to make Sock look better, same with voting Sock last night when he probably thought he was getting lynched May or may not have been interested in a girl at a bar with an allergy to redheads. VOTE COUNT DAY 6 Sock (6/9): Ben JJ, Timmah, Curtis, Lamps, im317, Primate, Mittens David (2/9): Spin, JJ Lamps (1/9): DR Timmah (0/9): JJ, Primate Ben (0/9): Angi, Primate, Timmah Sock has been lynched.

Conclusions:

D1: nothing of note
D2: Seems sketchy to me since he was calling Farlig out because of this block back on D2 but it was later determined Merc was most likely the Mafia kill, and given he still pushed for his lynch D5 when Ben was getting votes. Could read town since he calls for Maddie to be killed but the fact he includes Ahoda (to be killed) is sketchy when Maddie seems pretty obv scum.
D3: Suspects that day were Ahoda, Mittens, Shadow, im317. All but 1 has flipped either town or 3p. The one who hasn't, im317, he lynched immediately after Zersch asked im317 what's up, as if he had info. So, he could either be town thinking Zersch knows im317 is scum or scum, feeling he needs to lynch to look good if Zersch has info. Either way, not really conclusive except that none of his other 3 reads were mafia and Shadow was obvious lynch that day, anyway.
D4: Continues to say Ahoda is scum. Lynches Dadd after lie detector result, which seemed obvious. Lynched Jamie after his claim. Said Christian seemed scummy.
D5: Casts suspicions on Christian that he could be Jamie's scum buddy, says he might go look and see how votes came in but doesn't do it. Could be mafia seeking Christian as an easy target. His Town/Scum list isn't that weird in itself. Obv some of his scum suspects have now flipped town. It stood out to me that he has Ben/Timmah under a category stating he confuses them for each other but doesn't cast any suspicion on them as scum besides that. Meanwhile, Ben has flipped scum and Timmah has never seemed to be a target for Curtis, really. Under his 5 scummiest, two of the five have since flipped town. One has been "cleared" by Vic (although that's not set in stone or anything obv), the other two are im317 and TIB. I personally don't think TIB Is scum, maybe im317 is. Trying to point out other Mason seems sketchy but, if he were a mafia, he probably would just share that on his scum board. Defends Zersch and then agrees he could have set something up with Maddie in order to look innocent. Hard to really conclude anything about this since Zersch basically disappeared after seeming very town and giving us Mafia/Maddie on D2.
Worst thing to me is saying he doesn't believe Ben or Sock's claims but then lynches Farlig. He uses excuse similar to Timmah's in that he doesn't trust people on the other trains (Ben/Sock trains). Passes by any real doubt about Timmah's vengeful claim in the process and waves off lynching David as too boring.
D6: Talks about Ben & Sock being scummy pretty consistently. After Ben is killed by Brian, lynches Sock. The only thing that looks bad (besides Sock flipping town lol) is that he seemed to go back and forth with Timmah a lot, saying if someone on Farlig's train is scum it's him, pointing out why Timmah's conspiracy theories regarding Vic are wrong, even comparing him to Ben in terms of what he was saying about Vic, but never lynches him. I also don't see that Sock's claim was that outlandish given a role with a day killer, it made sense to me that someone would have a role where they couldn't die during the day. Also, Sock seemed like an easy target as he wasn't around a lot to defend himself. Also, continually ignoring David as a lynch target keeps giving me bad vibes.

Curtis's lynch record:

D1: Nofo
D2: Maddie, Vlady
D3: im317, Shadow
D4: Dadd, Jamie
D5: Christian, Farlig
D6: Sock

The two mafia he lynched (Maddie/Jamie) seemed like obvious lynches at the time. The Dadd lynch isn't really bad due to the false lie detector info. Christian lynch isn't that bad since I do agree Christian seemed scummy when claiming. The lynches I question most are Farlig and Sock since Farlig could've been a way to save scum Ben and Sock could've been a way to save scum Timmah, or someone else?

FUCK YEAH! MINE'S THE LONGEST

Primate @ 20/8/2017 21:08

Angi tied herself to timmah yesterday. Not sure if they are scum together, or if she knows he's Town and is trying to get credit.

Or it could just be her honest opinion.

JJ @ 20/8/2017 23:05

Zersch @ 20/8/2017 22:59 Oh and for the record I didn't just waste the mirror for shits and giggles, I didn't have a choice and it could only be used on myself. What was it supposed to do?

Would tell me anyone that visited me on the night I used it.

Spoiler: No one did.

everyone getting tied together

Curtis looks worse than I thought.

lets all mass claim right now

It seems I am 100% scum depending on the flip of about three different people

Bring it on. Off with their heads

Curtis @ 20/8/2017 23:15

It seems I am 100% scum depending on the flip of about three different people Bring it on. Off with their heads

given Mittens claim, if hes telling the truth then i think you are scum 95%.

Curtis @ 20/8/2017 23:09

FUCK YEAH! MINE'S THE LONGEST

Well you were first. Well, Rose was first but I got bored since she seems so town. :P

Primate @ 20/8/2017 23:13

Curtis looks worse than I thought.

lol rly? I think my reads have been pretty good (:

I guess the Farlig/Sock lynches were dark times