If miko is mafia, and merc is town, miko came out with info to defend merc for no good reason one day, when a mafia Miko would be much better off having merc lynched.


Plus mafia tracker ahoda clearly stated that his targets were farliq and maddie and neither had night actions, which turned out to be true.

Mercator @ 30/5/2017 23:51

I have a gut feeling Stephen is in the chaos team, not sure if we should be after them or mafia, not sure how much of a threat they are. I highly doubt he is mafia though, I'd say Timmah or Miko are the GF.

But he was on the Spin train. Do you really think that a brand new player is going to intentionally throw away their experienced ally round 1?

I really don't think miko should put everything just yet

BadgerMcBeaver @ 30/5/2017 22:48

thisisbad @ 30/5/2017 23:46 I'd say kiwi is gf and vlady is third party if I had to guess. Do I have to guess? Timmah could definitely be a GF from my perspective at this point. But I could see Kiwi too. I wouldn't be surprised if you were right about Vlady (in which case, I think it's even funnier that a train with only 2 town members were able to lynch a maf at final 17 lol).

I'm trying to keep my promise that I won't claim, but if I were to claim you'd no longer think I am scum based on a few facts that would work together to show that I'm town.

Timmah @ 30/5/2017 21:54

BadgerMcBeaver @ 30/5/2017 22:48 thisisbad @ 30/5/2017 23:46 I'd say kiwi is gf and vlady is third party if I had to guess. Do I have to guess? Timmah could definitely be a GF from my perspective at this point. But I could see Kiwi too. I wouldn't be surprised if you were right about Vlady (in which case, I think it's even funnier that a train with only 2 town members were able to lynch a maf at final 17 lol). I'm trying to keep my promise that I won't claim, but if I were to claim you'd no longer think I am scum based on a few facts that would work together to show that I'm town.

I believe you

BadgerMcBeaver @ 30/5/2017 22:53

Mercator @ 30/5/2017 23:51 I have a gut feeling Stephen is in the chaos team, not sure if we should be after them or mafia, not sure how much of a threat they are. I highly doubt he is mafia though, I'd say Timmah or Miko are the GF. But he was on the Spin train. Do you really think that a brand new player is going to intentionally throw away their experienced ally round 1?

I am 99.9% positive that Stephen is NOT on the chaos team. It would go against everything that gave me my mafia read on him earlier. If he is, I will be quite impressed though.

thisisbad @ 30/5/2017 23:53

If miko is mafia, and merc is town, miko came out with info to defend merc for no good reason one day, when a mafia Miko would be much better off having merc lynched.

I mean, Merc's reads haven't been that accurate this game so he wasn't as risky to keep alive IMO. And it gained Miko a lot of town cred. He hasn't had to face any criticism since then.

I don't think this is the type of play that Miko would normally make, but with a scum board pushing him to do it... IDK?

Timmah @ 30/5/2017 23:54

BadgerMcBeaver @ 30/5/2017 22:48 thisisbad @ 30/5/2017 23:46 I'd say kiwi is gf and vlady is third party if I had to guess. Do I have to guess? Timmah could definitely be a GF from my perspective at this point. But I could see Kiwi too. I wouldn't be surprised if you were right about Vlady (in which case, I think it's even funnier that a train with only 2 town members were able to lynch a maf at final 17 lol). I'm trying to keep my promise that I won't claim, but if I were to claim you'd no longer think I am scum based on a few facts that would work together to show that I'm town.

Don't claim until my vote is on you and I'm pushing for your lynch (even then, it's your choice).

But if you prefer not to claim, realize that I am going to be watching you a little more closely than I would be otherwise. I assume you are prolly doing the same for me since I have also chosen not to claim.

thisisbad @ 30/5/2017 22:53

If miko is mafia, and merc is town, miko came out with info to defend merc for no good reason one day, when a mafia Miko would be much better off having merc lynched. Plus mafia tracker ahoda clearly stated that his targets were farliq and maddie and neither had night actions, which turned out to be true.

Well, you've nearly convinced me that we need to lynch Kiwi...

If Miko is what I think he is, then telling us all of his info before he dies could help those of us still trying to figure this out, figure this out...

BadgerMcBeaver @ 30/5/2017 20:53

Mercator @ 30/5/2017 23:51 I have a gut feeling Stephen is in the chaos team, not sure if we should be after them or mafia, not sure how much of a threat they are. I highly doubt he is mafia though, I'd say Timmah or Miko are the GF. But he was on the Spin train. Do you really think that a brand new player is going to intentionally throw away their experienced ally round 1?

I CBF reading through D1 right now because popcorn, but he probably joined it when it looked like he was going to be lynched anyway?

BadgerMcBeaver @ 30/5/2017 21:56

thisisbad @ 30/5/2017 23:53 If miko is mafia, and merc is town, miko came out with info to defend merc for no good reason one day, when a mafia Miko would be much better off having merc lynched. I mean, Merc's reads haven't been that accurate this game so he wasn't as risky to keep alive IMO. And it gained Miko a lot of town cred. He hasn't had to face any criticism since then. I don't think this is the type of play that Miko would normally make, but with a scum board pushing him to do it... IDK?

I think you ignored the second part of what I posted though

If merc says gf is timmah or miko, good chance its kiwi

(Ummm don't tell merc I was talking about him ok?)

Oh you're right, I totally did. Sorry.

##Unlynch.

But Miko I still wanna know what you saw because we don't have much concrete info here.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 30/5/2017 22:02

Oh you're right, I totally did. Sorry. ##Unlynch. But Miko I still wanna know what you saw because we don't have much concrete info here.

I wasn't trying to be a dick just I do think it's a good argument and if it has holes I'm listening



I'm doing more work for miko than he is sheesh

You and I are like lawyers for Miko and Stephen respectively. XD