CherryBerry @ 15/6/2015 10:22

Welcome, Ahoda. What can you tell us about why you're joining us today?

I gave Brian $20 and he let me join.


It was my passive role. It made me join on D2.

Cake @ 14/6/2015 22:06

Lol overdeffensive, you praise me and agree with me then you are like idk. Tricks is mafia.

Is this serious or a joke?

Speculation of Night 1 kills:

im317/third party - presumably killed by a vigilante and possibly mafia, if there's a third party faction in play they might substitute for serial killer.
Schrauben - He came off as the most townish imo yesterday and I have a suspicion that he was taken out by im317's faction.
Rob - He came off as a bit suspicious yesterday and I don't see mafia going for him. I suspect he got taken out by the vigilante, but the lone ranger usually doesn't strike the first night so maybe it was a serial killer.

Trains (that mattered) from Day 1:

Christian: Ari was the first lynch on Christian, Day 1 as he gave the signal to start the C-train. Although once Christian unlynched he switched to Rose.
Chris was not far behind and as expected, lynched Christian, thus getting the Christian train up to 1 again. Mind you, Christian had just lynched Chris the post before.
Cake was then the second lynch on Christian and gave the reasoning that he smelled scum. No other train had started at this point in time.

Tony: Colby starts the Tony train and lynched him based on activity, this was done after Cake's lynch of Christian.
Tricks was the second lynch vote on Tony, this happened directly after Lamps lynched Chris. He argued that Tony was a better lynch than Chris, contribution-wise.

Chris: Christian was the first lynch on Chris, the two of them basically lynched each other in retaliation.
Lamps was the second lynch vote on Chris and lynched him based on future contributions, this was done sometime after Colby's lynch on Tony.

The lynch trains were now 2-2-2 with Christian, Tony and Chris sharing the lead. Rose had gotten votes from Curist, Ari and Merc, but these were nullified when Alsark replaced her.

Alsark had a few things to say. He didn't like Boc's "hey, let's all hold hands joke" earlier in the Day thread". However, he also didn't like Christian's post pointing out to Ari that he was already there when Ari lynched him for not being there lol. So Alsark adds a third lynch to Christian.

Buffy also says that she felt that Christian's lynch of Chris felt off and that he usually laughs it off, thus adding a fourth lynch. The C-train now has 4 votes, thus taking the lead.

Angi then jokingly asks if it's time for someone to come in and point out that Christian's train is moving too fast and try to derail it. Some of us feel that Christian is a bad lynch and Angi adds a third vote to Tony.

Christian unlynches and Cake unlynches and switches to Alsark.

Chris is out of the running at this point and it now stands between Christian and Tony with 3 lynch votes respectively. Christian tries to fight for his innocence and Cake gets suspicious and wants to lynch him again. Because of this, Christian lynches Tony. Cake thinks that Christian is scum at this point and lynches him again. It's now 4-4.

Buffy unlynches Christian and it's down to 4-3 with Tony in the lead. Boc adds a fifth lynch vote on Tony.

Christian's lynch train slows down and Tony's takes the lead with 6 with Beaver adding the final lynch. There are random lynch votes for Zersch, Vernon and Cake late in the game but nothing that takes off.

vic and Vernon are the only two not to post at all? I'm wondering if they're getting replaced? Idk if that's going to happen past day 1 but I am leaning toward one if them.

I also want to hear what DD comes up with. Those "I'll read and brb to post" statements always make me want to keep track if they actually follow thru.

My thing with moose is I feel she has some reasoning but trying to be cautious ... But I agree she kinda blew it by even saying that much.

Herm seemed to be doing the same with boc and Shawn but then seemed like he retracted.

I'm mobile at work - can someone post a vote count and deadline ?

This is it I think.

DD - 2
Shawn - 1

Not much.

Anyway, why's there so much discussion about Moose not making sense and that something might or might not be up with her?

If we don't know who to lynch then I suggest everyone lynch the person they're most suspicious of and we work our way from there.

Too many people not offering opinions. You gotta keep on keeping on.

##Teebs

Ugh. I was working on a big post like 2-3 hours ago then IT called and said they needed on my computer and restarted it while I was at lunch and working on other things.

Cool. Well I'll type it up again later, I don't feel like doing it again so soon.

I would rather want to lynch someone who isnt saying much rather than someone that is. Always hard to lead a lynch on those that are quiet when we approach the end....

Very granular thoughts...

1. Moose - Has a relatively high amount of posts. Has lynched.
2. Teebs - Has 1 post that is not game related
3. Curtis - Few and non-game related posts.
4. Nofo - Lot of posts yesterday, none today.
5. Herm - Buttload of posts. Seems to be trying.
6. Lamps - Seems to be trying. Has lynched and discussed.
7. Merc - Hasnt discussed much, but lynched.
8. Alsark (formerly drrr) - trying and active when he joined.
9. Korr - Has posted some weird cryptic shit.
10. Christian - Did seem pretty defensive on day 1. Staying active.
13. Angi - Active and trying.
14. Buffy - Lots of posts, active and trying.
16. Chris - Hasnt said much per usual.
17. Boc - Hasnt said much but has been actively lynching.
20. Colby - Doesnt have an awful a lot of posts but most of them are game related.
21. DD - No game related posts at all
22. Vernon - Has he posted yet?
23. Cherryberry - Relatively high amount of posts. Seems to be trying.
24. Vic - Has he posted yet?
25. Shawn - Hasnt posted anything game related.
26. Walk - Relatively high amount of posts and discussing
27. Cuhraig (formerly Zersch) - Has he posted yet?
28. Wikey - No game related posts
29. Dylan - Has a few posts but doesnt seem like any of them are game related
30. Tricks - Lot of posts, actively discussing.
31. Timmah - Relatively high amount of posts, seems to be trying to discuss.
32. Badger - Has a few posts, seems to be trying.
33. Sami - Has said nothing game related
34. Cake - Lot of posts, is discussing.
35. Ahoda - Not much to say.

Well from that I wouldnt mind lynching any of those that are not really contributing. Teebs / Korr / Chris / DD / Vernon / Vic / Shawn / Cuhraig / Wikey / Sami all seem to fall on the lower side of the activity / contribution list.

Might as well start at the top again until those people start contributing!

##lynch Teebs

Some people I'd like to hear thoughts from:

Curtis: Not impressed, might be useful later on.
Chris: Same as above.
Korr: Doesn't do anything besides displaying his O condition.

Some people I'd like to hear more from:

Shawn: Hasn't really contributed anything besides commenting on my suspicion of him.
Sami: Says that the mafia team are usually red and denied being scum on Day 1.

Teebs: I don't remember this person, but he/she hasn't showed today.
Nofo: I'd like to hear more game thoughts once he shows up.
Wikey: I'd just like him to offer his assistance to the team lol.
Vernon: Nowhere to be seen.
Vic: Same as above.
Cuhraig: Same as above.

I would guess there is scum to be found at the end of the Tony train yesterday. Likely at least one jumped on. So looking at angIChristian boc badger there. Also people who are very active but never lynch are scummy

If alsark got attacked yesterday, it was by teebs.

Or well, I mean, unless someone of you tells me the meta of rose and if she is good at mafia.

If anyone was scum on Tony's train I'd bet it's between Boc and Beaver, if it's anyone at all. It would've been an easy lynch train to place a lynch on, especially near the end. I don't think scum would've gone out of their way to get directly involved when the lynch trains were still tied and with as many people laying low as it is there shouldn't be any reason to take risks that early.

Cake @ 15/6/2015 13:18

If alsark got attacked yesterday, it was by teebs. Or well, I mean, unless someone of you tells me the meta of rose and if she is good at mafia.

I didn't understand this at all but Rose is good at mafia when she's active.

I think it's because you said Alsark was already much better than Rose and misunderstood what you meant.