Timmah @ 3/1/2018 13:43

hiding shouldn't work like investigations when it come to the gf, but that would be up to the mods I suppose.

For now, I am leaning this way as well as a hider risks getting two people killed if he breadcrumbs who he is hiding behind and scum picks up on it and breadcrumbing would be the only way for us to know who a hider hid behind (i.e. lamps) after a night in which the hider died.

Even days suck. Getting caught up now.

you know i had forgotten that Bryce was still alive. also what have i done that has me listed on both scum teams?

also i will own up to trying to visit Timmah last night. but my action was unsuccessful, which is why i said i thought something was off with him. do we know if you are told you are blocked specifically if you are blocked? i thought i remembered someone saying they were blocked, and i kind of remember someone saying they were unsuccessful when they tried to visit Christian. but with hider and commuter dead idk what would make me unsuccessful in visiting Christian.

DsssssssS @ 2/1/2018 21:53

##lynch herm

I actually like this move. I'm not a fan of Herm hammering D5 with so much time left on the clock. I'm not a fan of being allowed to self-vote (since I think it violates the Play to Win clause), but someone here at FE explained to me a long time ago why it is advantageous for Mafia to self-vote when they are obvious caught scum. For Mafia, when scum is caught, the sooner the day ends, the less of a chance there is for other Mafia to get caught. So it makes sense for TIB to self-vote. There was some interesting discussions happening at the end of D5 with people discussing TIB's "DS and Herm are Kids Table" outburst. While DS reacted the way you'd expect someone to react if TIB was full of shit, Herm posted two meme-ish pictures, then hammered. Basically, he no-sold that shit. Was it to make sure nobody had anything to go on related to him and his alignment? I think so.

Gonna see if anyone else brings this up/Herm justifies his actions post-TIB before voting, but yeah...not a fan.

Herm @ 2/1/2018 22:10

I rather get lynched than daykilled if someone's got that up their sleeve today, will claim if necessary.

Interesting. Any particular reason?

I don't think I ever self-voted.

Helios

I rather get lynched than daykilled if someone's got that up their sleeve today, will claim if necessary. Interesting. Any particular reason?

Yes.

So is this the second person that tried to visit Timmah and couldn't? Didn't DS try to investigate him N1 and was supposedly role blocked?

Snowflake poker @ 2/1/2018 22:28

DsssssssS @ 2/1/2018 22:27 Snowflake poker @ 2/1/2018 19:24 DsssssssS @ 2/1/2018 22:21 Snowflake poker @ 2/1/2018 19:12 DsssssssS @ 2/1/2018 22:07 Farlig, any info today? Forgive me, but I still don’t trust you and there is still a no feeding the animals sign present. So you've got a passive role then or How far do you live from the bay? If you count the Golden gate bridge as the western most part of the bay then like 5 miles Take a fishing pole and leave now. I have a role. It hasn’t produced anything helpful yet. That is all you need to know at this time.

I just wanted to point out that this Farlig's shutdown of DS' rolefishing was hilarious.

Regarding hammering D5:

Herm @ 3/1/2018 19:29

Oh right, no one was saying anything/and if they did they seemed to complain about the 48 hour day taking so long. The way I understood the situation, people wanted the day to end.

Never mind, I read that post wrong and confused me with TIB.

Spin @ 2/1/2018 23:21

I'm obviously Town Miller. Stop trying to make me something else. DS, you could very easily be Kids In-Law Cop, trying to find your opponent. It's not out of the realm of possibility.

I thought you were "Town Miller Searching for Someone"?

Snowflake poker @ 3/1/2018 15:33

So is this the second person that tried to visit Timmah and couldn't? Didn't DS try to investigate him N1 and was supposedly role blocked?

here DS' 24th post of day 2 http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=6559&postsby=2283#379000

and his 47th http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=6559&postsby=2283#379365

yeah it was Timmah, idk why i remembered it as Christian other then it making sense to be unsuccessful trying to visit a hider.

im317

also what have i done that has me listed on both scum teams?

not much tbh.

but the fact that you did visit Timmah last night, at least helps me figure out where you stand in the grand scheme of things a little better.

Snowflake poker @ 3/1/2018 13:00

And im? Funny thing is Bryce asks about Christian hiding behind TIB since TIB flipped godfather. I don't think Christian ever said he hid behind TIB but the same theory could be true about TT if he is the godfather for the other squad depending on how a mod would account for hiding behind someone that is supposed to appear as town to all investigative reports.

Wait, what's this about Christian hiding behind TIB? I thought the working theory was that Christian hid behind TT on Night 1, and died hiding behind Lamps on Night 2.

Also, I think that, for the purposes of a Hider, Mafia is Mafia, regardless of the alignment they scan as.

Bryce asked about the TIB/Christian thing on D4/D5.

Not sure about context.