Quote

If she isn't scum would they really block him?

This is the part I questioned.

I'm trying to figure out what you're trying to say there

If Rob is a Cop, he would scan you
If you were mafia, the mafia would block Rob to prevent him from scanning you
If you weren't mafia, the mafia wouldn't bother blocking Rob because he wouldn't be scanning one of them

That's what he's saying

Oh well depending on Rob's role, it may cast suspicion on you. Has he actually been confirmed as a cop? I thought he could be a tracker etc. And if you are town and suspicious we are more likely to lynch you. We need to hear from Rob anyway

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 18/2/2013 23:12

I'm trying to figure out what you're trying to say there

I thought it meant that you were the reason he'd get blocked, with the assumption being that you were scum.

Bleh I am slow at posting today.

But I don't believe the mafia would allow a cop to go unblocked and I don't believe the mafia would want Rob, who is suspicious of you, to confirm your innocence since you've been getting heat

That's a far simpler explanation Curtis thanks haha.

Rob was extremely certain Greenday was mafia so idk if he is a cop. Because could of been paranoid etc. His certainty gave me the impression he may of been a tracker. But I may of missed him confirming he was a cop.

Unless A: the mafia is dumb. or B: the mafia decided that there was a better roleblock target for whatever reason

It's hard to speculate. And we're also going off the assumption that the mafia has a roleblocker. Though I think there's definitely one out there due to one Night 1 kill. Rob can maybe confirm if he was blocked or not. No town roleblocker would block him

Shawn yesterday:

Quote

I havent been posting cause Im kind of confused so if you guys could just give me some time to get on the right page that would be good.

Shawn today:

Shawn @ 18/2/2013 19:39

Rito Kanakiri @ 18/2/2013 18:41 i switched to rob after a greenday vote formed because the train for greenday scared me and I thought rob was pulling a fast one.. Why would a lynch train scare you? That just makes it look like you voted for him early just to get any suspicion off of you then changed your vote so your vote wouldn't count towards your fellow robot. ##lynch: Rito

He seems to have caught on pretty quickly....

Jeff, Drrr and now Shawn are top of my lists for suspicious.

Not that I trust Rito, but I always have a tough time figuring out if he's just being his random self or actually has anything he's basing his comments on.

Kiwi @ 18/2/2013 23:13

Oh well depending on Rob's role, it may cast suspicion on you. Has he actually been confirmed as a cop? I thought he could be a tracker etc. And if you are town and suspicious we are more likely to lynch you. We need to hear from Rob anyway

Greenday was a doctor and was probably protecting scum night 1. If he was a watcher he would not have been able to ascertain that Greenday is 100% scum like he stated.

I agree that most likely Rob would have targetted me, HOWEVER I don't understand where this argument of "if he was blocked, drr is scum" comes in at all. It's incredibly stupid logic!

Scum would not know who Rob was 100% targetting. If they opted not to kill him, and if they had a blocker at their disposal, they would block him regardless f the likely target. Because confirming someone he's suspicious of as town is bad for scum. No one else claimed so no one else has a sure night action that they would feel the need to deflect.

If they had a roleblocker, they would block Rob. It doesn't matter WHO he would theoretically be scanning. It's still a detriment to the mafia.

And asking his results is unnecessary. Ousting trustworthy town makes them early kill targets. And ousting roles is even more retarded. I think as long as the results aren't clearing someone in danger or ousting someone dangerous they are best kept close to the vest.

Rob @ 18/2/2013 21:13

The arguments against Mal are also pretty interesting, and I'm curious as to why that train ran out of steam. His excuse of not being terribly invested is right up there with "Look! Your shoe's untied!" in the compendium of obvious excuses.

While i realise it IS pretty lame of me. I think it ran out of steam because it's just Ari's gut instinct followed by Alex thinking Ari is cool enough to agree with said opinion.

I mean I can't help that I played like a schmuck days 1 and 2. But I'm here now. Day 1 I voted defensively to avoid a tied no-lynch scenario.

Day 2 I was barely paying attention but I saw that Greenday was worthy of being lynched and that he was going to be lynched more likely than not so I figured it best to just let that run it's course.

This small post is literally my entire gameplay synopsis.

Onto more important things.

I don't think Vernon is particularly scummy though I dunno. I'm sure his death will be telling one way or another. But I really feel like Jeff is a more solid lead. Especially if he's a don or something.

The fact that it's so hard to get a decent train on him despite him just... being there is kind of strange. I guess that's fairly hypocritical of me. Haha.

I really feel like both Drr and Rito are town and they are just being dumb and feeding each others drama while the scum is sitting back rubbing their hands.

Curtis @ 18/2/2013 23:16

It's hard to speculate. And we're also going off the assumption that the mafia has a roleblocker. Though I think there's definitely one out there due to one Night 1 kill. Rob can maybe confirm if he was blocked or not. No town roleblocker would block him

Unless one of the attacks was on Henry who just backed out of it. As any sane person would do day 1 with that sort of power.

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 19/2/2013 4:23

Kiwi @ 18/2/2013 23:13 Oh well depending on Rob's role, it may cast suspicion on you. Has he actually been confirmed as a cop? I thought he could be a tracker etc. And if you are town and suspicious we are more likely to lynch you. We need to hear from Rob anyway Greenday was a doctor and was probably protecting scum night 1. If he was a watcher he would not have been able to ascertain that Greenday is 100% scum like he stated. I agree that most likely Rob would have targetted me, HOWEVER I don't understand where this argument of "if he was blocked, drr is scum" comes in at all. It's incredibly stupid logic! Scum would not know who Rob was 100% targetting. If they opted not to kill him, and if they had a blocker at their disposal, they would block him regardless f the likely target. Because confirming someone he's suspicious of as town is bad for scum. No one else claimed so no one else has a sure night action that they would feel the need to deflect. If they had a roleblocker, they would block Rob. It doesn't matter WHO he would theoretically be scanning. It's still a detriment to the mafia. And asking his results is unnecessary. Ousting trustworthy town makes them early kill targets. And ousting roles is even more retarded. I think as long as the results aren't clearing someone in danger or ousting someone dangerous they are best kept close to the vest.

That's what I said later on that it is unlikely they would block anyone else. But if there are SK and a Vig, its very strange the low amount of kills. All these people can't be getting blocked and now Rob is apparently getting blocked. If Rob wasn't blocked, you are likely town however :D Assuming you are not the don etc.

Also agree on Shawn Nat. I actually thought that earlier but was on my phone so forgot about it. Also is this another time he seems to be copying Roses actions?