Lynching Brian is the worst idea ever. Why lynch him at all if he's going to die but also just in case there is some type of cure. The reasoning is that two townies might die but it's basically always a risk and lynching Brian as he dies is equivalent to a no lynch.

Also am I the only one who finds it hilarious that herm has a theory about im317 staring at his rank to come up with the vig role? I mean I get the gist but that detail lol

Also agree with Wikeys assessments about believability and faking being silenced would be the easiest thing ever. So idk how you figure mr Canuck

If aris claim is real we have an arsonist? We had this as a mafia kill role before but it sounds more third party unless there's an Ari to counteract each mafia kill role. Also seems easy claim to make.

Buffy @ 2/11/2015 16:17

Also am I the only one who finds it hilarious that herm has a theory about im317 staring at his rank to come up with the vig role? I mean I get the gist but that detail lol

Yeah...I know Herm has some strange ideas, but are they ever this strange?

Lol, the important thing is you know what I mean.

I don't think we should lynch any of the claimed roles today.

I guess it's possible that Ari is a Firefighter. But if Ari and im317 are both town then what's stopping mafia kills?

If it's been caused by a town role then how come no one knows anything?

The answer should be right in front of us lol.

I'm still down for lynching Herm, but I don't believe Ari's claim at all. This same exact claim has been made by someone being pressured for lynch like 4 straight games. Every game is not going to have a priming, arsonist type of role in it.

Also, I still don't think I believe rose's claim either. The argument that, well there is someone to corroborate, and there's no way they'd risk losing 2 mafia members is all fine and well, except that making the claim saved rose and has let them get at least 1 day further into the game, and looking like even more than that. Seems like it may be worth it to me.

Buffy, how in the world do you get to be the role blocker in pretty much every game!?!?!

AYY ARI, YOU TRYNA STEAL MY CLAIM FROM THE OTHER GAME HUH?!????

This DOES explain the lack of SK kills. A handful of us could be primed by the arson right now waiting to be lit. How discomforting!

I can't make much sense of the lack of mafia kill. I imagine 317 killed Chris since he's been suspicious of him. Chris would be a stupid Mafia target

Timmah @ 2/11/2015 22:35

Also, I still don't think I believe rose's claim either. The argument that, well there is someone to corroborate, and there's no way they'd risk losing 2 mafia members is all fine and well, except that making the claim saved rose and has let them get at least 1 day further into the game, and looking like even more than that. Seems like it may be worth it to me.

As much as I think that they must be town, looking at both of them as players without a claim behind them, I get really suspicious based on their lack of contributions and overall thoughts on game related stuff.

Yes, I have been a bit indecisive but that does not mean I'm scum. I'm indecisive because the people I get scum vibes from have claimed a town role and the players I have lynched have eventually turned up town lol. It's a natural reaction to being wrong. I mean, the obvious path is to follow the role results presented by the town players, but everyone's second guessing that so much and even the validity of the claimed roles.

Maybe we're questioning things so much that we're too afraid to assume anything is confirmed? Let's assume for just a brief moment that everyone has been telling the truth about their roles.

Town if they're all telling the truth:
Herm: Town
Ari: Town Firefighter
Brian: Town Doctor
Buffy: Town Roleblocker
Rose/dr: Town Lover
Nobert: Town Lover
im317: Town Vigilante (jumped on Vernon's train started by Angi Day 1, lynched JC Day 2)

Town Vibe:
JC: ??? (was silenced Day 2)
Wikey: ??? (big contributor)
Timmah: ??? (big contributor, lynched JC Day 2)

Possibly Town:
Canuck: ??? (jumped on Vernon's train Day 1, lynched JC Day 2)
Redster: ??? (was blocked by Buffy Night 1, was lynched by Buffy Day 2)

Not sure:
Curtis: ??? (started a lynch train on Primate Day 3, lynched Brian Day 1)
Henry: ???
Dyl: ???
Schrauben: ??? (low activity)
Jayadamo: ??? (low activity)

I have a vibe about Dylan Rogers

Who else has a vibe about Dylan Rogers?

Timmah @ 2/11/2015 16:33

I'm still down for lynching Herm, but I don't believe Ari's claim at all. This same exact claim has been made by someone being pressured for lynch like 4 straight games. Every game is not going to have a priming, arsonist type of role in it.

I'll have to go back and check if this is indeed the case. But I don't want to condemn a player based on that.

The signs do point to a non traditional third party. And when you consider that there aren't that many third party roles, it's not hard to believe that an arsonist and firefighter could be in play.

Or maybe we actually have a standard SK and it's im317. I can think of a few ways that would be possible.

Timmah @ 2/11/2015 16:35

Also, I still don't think I believe rose's claim either. The argument that, well there is someone to corroborate, and there's no way they'd risk losing 2 mafia members is all fine and well, except that making the claim saved rose and has let them get at least 1 day further into the game, and looking like even more than that. Seems like it may be worth it to me.

The claim has indeed worked if it is fake, but still, the risk involved. Put yourself in scums shoes, would you ask one of your team mates to risk themselves like that, if the possible end result is you both getting lynched?

Curtis @ 2/11/2015 17:13

I have a vibe about Dylan Rogers Who else has a vibe about Dylan Rogers?

He hinted at having a visiting role earlier for no real reason. I'm leaning towards absent minded townie.

Adds up to scum Curtis!

Also I agree that lynching Brian is DUMB! We've already had a tie/no lynch which was a huge waste of time. That'd be 2/4 days learning no information from a lynch

Wikey @ 2/11/2015 16:17

Curtis @ 2/11/2015 17:13 I have a vibe about Dylan Rogers Who else has a vibe about Dylan Rogers? He hinted at having a visiting role earlier for no real reason. I'm leaning towards absent minded townie.

It was to justify Buffy and Ari both being right. And further show that target switches are possible.