Who do you think is scum, Brian?

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 16:52

Herm @ 15/4/2014 9:22 Oh I'm a guy, girls call me pretty face Herm. I can see why some people confuse me for a girl though, I'm sorta hard to figure out. If you have such a pretty face, where's your FE Hed?

I don't even know what that is. Hed as in head?

##Lynch...................................................Vernon!

I just get scummy vibes! Im sorry Vernon! Also Herm sounds like a good option...and Buffy for being overly defensive/jerk to me day 1

That's fine, I haven't given reasoning to ALL of my votes so I guess I understand.

Scummy vibes though? So just. a general read of me?

Getting rid of Herm today would the most telling. There's been a ton of people going against him (her?) so that will help us make cases for later days. They claim it's partially inexperience but I think it's just poor scum game playing.

## lynch Herm

Also cool with lynching Brian, Angi, g0, and I guess Buffy.

Hm, it seems like I might be today's lynch target. There were two advices I took in that I could try to use to get you guys to help perhaps convince at least some people suspicious of me that I'm not scum. Patrick's advice was to not say anything, I assume he meant no game talk or trying to throw out theories. Tricks's advice was to start scum hunting, I have been seriously trying to look for scum since Day 1 though but come on. You guys have played mafia like this so many times that what seems obvious to you guys is not obvious to me. I don't know who's scum or town.

This is my third time ever playing a proper mafia game, first time was 6 years ago, second time was here and third time is now. I'm probably the most inexperienced here tbh. I'm thinking about roleclaiming, but my role is heavily tied to what sort of character I am so I'm not sure if that's allowed.

Town:
Ari - obviously ;)

Likely town:
DR
Perry

Meh:
Curtis - was lynched by HC.
Vernon - strikes me as town.
Patrick - strikes me as town.
Greenday - not sure about his claim but ill put him here.
Ahoda - strikes me as town.

Not sure:
Boc
Shawn
Buffy

Possible lynches:
Angi - lynched Greenday. lynched Curtis. lynched Malion. Bandwagony votes.
Cash Money - lynched Herm because the Mal train gained a lot of steam quickly. Hasnt said much else.
g0 - dont think he/she has said anything of note regarding his/her suspicions.
Herm - Been the target of a lot of suspicion. Malion was lynched in his stead. Mafia ploooy? A lot of people seem to suspect him though. That rarely happens to mafia.
itsbrianyay - Said Herm was scummy. Didnt lynch. Dont think he has said anything about other suspicions.
Shadow - scummy post I mentioned earlier. Has accused me and Herm. Then lynched Mal.
Tricks - lynched Herm. Said Curtis and Boc where scummy.
Wikey - Said Curtis was scummy. Pointed at Boc, Greenday, Vernon, Vic. Lynched Greenday. Hasnt said much else.

Not sure if Herm is the best target. He seems to have so many people against him, that doesnt happen to mafia a lot. Some of the people here above have talked a lot but said very little....

Yeah, I think this Herm train seems to be growing kinda fast. And I am meta-gaming (again), but Herm acted exactly this same way as Gabriel in ATTWSIV. I thought he was scummy all game but he wasn't. I just think he thinks out loud.

And, even though Vernon doesn't want to give additional info, looking back at Brian's posts from Day 2:

Quote

i'm gonna go with my gut and ##lynch herm for now, though it might change because i keep doubting myself. on top of the contradictory statements and other oddities, he keeps calling the mafia "vampire scum" when it's clear that the vampires are cult, not the mafia (unless there's 2 factions of vampires in buffy lore..? i have no idea). to me it seems intentionally ignorant.

I just wonder why he would say it's clear mafia would not be vampires but then says he has no idea about Buffy lore. Seems contradictory and almost like he knows something about the mafia.

I think Patrick's "advice" was more along the lines of "if herm is town he's digging his own grave" and less actual advice for you to follow. Actually following that advice (especially from Patrick of all people) is a bad idea though. If people suspect you, its for a reason and they won't stop just because you havent said anything recently.

...though g0 is getting a lot less heat today by not saying anything! So (:

Ari @ 15/4/2014 14:39

Town: Ari - obviously ;)

lol Ari's scum

Curtis @ 15/4/2014 19:45

Ari @ 15/4/2014 14:39 Town: Ari - obviously ;) lol Ari's scum

aaah you got me detective

Im gonna go aaaand

##lynch itsbrianyay

Quite hypocritical of you to now suspect Angi and Wikey for wanting to lynch me, Ariel! Yours and Cocoa's votes on me were the most suspicious I thought. Both gave weak reasoning

Curtis @ 15/4/2014 19:49

Quite hypocritical of you to now suspect Angi and Wikey for wanting to lynch me, Ariel! Yours and Cocoa's votes on me were the most suspicious I thought. Both gave weak reasoning

How? I know my alignment, not theirs.

Considering HC did lynch you I dont think you are mafia at the moment. You where at risk for some time and dont think the mafia would have risked it.

Wikey talks about his suspicions so id have him close to the bottom of that suspect list. Angi has made some bandwagony votes and jumped around.

Brian said he suspected Herm but didnt act on it. Dont think he has voiced much suspicion otherwise? Seems like scum hiding! So ill have my vote on him for the time being.

drrr @ 15/4/2014 21:40

I think Patrick's "advice" was more along the lines of "if herm is town he's digging his own grave" and less actual advice for you to follow. Actually following that advice (especially from Patrick of all people) is a bad idea though. If people suspect you, its for a reason and they won't stop just because you havent said anything recently.

Lol, I took in what Patrick and Tricks had to say but I doubt that would change much at this point. Since I already had so many people being suspicious of me from yesterday I knew I had to speak up today, but that only got more people suspicious of me. If things go south I'll roleclaim, but only if absolute necessary.