It always irks me and seems scummy to me when people say if you lynch me its all over, town is going to lose, very very bad, etc. Just does. Doesn't mean it is always true.

ff_zero @ 5/1/2014 11:26

It always irks me and seems scummy to me when people say if you lynch me its all over, town is going to lose, very very bad, etc. Just does. Doesn't mean it is always true.

'cept in this case it does. Lynch me today, power goes out, we lose someone else, mafia bands together in the dark to all vote anonymously; game over.

ff_zero @ 5/1/2014 17:26

It always irks me and seems scummy to me when people say if you lynch me its all over, town is going to lose, very very bad, etc. Just does. Doesn't mean it is always true.

It sounds scummy to me his role claim wouldn't work well on an onsite game. I guess Lovely Princess has been overused.

Kru @ 5/1/2014 12:20

ff_zero @ 5/1/2014 17:26 It always irks me and seems scummy to me when people say if you lynch me its all over, town is going to lose, very very bad, etc. Just does. Doesn't mean it is always true. It sounds scummy to me his role claim wouldn't work well on an onsite game. I guess Lovely Princess has been overused.

Like I said, I'm pretty sure it's just voting in PMs instead of in-thread. It's not that implausible.

That sounds broken anyway.

Yeah well tell Matt that. Not my idea lol

I don't buy it, claiming to have a role like that would be stupid for being town.

DR needs to kill Nofo soon so we can decide on who to lynch tomorrow in case that Green dies tonight.

So you want town to lose? Cuz you're scum?

I'm a bit busy so I can't respond in detail to everything right now, but a few thoughts before I run off:

I don't see kiwi's insistence that Greenday is town as being scummy as much as I see it as leaning too heavily on metagaming.

I really want to actually hear from Nofo before I fire the gun! I'm buying Wikey as more than likely town right now but I am not very big on daykilling someone who hasn't defended themselves yet, and people pushing for that are a little shady to me. If Nofo still hasnt said anything in a few hours I'll shoot.

Some people have been really quiet and its bothering me! Patrick and Malion, mainly, but there are others.

Alright, back later

Greenday @ 5/1/2014 19:42

So you want town to lose? Cuz you're scum?

You are going to die anyway town or scum, you have just put a big target on yourself after role claiming. That's why we need to decide on who to lynch and have everyone to agree in case that you are telling the truth.

Tom Brady @ 5/1/2014 10:07

So, as I was reading through, I thought Kiwi was pretty insistent that Greenday should not be considered as a lynch candidate yesterday, and I thought it odd. Based just on day 2, I could see Kiwi and Greenday been scum buddies. This is all just speculation. If you notice, in that same post I name DR and im317 as suspects too. This is by no means me making solid accusations. It is all speculation, me throwing all my thoughts out as they come to me. I am actually more interested in the DR, im317, Nofo thing.

again i gave someone else an item night 1. i would rather not say who it was or what the item is but i suppose its ok to say that i have the Rosary Buffy's role needed to get 2x power.

Tom Brady @ 5/1/2014 10:16

I am trying to get my head round it. DR hasn't claims that she was passed the gun and armour last night. im317 has confirmed that he gave her the armour. I would like to know his reasons for doing so, because DR has hardly been giving off obv town vibes. And she also claims she was passed the gun. This could be a lie. Nobody has come forward about passing it to her, which is interesting because I don't think a townie would have anything to lose by doing so. It would clear this up for us. So, either DR is telling the truth and a townie has yet to come forward, she had the gun from the start and is SK/GF, or she is scum and one of her scum buddies passed it to her, and now dare not come forward for fear of exposing themselves. I would like to know what Vic meant earlier too, when he said that the role came up as Oppressed Civilian. Is he talking about DR, or himself? Because he claimed he just found out what items his target had, not their alignment too.

i gave Drr the armor because she was actually trying at being helpful, something we were in very short supply of at that point.

Greenday @ 5/1/2014 12:19

ff_zero @ 5/1/2014 11:26 It always irks me and seems scummy to me when people say if you lynch me its all over, town is going to lose, very very bad, etc. Just does. Doesn't mean it is always true. 'cept in this case it does. Lynch me today, power goes out, we lose someone else, mafia bands together in the dark to all vote anonymously; game over.

sometimes town can be so stupid. mafia cant win if there is 3rd party still alive. if mafia has majority and there is 3rd party alive the game continues, its possible for town to get majority back and still win in the case.

##lynch Wikey
6/15 now. we can go into the lynch at either 6/14 or 5/14 if Drr day kills Nofo. i would rather go in with 14 and know we are lynching scum, or have time to change targets because we day killed scum

Kru @ 5/1/2014 14:00

Greenday @ 5/1/2014 19:42 So you want town to lose? Cuz you're scum? You are going to die anyway town or scum, you have just put a big target on yourself after role claiming. That's why we need to decide on who to lynch and have everyone to agree in case that you are telling the truth.

Mafia would not benefit from killing me at night because it's only if I'm lynched.

That sounds too convenient.

So I guess DR can day kill you and your ability won't trigger? Am I correct?

I'm 99% positive it wouldn't trigger but why would we even want to risk it? We haven't killed a SINGLE mafia member yet and we're getting down to the wire.