Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 ... 4 5 6 7
Ghost Island - Episode 2
 Poll Question: READ THE OP THEN VOTE
NuMalolo (orange)
 
1 Vote
(1%)
NuNaviti (purple)
 
8 Votes
(11%)
Libby (vote) or Morgan (dont)
 
6 Votes
(8%)
Wendell (vote) or Domenick (dont)
 
9 Votes
(12%)
James (vote) or Donathan (dont_)
 
5 Votes
(7%)
Angela (vote) or Chris (dont)
 
5 Votes
(7%)
Desiree (vote) or Kellyn (dont)
 
4 Votes
(6%)
Stephanie (vote) or Jenna (dont)
 
8 Votes
(11%)
Brendan (vote) or Michael (dont)
 
6 Votes
(8%)
Sebastian (vote) or Bradley (dont)
 
5 Votes
(7%)
Laurel (vote) or Chelsea (dont)
 
6 Votes
(8%)
Good move
 
6 Votes
(8%)
Bad move
 
3 Votes
(4%)
 
Dyl
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 80
Group:Moderator
Posts:13,546
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #91: 7th Mar 2018 9:58 PM 
Looking back I can see a good reason to keep Dom is the Chris/Dom rivalry. If Dom would have left, Angela/Wendell/Chris/Morgan could have teamed up. That would have been a very easy thing to explain though.
"So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
   
Shadow
User Avatar
Mr. Cat
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 80
Group:Legend
Posts:8,693
Joined:Sep 16, 2013
Post #92: 7th Mar 2018 10:01 PM 
Libby > Morgan
I'm glad Libby isn't going to become the inv pretty blonde type. I was worried after episode one. Her move was iffy but it was brutal and good tv. Her chances of going deep may be hurt after the move, as she now seems hard to trust, but at least she can grow into a character from it. Perhaps a villain

Domenick > Wendell
I like Dom better than any of his types before him. (The idol finding car salesman type) But I would have been okay with him being the one to leave instead of Morgan. Would have been a better move. I like Dom more than Wendell, despite Wendell likely getting farther and having the better edit of the two.

James > Donathan
I like Donathan so much better when he is fed to us in small doses. James I liked this episode a lot. He was just a positive presence from the start and ended up making a huge move for the game. I think he'll go far. Donathan too probably but I like James better. I didn't expect that from James coming into this ep

Angela > Chris
They are kind of interchangeable. Both have been shown to be aloof and not in the know. Angela with a slight edge over Chris because she seems sweet. Hopefully she turns on her tribe now.

Desiree > Kellyn
Don't like either of them. Desiree is still an unknown but Kellyn has the potential to be my least favorite of the season. Hannah-lite. Fortunately I do not think it will get that bad. Kellyn this episode was all about being cocky she was in majority, declaring a pagoning would be epic, and discussed ugly babies.

Jenna > Steph
Tough vote but I picked Jenna over Steph because I am unsure if I find Steph annoying. I don't like her confessionals much but I like that she's a strong force. These two remind me of Chelsea/Kim and Jenna/Heidi. Steph is a better player but Jenna seems less annoying.

Michael > Brendan
I voted prematurely thinking I don't like Alpha type Male leaders and picked Michael over brendan by default. But when I think about it, Brendan isn't so bad at all. Kind of rootable. Michael I just remember more because he got the idol.

Sebastian > Bradley
Easy vote. We haven't seen much of Seb but Bradley was a whiney twat in tonight's ep. Seb seems fun. An Ozzy type not shoved down our throats

Chelsea > Laurel
Forgot who both were. I regret this vote after remembering that Laurel spoke once, whereas who the fuck is Chelsea. I just liked the name Chelsea better. Don't have a strong opinion on either obviously.

Posted Image
Spoiler+

   
Dyl
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 80
Group:Moderator
Posts:13,546
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #93: 7th Mar 2018 10:02 PM 
Igor @ 7/3/2018 21:06
jme @ 7/3/2018 21:02
Igor @ 7/3/2018 21:00
That tribe got punished so hard and it was fucking glorious. That is exactly how NOT to play a 4-4 situation. James absolutely decimated them, I fucking love this kid. Potential to be one of the greats.

one of the greats? you're too much igor


Just wait!!!
My boi is just beginning
His reads are on fucking point and he makes shit happen
Devon 2.0


Why not vote Dom. He's a cuck just like you cuckboi
"So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
   
Dyl
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 80
Group:Moderator
Posts:13,546
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #94: 7th Mar 2018 10:13 PM 
Morgan > Libby
- Like them both. Was really loving the Morgan/Wendell duo and am gutted that it is over. Libby seems pretty good though. I think she needed to hold her ground more this vote and either play it safe, or get Wendell out instead. But I think she can step up.

Wendell > Dom
- Wendell is my dude and as Jamie said I am kind of tired of the Dom style player. He's not bad but I am just lukewarm on him.

Donathon > James
- James is an okay player. I have already expressed my questioning of the move. Was not crazy about it. Donathon is absolutely lovable and I am fine with him not getting a ton of screentime but we need our weekly Donathism to keep me satisfied.

Chris > Angela
- Chris had his moment. I still am not crazy about him but he serves a purpose. Angela stinks, really wanted her to leave and now will hold the fact she should have left over Morgan against her.

Kellyn > Desiree
- Had a couple one liners was pretty funny. Not getting much from Des.

Stephanie > Jenna
- Lukewarm on both. Liked Steph from EP 2.

Brendan > Michael
- Dislike Michael. Lukewarm on Brendan.

Bradley > Sebastian
- Can't stand Sebastian. He stinks. His voice bothers me. I enjoy the Bradley hates everything storyline so that is what I'll go with.

Laurel > Chelsea
- Laurel is my fantasy player so I guess her.

I like NuNaviti better though with Morgan gone it is a lot closer. Wendell/Libby/Donathon are three of my favorites so it'd still swing in their favor big time.

I think it was a good move in the sense it gained the power, but Naviti gave them the power and I don't think they choose the best option so I voted for a bad move.
"So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
   
jamie
User Avatar
together we can defeat obese children
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 115
Group:Overlord
Posts:11,794
Joined:Jan 11, 2015
Post #95: 7th Mar 2018 10:16 PM 
babies are ugly let's be real
drrrrr @ 9/11/2017 18:03
I was wrong about Jamie he is a true visionary and I name him my successor


   
Christian
User Avatar
Captain Charisma
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,182
Group:Godfather
Posts:35,995
Joined:Apr 29, 2014
Post #96: 7th Mar 2018 11:36 PM 
I completely expected Angela to be voted out for being too close to Chris, which would have sucked because she wasn't going to go with his plan anyway. I'm glad Malolo blindsided Morgan. It was perfect. She had no idea it was even a possibility. lol

Bradley came off pretty negative at his new beach, but then helped his tribe win immunity. So he balances out.

I hoped Chris would draw the white rock and go to Ghost Island. I'm bummed he didn't get an advantage. Could have helped upon his return to his tribe.

I'm confused about Naviti's plans for moving forward if they had voted out Angela. Chris would have been next, leaving only Domenick, Wendell and Morgan with the four Malolos.
 
   
Christian
User Avatar
Captain Charisma
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,182
Group:Godfather
Posts:35,995
Joined:Apr 29, 2014
Post #97: 7th Mar 2018 11:40 PM 
Did Angela will the legacy advantage to someone during the credits? DVR cut off the ending, just as she started talking about it.
 
   
Outlast
User Avatar
Chemical Plant
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,467
Joined:Jun 6, 2014
Post #98: 7th Mar 2018 11:41 PM 
Not sure I like this move for Libby, you should never vote out somebody that is getting that close to you, I guess it's really early though. Not sure why they didn't just go after Dom, if you think he has the idol, blindside him. I guess you could be nervous he plays it to break the supposed tie, but they didn't show James and them talking about that, so it just comes off like a bad move to me.
naonka : saus:: bill:

   
Christian
User Avatar
Captain Charisma
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,182
Group:Godfather
Posts:35,995
Joined:Apr 29, 2014
Post #99: 8th Mar 2018 12:01 AM 
Christian @ 7/3/2018 23:40
Did Angela will the legacy advantage to someone during the credits? DVR cut off the ending, just as she started talking about it.

She did. I had recorded the show following Survivor as well, and it started with the part that got cut off.
Spoiler+
 
   
Vic
User Avatar
Sole Survivor
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 112
Group:Legend
Posts:7,152
Joined:Aug 16, 2013
Post #100: 8th Mar 2018 3:01 AM 
Wasn't expecting that result at all. I think it was too early though. They should've all just voted out Angela and then Chris. They'd still have the numbers and not have as many people coming for them rather than wanting to work with them

This is something I would've done in an ORG so that's how I know it's dumb
 
   
Bryce
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 100
Group:Legend
Posts:8,748
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #101: 13th Mar 2018 11:05 AM 
Shadow @ 7/3/2018 21:58
I’m stunned


My jaw dropped when I saw that Morgan vote. Devastated really. I was really wanting her to go deep. I usually don't enjoy too many female players overall, but I was really liking her.

James' play was so good though. He surprised me this episode. But I agree with Jake that it was weird James believed Dom was voting Angela but also didn't want to vote him in case he played the idol.

That swap is a tricky spot, honestly. You don't want to go to rocks, but you know when Chris comes back he will be turning on Dom. So what do you do? I think purple was screwed regardless. If they were going to vote someone out, the smartest thing may have been to vote out Dom and try to reel Chris and Angela back in against the Mololo.

But it's like no matter who you target, Morgan/Wendell/Dom were in a bad spot. Chris going to GI really screwed them.
 
   
Bryce
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 100
Group:Legend
Posts:8,748
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #102: 13th Mar 2018 11:07 AM 
Also, I hate that production does this separate baskets and choice of split for the game. They want it to be 5-4. Maybe for closer numbers? But I loved when the minority tribe would randomly get numbers on a new tribe and then still screw it up

It's almost like the minority tribe gets punished harder in the swap unless they can make something happen. I don't know. It bugs me they don't let it happen naturally.
 
   
Bryce
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 100
Group:Legend
Posts:8,748
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #103: 13th Mar 2018 11:22 AM 
NuNaviti - more people I like on here, I think. The new purple tribe has a lot of underedited people so it's hard to know who they are right now.

Morgan > Libby - Libby is ok. She seems smart enough and this episode has me a bit higher on her, but I really, really liked Morgan. Shocked she didn't anticipate this. She seemed a little over the top happy this episode though, but other than that, I thought she could have been a really great player.

Wendell > Domenick - Honestly, Wendell has been pretty non-existent. You can tell he's a calm and collected dude though, but I don't think he's as game savvy as I felt he would be going in. I still like him more than Dom though. Dom is an idiot.


James > Donathan - 100%. Don was not a part of this episode at all which I thought was odd. But he clearly has no strategic chops. This was James' episode and he surprised me a bit. I didn't think he had that in him.

Angela > Chris - Tough because I don't enjoy either. But I felt for Angela this episode. This reminds me of something I would do where I would decide to stick with my tribe but they would all plot to get rid of me and I would have no idea. Sad to say, but I'm sure it's happened before. Chris is the douchey dude I would be immediately off put by if we were playing the game together.

Kellyn > Des - I expected Des to be a bigger personality. It's ok she's sitting back though because she's been winning, but I don't know anything about her. Kellyn was a little too bold and forward in her strategy this episode. That isn't a great way to play the game, as if you're untouchable and on top, but she seems smart enough and she's been great in challenges which is good. She was a pre-game favorite.

Stephanie > Jenna - Jenna is sweet, but she's been more back seat. I think she'll be a bit more prominent in the future, but for now Steph is front and center as the female strategist this season. She's kinda annoying, but I'm enjoying her anyway.

Brendan > Michael - Both are boring, but Brendan has surprised me with reads so far. Michael is just there. Bummed he found the idol, but oh well.

Bradley > Seb - Even though Bradley was super whiney this episode (wonder why they showed us that so much), I still think Bradley is a player and Seb is just dumb. I'm not a Seb fan and I think Bradley has a lot to offer the game.

Laurel > Chelsea - Either or, but I think Laurel looked a lot more promising pre-game. I think I'm just relieved to know edit wise that at this point, no chance for a Chelsea win.

Good move - I honestly don't know. I think it was a good move to have full power. Chris and Angela will stick with Mololo moving forward which I think in the long run is great for future swap or merge. Bad move getting Morgan instead of Dom though. That made no sense. It would have been AMAZING to see Dom go here. But the Chris/Dom feud will continue to be fun, though I feel like it will result in Chris going instead of Dom next episode.
 
   
4 Users Viewing (4 Guests)
  Survivor  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service